6 Months of Error Coin Hunting: My Brutally Honest Lessons on What’s Worth Keeping & Selling

Six months ago, I dumped 83 rolls of Lincoln pennies onto my kitchen table – coins I’d saved since childhood. What followed was an education in harsh realities, wishful thinking, and the true meaning of “rare.” Here’s what my blistered thumbs and tired eyes learned about separating treasure from trash.

The Day My Hobby Bit Back

You know that moment when excitement curdles into panic? Mine came when I found a 1939-S cent with what looked like a silver tear across Lincoln’s wheat stalks. Fifteen years of casual collecting evaporated as I fell headfirst into error coin obsession. Let me tell you – the coin world isn’t kind to starry-eyed beginners.

My First Lesson: Trust Nothing

That 1939-S taught me the golden rule: assume damage first, error second. Under my loupe, I spotted what most miss – real lamination errors (like my later 1934-D find) show organic imperfections. Mechanical damage? Look for parallel scratches or jagged edges that scream “pliers, not planchet!”

My 3 AM Education in Error Coins

The Case of the Folded Copper (1934-D vs. 1932-P)

My 1934-D cent had a deformed rim that initially broke my heart. Then I noticed the metal folding like pastry dough – the smoking gun of true lamination. The 1932-P was sneakier, its crack following the curve of “UNUM” like a con artist’s smile. Three hard-won lessons:

• Shadow Play: Tilt coins under a lamp – laminations cast soft shadows, damage throws harsh ones
• Toothpick Truth: Gently trace edges – real errors glide smooth, damage snags like Velcro
• Market Reality: That “rare” lamination? Probably a $15 coin unless it’s slab-worthy

“Here’s the dirty secret no one mentions: Most eBay ‘error’ listings are either damaged coins or camera tricks. I learned this after wasting $47 in listing fees.”

Rainbow Hustle: Chemical Toning vs Metal Secrets

When a 1958 cent glimmered like oil on pavement, I nearly listed it as a rare alloy error. Then I remembered the acetone test: one swipe with a soaked cotton bud. The “rainbow” dissolved into garage cleaner residue. That $5 bottle of acetone saved me from three embarrassing listings.

When Pretty Coins Lie

My worst mistake? A stunning 1952-S with sunset colors… and my thumbprint in the toning. Natural color forms in concentric circles like an agate – mine had splotchy “beauty marks” screaming artificial aging. My survival guide:

• Magnify First: 90% of “toned” coins show residue under 10x power
• Compare Ruthlessly: PCGS CoinFacts became my late-night addiction
• The Gut Check: Would a stranger pay $10 for this at a flea market?

Wake-up call: After examining 12,400 coins, I realized only true museum pieces deserve grading. The rest? Bundle them as “color curiosities” and move on.

eEBay’s Bitter Truths

Selling 47 “special” coins taught me brutal economics:

The Insomniac Collector Test

If no one’s searching for your error at 3 AM, it’s not worth listing solo. My turnaround strategy:

• Strength in Numbers: Group minor errors (“5 Weak Die Varieties” sells better than singles)
• Title Sorcery: “1934-D Wheat Cent Lamination Error? NGC Details?” beats “RARE ERROR!!!”
• Sold Listings Don’t Lie: Search “Lincoln cent error -fake -damage” then filter sold items

“My breaking point? Spending $14.75 to list a ‘rare’ coin that sold for $9.99 after fees. Now I call it the Stupid Tax.”

The Waiting Game Scam

That $150 sale you covet? It probably moldered for 18 months. My time-versus-money breakdown:

The verdict? Unless you’ve found the Holy Grail of coins, time eats profits.

My Six-Month Coin Autopsy

• Coins processed: 12,400 (yes, I counted)
• Actual keepers: 83 (0.67% – worse than lottery odds)
• Total earnings: $1,127.50
• Hours lost: 288 (equal to 36 workdays)
• Real hourly wage: $3.91 (below 1968 minimum wage)

This birthed my Three-Strike Rule for any coin:

1. Can I sell it for 20x face value TODAY?
2. Is it visually striking to non-collectors?
3. Does it advance my personal collection?

Two strikes? Into the “bulk junk” box it goes.

Wisdom Earned Through Failure

1. Magnification Lies: 10x loupes breed false confidence. Sort first with naked eyes
2. The Omelet Test: If it’s not worth burning breakfast over, it’s not special
3. Wood Grain Reality: 9/10 “mint errors” are environmental damage

The Real Treasure Wasn’t Copper

After six months of heartbreaks and rare wins, I found clarity. The $1,127 profit couldn’t compensate for 288 lost hours. But learning to distinguish true rarity from fool’s gold? That’s priceless. If you remember one thing, make it this: Collect for love first, money distant second. The coins that matter will shout their worth – the rest are just metal with stories.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Advanced Error Coin Authentication: Expert Techniques for Identifying Valuable Varieties – Mastering the Art of Error Coin Identification Want to spot valuable errors most collectors miss? After 20 years of hand…
• 7 Insider Secrets About Error and Toned Coins Veteran Collectors Won’t Tell You – The Hidden Reality of Coin Errors and Toning That Most Collectors Never See Let’s get real about what really happe…
• Hidden Code, Hidden Value: How Forensic Tech Expertise in Legacy Systems Can Launch Your Expert Witness Career – When Software Artifacts Become Legal Evidence What happens when aging code becomes the star witness in court? Lawyers in…