5 Critical Mistakes to Avoid When Grading Rare Coins (And How to Recover from Them)

I’ve seen these mistakes over and over. Here’s how to avoid the pitfalls that trip up most people.

Grading rare coins feels like walking a tightrope without a net. One misstep with that 1922 Peace dollar – from “PR, Unc details altered surfaces” to “PR63 CAC” – shows how fortunes can change overnight. After 15 years in the trenches, I’ve watched collectors make the same avoidable errors. Let me show you how to sidestep these traps (and bounce back if you’ve already fallen in).

Mistake #1: Blindly Trusting the First Grading

Ever heard the phrase “trust but verify”? In coin grading, it should be “trust after verifying.” Even PCGS, the gold standard, misjudged that Peace dollar. Here’s how to protect yourself:

• Get a second opinion – For any coin worth more than your monthly mortgage payment.
• Know your grader’s blind spots – Matte Proof Peace dollars stump even experts.
• Follow the upgrade trail – Check population reports for grading trends on your coin type.

Your Recovery Playbook

Think your coin was undergraded? Try this:

1. Keep every email, receipt, and grading slip (like that savvy Dutch collector did).
2. Break it out of the holder and resubmit during a new grading session.
3. Get that green CAC sticker – it’s like a second opinion from the grading gods.

Mistake #2: Ignoring Market Context

That same Peace dollar jumped from $144K to $190K – but we’ve seen wilder swings. Many collectors miss these crucial factors:

• Timing is everything – Your “junk” coin today might be tomorrow’s treasure.
• Holder prejudice – Some buyers still see the ghost of that old details grade.
• Price guides lie – True rarities create their own markets.

Red Flags You’re Paying Too Much

“I own the single PR67 CAC, and I paid well over the Price Guide… and I was happy to do so.”

This collector gets it. Before opening your wallet:

• Check how many exist (only 14 correctly graded 1907 High Reliefs after decades of mistakes)
• Compare recent auction prices, not just book values
• Watch for upgrade waves – they signal shifting grading standards

Mistake #3: Underestimating Grading Subjectivity

Let’s be real – grading is more art than science. That 1794 Flowing Hair dollar’s identity crisis proves even the experts second-guess themselves. Key takeaways:

• Graders have bad days too – your coin might get a better shake tomorrow.
• Rules change – remember when High Reliefs weren’t considered Specimens?
• “Altered surfaces” can mean anything – always ask for specifics.

Stack the Deck in Your Favor

1. Submit when senior graders are working – experience matters.
2. Include provenance paperwork – history adds credibility.
3. For six-figure coins, demand multiple opinions.

Mistake #4: Failing to Document Grading Disputes

The Peace dollar owner played this perfectly – they demanded specifics about the “altered surfaces” call. Their secret weapon? This simple email:

“Could you find out the exact reason? It only states ‘altered surf,’ but I do not have the real reason.”

Always:

• Ask pointed questions (“Is it PVC damage or tooling?”)
• Get everything in writing – emails are your paper trail
• Build a case showing you’re serious about accuracy

Mistake #5: Letting Emotion Override Strategy

When that Peace dollar got the details grade, panic was an option. Instead, the owner:

• Confirmed it was real (the only thing that truly matters)
• Researched similar upgrades (like that 1796 Draped Bust dime)
• Played the long game – and pocketed $46K extra

Keep Your Cool Under Pressure

1. If it’s genuine, the grade can improve – breathe.
2. Markets fluctuate – sometimes the best move is no move.
3. As one dealer told me: “$48k is nothing to sneeze at” – know when to cash in.

Turn Mistakes Into Windfalls

From Peace dollars to Flowing Hair specimens, grading inconsistencies create opportunities. Avoid these five mistakes and you’ll:

• See grades for what they are – educated guesses
• Build submission histories that improve your results
• Turn setbacks into comebacks
• Profit when others overreact to temporary labels

That Dutch collector’s story proves it – with patience and smart strategy, a “problem” coin can become your biggest win. In this game, the real treasure isn’t in the holder – it’s in knowing how to play it right.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Resolve PCGS Grading Inconsistencies Fast: My Proven 5-Minute Strategy for Rare Coins – Stuck with a frustrating PCGS grade? I’ve been there—nothing stings more than seeing a rare coin graded lower than…
• The Insider’s Guide to PCGS Grading Inconsistencies: Uncovering Hidden Realities Behind Rare Coin Valuations – Ever wonder why two coins that look nearly identical can get wildly different grades? I’ve spent years digging into this…
• I Tested Every PCGS Grading Strategy for Rare Coins: Here’s What Actually Works and What Doesn’t – Introduction I tested every PCGS grading strategy out there for rare coins—and I’m sharing exactly what worked and what …