8 Advanced Cherry-Picking Techniques That Pros Use to Find Rare Coins in Plain Sight

Want to find rare coins that others overlook? Let me share what I’ve learned after decades of turning overlooked details into big wins.

Whether you’re a serious collector, an investor, or a dealer hunting for inventory, today’s market rewards those who spot what others miss. That $10 coin on your desk? It might actually be worth $3,500—if you notice the doubled die most people don’t. Or the overdate sitting in plain sight.

These eight pro techniques have helped me find value where others see ordinary coins. No hype, just practical methods that work—even in today’s competitive market.

1. Find Hidden Gems in Plain Sight at Grading Services

PCGS, NGC, and ANACS focus on condition, not die varieties. They won’t catch a doubled die unless you tell them to look. That’s your advantage.

How It Works

Graders often accept what’s submitted. Send in a coin with no variety flagged, get back “normal” on the label—even if it’s a prized DDO. I’ve seen Mint State coins with clear doubling return as common dates because no one pointed it out.

Your Action Plan: Work the Population Reports

• Check PCGS CoinFacts and NGC Census for varieties with fewer than 10 in top grades.
• Compare counts between services. If PCGS shows 26 high-grade coins but NGC only 5, something’s off—and you might find it.
• Target coins labeled “No Variety” in PCGS/NGC slabs. They’re your best chance for a breakout.

Quick Population Check (Python Script)

import requests
from bs4 import BeautifulSoup

def check_pcgs_pop(year, denomination, variety=""):
    url = f"https://www.pcgs.com/coinfacts/coin/{year}-{denomination}/{variety}"
    res = requests.get(url)
    soup = BeautifulSoup(res.content, 'html.parser')
    pop_data = soup.find('div', class_='pop-table')
    return pop_data if pop_data else "No data"

# Try it: 1913-S Buffalo Nickel
print(check_pcgs_pop("1913", "S", "Buffalo-Nickel"))

2. Beat the Online Coin Auctions

Raw coins on eBay, GreatCollections, and Stack’s Bowers often hide rare varieties behind simple descriptions. The trick? Know which ones get missed most often.

Pro Tip: Look Past the Toning

Beautiful toning masks die details. That stunning 1934-D Peace Dollar? Under a 10x loupe, you might see strong doubling the seller never noticed. Use side lighting and a 30x loupe to catch what flat photos hide.

Where to Hunt

• eBay “Buy It Now”: Search “1958-D Lincoln Cent” with filters for raw and toned coins.
• GreatCollections: Watch for “uncirculated” lots with blurry TrueView images.
• Local Coin Shops: Ask for common-date junk boxes. My best find? A 1951-S/S Roosevelt Dime—now MS67 at PCGS, pop 1.

3. Spot What Auction Houses Overlook

Volume matters more than detail at big auctions. I found a 1926 TDO FS-101—PCGS’s top grade—for $900 because the catalog missed the doubled die visible in photos.

How to Win

• Download auction images, then zoom 400% to scan for doubling, repunching, or polish lines.
• Focus on coins described by appearance (“beautiful toning”) not technical details.
• Bid on “lottery” lots: “1934-D Peace Dollar, BU” with no mention of variety. You’re betting on what’s not said.

4. Break Out and Upgrade Unattributed Slabs

Here’s a money move: Buy high-grade coins in old ANACS or ICG holders with no variety label, break out the slab, and resubmit with proof. My 1936 Buffalo Nickel was MS65 at ANACS with no details. After documenting its DDO, PCGS graded it MS67FS.

Step-by-Step Breakout

1. Check the holder isn’t CAC-stickered or tied to a registry set.
2. Use a slab opener (available online) to avoid coin damage.
3. Shoot die markers with side lighting (flashlight at 45°).
4. Submit with a cover letter citing the specific variety (like “FS-008.7” for Shield Nickels).
5. Include printouts from shieldnickels.net or VAMworld.com.

5. Hunt “Dead Mints” with Hidden Rarity

Some mints have rare varieties that grading services don’t see often. The 1951-S/S Roosevelt Dime is nearly extinct in PCGS census. But many sit in collections as common coins.

Build Your “Dead Mint” Watchlist

• 1951-S/S Roosevelt Dime (MS67, pop 1)
• 1960-D/D Lincoln Cent (FS-101, pop 3)
• 1972-S/S Eisenhower Dollar (FS-501, pop 0)

Search by mint mark alignment. A shifted S under the main S? That’s your clue.

6. Use Lower-Tier Grading Services to Your Advantage

ICG, ANACS, and PCI often miss varieties. That’s why I love them. ICG once graded my 1926-S Buffalo Nickel “VG8” with a 55/54 overdate—unattributed. Bought for $40. After reattribution, PCGS graded it MS63.

Why This Works

These services use less experienced graders and skip die analysis. They’re also faster and cheaper. Perfect for pre-screening before a PCGS/NGC submission.

7. Mine “Proof Set Junk” for Gold

Dealers break proof sets for bullion or use them as change. I know one who uses 1950s proofs as customer change. These sets often hold rare varieties or high-quality proofs that were never checked.

Your Move

• Buy bulk proof sets labeled “for parts” or “broken sets” on eBay.
• Check each coin for die markers. I found a 1956 Type 1 half dollar with two-sided frosting—now worth $1,200.
• Submit standout proofs to PCGS. They love deep mirror finishes and reward them with higher grades.

8. Build Your Die Marker Reference Library

Pros don’t guess. We document. My database covers key dates: 1955 Lincolns, 1972-1974 Eisenhowers, 1982-P Roosevelts. Each entry has:
– Close-up photos of doubled areas
– Die state (EDS, MDS, LDS)
– Population data
– Price history

Start Your Library

1. Get The Cherrypickers’ Guide to Rare Die Varieties (Fivaz & Stanton).
2. Use a USB digital loupe for 50x die marker photos.
3. Tag images with Die Variety + Mint + Year + Marker Location.
4. Cross-check with Wexler's Silver Dime Varieties or CONECA.

The Truth About Cherry-Picking

This isn’t about luck. It’s about spotting what others don’t. The grading services miss varieties. Dealers overlook details. Auction houses miss visual clues. And markets don’t price these errors—until you do.

These eight techniques—from working population gaps to breaking out slabs and building die databases—are what I use to turn small finds into big wins. Master them, and you won’t just find good deals. You’ll find that one coin that changes your collection.

The best finds aren’t in price guides. They’re in the tiny details hiding in plain sight. First one to notice wins.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• 5 Mistakes Coin Collectors Make When Hunting Cherrypicks (and How to Avoid Them) – I’ve made every one of these mistakes myself. Maybe you have too? Let’s talk about the five most common traps collectors…
• The 5-Minute Guide to Spotting and Cherrypicking High-Value Coin Varieties (That Most Dealers Miss) – Need to solve this fast? Here’s the no-nonsense method I use. You’re at a coin show, scrolling eBay, or brow…
• The Hidden Truth About Cherrypicking Rare Coins That No One Is Talking About – Most people think finding rare coins is pure luck. I’m here to tell you: it’s not. After years of hunting through flea m…