Counterfeit PCGS Slabs: Why This Problem Is Exploding and How to Fight Back
June 23, 2025My Exploration of the 1863 Story & Southworth Civil War Token
June 23, 2025Barber dimes have always captured my imagination, and I recently spent quality time with a 1903 Philadelphia Mint issue. This little piece of history taught me some practical lessons about grading and preservation that I think fellow collectors will appreciate.
Spotting Philadelphia’s Work
Here’s a quick tip: if you’ve got a 1903 Barber dime without any mint mark, you’re holding a Philadelphia coin. While these are common, they’re still special pieces of history. I always check the reverse first – no ‘O’ or ‘S’ means it’s definitely from Philly, making identification simple even if you’re just starting out.
Reading the Details
Grading this coin requires careful attention. What I’ve observed is that most examples land around EF45 (Extremely Fine) thanks to clear features like Liberty’s headband. Occasionally, when that headband shows exceptional definition along the lower edge, it might approach AU50 (About Uncirculated) territory. But here’s the catch – if the original luster is gone, it usually won’t quite make the jump. Want to sharpen your skills? PCGS Photograde is my go-to resource. Spending time comparing their images really trains your eye.
Caring for Your Coin
Watch out for those bright green spots – they’re usually telltale signs of PVC damage from old plastic holders. If the discoloration is only surface-deep, you might salvage it. I’ve carefully used pure acetone (the real stuff, not nail polish remover!) with a Q-tip on affected areas, followed by a full rinse. But proceed with caution: acetone can’t reverse corrosion, and aggressive rubbing often does more harm than good. When in doubt? Skip the home remedies and consult a professional conservator. And always, always use PVC-free storage – it saves so many headaches down the road.
Collector’s Corner
Here’s what I’ve learned about coins like this Barber dime:
- Don’t underestimate eye appeal – a coin with minor issues can still charm collectors
- Address preservation concerns quickly, especially with PVC damage
- Build your grading confidence gradually with Photograde and discussions with other collectors
- Market-wise, the 1903 Philly dime maintains steady value in circulated grades, but mint-state examples command significant premiums
Parting Thoughts
My time with the 1903 Barber reminded me why I love this hobby – every mark and detail connects us to the past. Keep studying those coins, handle them with respect, and enjoy the hunt. Here’s to your next great find!