My Journey with Die Break and Clash Errors: Insights and Tips
July 13, 2025My Deep Dive into the 1911 ‘Weak D’ $5 Indian Half Eagle Mystery
July 13, 2025As a longtime coin collector, I’ve reached my limit with the flood of fake mint errors clogging up online marketplaces—honestly, it makes me sick. Over the years, I’ve watched what was once a niche corner of the hobby become a playground for scammers. We need to talk about how to fight back without losing the joy of collecting.
The Epidemic of Fake Mint Errors
Absurd listings are everywhere now, from Facebook Marketplace to eBay, all claiming to be rare mint errors. Just the other day, I saw one boasting an “IN COD WE TRUST” error—I had to laugh at that clumsy attempt to mimic “IN GOD WE TRUST.” These aren’t just random bad listings; they’re part of a growing wave where sellers target collectors hungry for unique finds. What really grinds my gears is how these fakes cheapen genuine errors, like my own nickel struck on a cent planchet. It’s properly documented and worth maybe $300. Seeing crooks push worthless coins for hundreds or thousands feels like a slap in the face to all of us.
Why This Scam Culture Is Exploding
From what I’ve seen, this mess boils down to a few things colliding. Error coins got hot after some media buzz, making them desirable. But that spotlight attracted opportunists who don’t know a planchet from a hole in the ground. It’s way too easy now—anyone can slap up a fake listing online for free, unlike the old days when scamming took real effort. Making it worse, I’m spotting more and more AI-written descriptions using canned phrases like “makes a unique addition to any collection” to sound legit. It breaks my heart thinking new collectors might get scared off, worried every deal is rigged.
Practical Advice to Shield Your Collection
After decades in numismatics, I’ve picked up some solid ways to avoid getting burned. Here’s what works for me:
- Dig into the real stuff: Learn what genuine mint errors look like. Grab a copy of the Cherrypickers’ Guide and chat with folks in collector groups. True errors are scarce and have telltale signs, like clear off-center strikes or planchet flaws.
- Get a second opinion: Before you buy, run it by a trusted dealer or send it to PCGS or NGC. I once talked a seller into doing this, and it saved them. Sadly, I’ve also seen fakes still sell for crazy money.
- Look closer at listings: Watch out for bad grammar, vague descriptions, or that obvious AI fluff. If a coin listing shouts “I’m rare coin!” or promises insane riches, run. Stick with sellers offering clear photos and a solid track record.
- Keep prices real: Remember, even good errors like my nickel-on-cent planchet have sensible values. If the price seems like a dream deal, it’s probably a nightmare—just walk away.
My Take on Preserving Our Hobby
As frustrating as it is, I’m not giving up. Coin collecting opens doors to history and art, and we can’t let scammers wreck that. I stay sharp by sticking with trusted sources and swapping stories with fellow collectors. It’s tough, but staying informed and a bit skeptical helps us keep the passion alive. Let’s channel this frustration and protect what we love.