The Counterfeit PCGS Slab Crisis: My Firsthand Insights on Its Exponential Growth
June 21, 2025My Deep Dive into the 1863 Story & Southworth Token
June 21, 2025
As a lifelong coin collector, I’ve always had a soft spot for the classic Barber dime series. That 1903 Philadelphia issue? It’s been sitting on my desk lately, quietly showing off its beauty while revealing some typical collector challenges. I thought I’d share what I’ve learned about grading these gems, handling surface issues, and practical care tips from my own experiences.
Grading the 1903 Barber Dime
When I first held a 1903 Barber dime, I noticed how subtle details tell its story. Most I’ve seen land between EF (Extremely Fine) and AU (About Uncirculated). Here’s what I look for: if Liberty’s headband along the lower rim shows strong detail, you might have an AU50 candidate. But if the coin lacks that original satiny glow, it often settles around EF45. Want to sharpen your grading eye? Try PCGS Photograde – I’ve spent hours with it and it really helps train your vision.
- Focus on wear points: A crisp headband often means a higher grade
- Watch the luster: Dull surfaces usually signal past handling issues
- Grade first, check later: Compare your assessment with expert opinions to improve
Dealing with Surface Damage
We’ve all seen those pesky green spots haunting Barber dimes. From what I’ve observed, it’s usually PVC residue from old storage holders, not true corrosion. While it’s tempting to intervene, go slow. For surface-level gunk, pure acetone on a Q-tip can help – lightly dab and always rinse the entire coin afterward to avoid tide marks. But here’s the hard truth: if it’s actual corrosion, cleaning will leave damage. When in doubt, consult a pro before touching it.
- Stick to pure acetone – nail polish removers contain additives
- Rinse completely to prevent new residue
- Patience pays: Aggressive rubbing creates new problems
Practical Advice for Collectors
If you’re just starting out, remember we all began somewhere. Storage choices matter most – skip PVC plastics entirely to avoid heartbreak later. Photograde became my best teacher, and sharing coins with fellow collectors refined my judgment more than any book. Treat every coin like the tiny historical artifact it is – clean hands, gentle touches, and respect for its journey through time.
The 1903 Barber dime reminds me why collecting stays fascinating decade after decade. Keep looking closely, ask questions, and may your next find bring that special thrill only collectors understand!
