Beware This BS Seller on eBay: My Coin Collector’s Alert

Just the other day, I was browsing eBay for coins and stumbled upon a seller peddling some seriously questionable stuff. It really drove home how careful we need to be in this hobby, so I wanted to share what I found to help you avoid similar traps.

The Sketchy Listings I Uncovered

One listing showed a $5 Gold Indian coin with a glaring “COPY” stamp, yet the description insisted it was minted in Denver and made of “pure gold”. The write-up was slick—loaded with phrases like “historic treasure” and “irresistible charm”—but it felt like robotic nonsense. Then I spotted a damaged dime and cent set priced at $1200. Seriously? That’s pocket change territory! Both items screamed scam, and I couldn’t believe they were even listed.

Why This Matters for Coin Collectors

As collectors, we know authenticity is everything. Here’s why this got under my skin:

• Stamped replicas like “COPY” break eBay’s rules, but unmarked fakes still slip through, making it a minefield
• The seller’s 100% feedback meant nothing with zero sales—a classic bait-and-switch tactic
• False gold claims likely mean it’s just plated, not solid—a massive red flag for metals collectors
• Overblown descriptions distract from missing grading or certification; always demand proof from PCGS or NGC

I reported these listings under eBay’s replica policy, and get this—they claimed no violation. How do you miss “COPY” stamped right on the coin? Makes you wonder if they care more about fees than protecting collectors.

My Practical Tips to Dodge Scams

After this mess, here’s how I protect myself—and what I’d suggest for you:

• Read descriptions like a detective: Buzzwords like “rare” or “uncirculated” often hide flaws—real coins have paperwork
• Inspect photos for stamps: Zoom in on images for “COPY” marks or damage; if it’s not slabbed, walk away
• Report junk listings: Use eBay’s tools even if responses frustrate you—it builds pressure
• Dig into seller history: High feedback means nothing without actual sales; check buyer comments
• Know market prices: A damaged dime isn’t worth $1200; keep a Red Book handy for reality checks

Honestly, we need that old-school “No Bozos” mentality—avoid sellers pushing junk to keep our hobby honest.

Wrapping It Up

This whole ordeal reminded me: stay sharp when collecting. Double-check everything, report shady stuff, and trust your gut. When we look out for each other, we keep this passion real. Happy hunting, folks!