5 Costly Coin Collecting Mistakes That Could Make You Miss a Fortune (And How to Avoid Them)

I’ve Seen These Mistakes Over and Over. Here’s How to Avoid the Pitfalls That Trip Up Most Collectors

After decades in numismatics, I’ve watched collectors repeat the same costly errors. Many realize too late they let rare treasures slip away. You don’t have to learn the hard way. Here’s how to spot and sidestep the most common—and expensive—coin collecting mistakes.

Mistake #1: Not Researching Obscure Varieties Before Selling

The Libertad Lesson

I still remember the collector who sold four 1991 Libertads. He didn’t know they were rare Type II specimens—reeded edge, mixed lettering—worth over $1,000 each. Only ~50,000 were minted, versus 1.6 million standard versions. That quick sale cost him $4,000.

Prevention Checklist

• Always check variety guides like Cherrypickers’ Guide
• Search auction results for your coin’s date and mint mark
• Join specialty forums—Libertad Collectors Society or CONECA for errors

Mistake #2: Ignoring Coin Anatomy Basics

An 1876 Seated Half Dollar overdate horror sticks with me. A collector used an AU-55 coin as his “reference” for 15 years. He never noticed it was a premium variety. It happens more than you’d think.

Key Areas to Inspect

1. Date digits: Watch for doubling, repunching, or overdates
2. Mint marks: Check position, style, and doubling
3. Edge types: Reeded or plain edges can mean huge value shifts

Mistake #3: Underestimating “Junk” Coins

That proof set left as a tip? It was a Close AM error worth $250. The takeaway? Never assume common dates are truly common.

Red Flags for Hidden Gems

• Coins with odd coloring—possible toning errors
• Any coin that just “looks different” from others
• Items from estate sales or non-collector sources

Mistake #4: Not Documenting Your Collection

More than one collector told me they spotted errors only after seeing their own coins as screen savers. Without good records, you’re guessing.

Documentation System That Works

“I photograph every coin under 10x magnification before selling. I focus on date and mint mark areas. Those 15 minutes might save me thousands.” —Veteran collector

Mistake #5: Moving Too Fast on “Sure Things”

A VAM hunter turned a $60 coin into $2,000. Then he spent months hunting for more. Patience pays. Rarity often shows itself slowly.

Slow-Down Protocol

• Wait 48 hours before selling any recent purchase
• Get a second opinion from a specialist—many grading services help
• Check multiple price guides—some varieties aren’t listed everywhere

When You’ve Already Made the Mistake: Damage Control

Think you let a rarity slip away? Try this:

1. Contact the buyer fast—some will work with you
2. Research recent sales to learn true market value
3. Offer to buy it back at the updated price
4. If it’s gone, note the details so you don’t miss it next time

The Golden Rule of Collecting

One collector returned a Libertad out of fairness. Integrity matters more than quick cash. The coin community remembers who plays fair—and who doesn’t. Build your reputation as you build your collection.

Stay alert, keep records, and when unsure—slow down. Your next “common” coin could be anything but.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• I Tested Every Strategy to Avoid Selling Rare Coins by Mistake – Here Are the Results – I Tried Every Suggested Solution and Documented What Works, What Doesn’t, and Why I kept hearing about collectors …
• Beginner’s Guide to Avoiding Costly Mistakes When Buying and Selling Rare Coins – Welcome to coin collecting! If you’re just starting out, this beginner’s guide will help you avoid costly mi…
• How to Write and Publish a Technical Book: A Guide from an O’Reilly Author – Writing a technical book changed my career—and it can do the same for you. Here’s my no-fluff guide to writing and…