Unpacking the High Prices of Cherrypickers Guides: My Numismatic Investigation
June 20, 2025My Deep Dive into the 1903 Barber Dime: Grading, Damage, and Collector Advice
June 20, 2025
As a fellow coin collector, I’ve watched the counterfeit PCGS slab problem grow from a nagging worry to a full-blown crisis. It hits close to home because these fakes aren’t just threatening our investments—they’re chipping away at the trust that holds our hobby together. Let me share what I’ve learned about spotting these phonies and keeping your collection safe.
Spotting the Fakes: What I Look For
After handling countless slabs, I’ve noticed consistent warning signs in counterfeits. Here’s what makes me pause:
- Label quirks: PCGS only puts “Morgan” on 1921-P Morgan labels—if you spot it elsewhere, that’s a red flag waving at you.
- Logo trouble: Real slabs have a distinct logo at the bottom right corner of the front side. Fakes often botch this or leave it out entirely.
- Barcode blues: Many counterfeit barcodes won’t pull up matching records in PCGS’s database—always worth a quick check.
- Font fumbles: The lettering on fake labels is usually close but never perfect. Look for spacing that feels off or characters that don’t quite match.
When examining coins themselves, I always start with attribution. For Morgans, comparing VAM varieties or hunting for missing details (like the reverse ‘slash’) can expose counterfeits faster than you’d think.
Why This Hurts All of Us
This isn’t just about losing money—it’s changing how we collect. I miss the days when buying a slabbed coin felt safe. Now? Even dealers get fooled sometimes. It’s tough asking newcomers to become overnight experts, and I worry this barrier might scare off fresh faces. We’re at a point where you either learn authentication or stick with dealers you’d trust with your wallet.
From what I’ve seen, the ancient coin market offers a sobering lesson: some fakes will slip through. But knowledge remains our strongest shield against them.
Protecting Your Collection: What Works
Here’s how I safeguard my own collection these days:
- Build your knowledge: Grab a Red Book or study online attribution guides. Time spent with genuine coins pays dividends.
- Compare visually: Side-by-side images with marked differences are gold—they train your eye faster than anything else.
- Verify everything: If a slab’s barcode doesn’t match PCGS records, treat it like a rattlesnake and back away slowly.
- Know your sources: Stick with dealers who’ve earned their reputation. Sketchy online listings that vanish and reappear? Don’t take the bait.
I’ve learned more from mistakes than any book could teach. Ask questions, study hard—paying for knowledge now beats losing thousands on a fake later.
Where Do We Go From Here?
Most counterfeits come from overseas, making it feel like an endless game. But I believe grading services must adopt stronger protections—maybe embedded QR codes or better security features. And we collectors? We need to share what we find and call out fakes when we spot them. Yes, buying slabbed coins feels riskier than ever, but staying sharp keeps the hobby rewarding. Don’t let the forgers win—outsmart them and collect with confidence.
