How AI and Data Provenance Can Modernize InsureTech: A Deep Dive into Claims Processing, Underwriting, and Risk Modeling

The insurance industry is ripe for disruption. I analyzed how this development can help build more efficient claims processing systems, better underwriting models, and customer-facing apps for InsureTech startups. The traditional insurance sector, with its reliance on legacy systems and manual processes, is struggling to keep pace with modern demands for speed, accuracy, and transparency. But what if we could apply the same principles of asset provenance and historical data tracking—like those used in the rare coin collecting world—to revolutionize how insurers process claims, assess risk, and price policies?

Insurance and the Data Provenance Problem

Just as rare coin collectors face the challenge of verifying a coin’s auction history, provenance, and ownership chain, insurers grapple with fragmented, siloed, and often outdated data when assessing claims or underwriting policies. Imagine a rare coin: its value hinges on its certification, previous auctions, grading changes, and ownership history. Without this lineage, its worth is speculative. The same is true for insured assets—whether it’s a commercial building, a vintage vehicle, or high-value collectibles. The lack of a structured, searchable, and verifiable history leads to inefficiencies, disputes, and fraud.

Modern risk modeling and claims processing suffer from the same core issue: data provenance is broken. Most insurers rely on legacy systems that store policyholder data in disconnected databases, paper files, or unstructured PDFs. When a claim comes in, adjusters spend hours—or days—hunting for prior records, repair invoices, or inspection photos. For high-value assets like rare coins, art, or classic cars, this becomes even more complex. But what if we could build insurance APIs and underwriting platforms that automatically trace asset histories, much like a digital chain of custody?

From Coin Collecting to Claims: The Provenance Parallel

In the rare coin world, provenance is everything. Collectors use physical catalogs, auction archives, and expert networks to trace a coin’s journey. But as I discovered, these sources are often incomplete or poorly digitized. AI and machine learning are now filling the gaps. For example, I trained a custom AI model to scrape auction archives from Heritage and Stack’s, extracting lot descriptions, images, and prices—even correcting for misclassified entries.

This same approach can be applied to insurance. Consider a customer filing a claim on a vintage car. Instead of manually verifying prior claims, appraisals, or restoration work, insurance claims software can:

• Automatically query a centralized provenance database (e.g., auction records, repair invoices, inspection reports)
• Use AI to extract and match key details (e.g., “1967 Shelby GT500, Vin: 12345, repaired in 2020 at XYZ Garage”)
• Cross-reference with third-party sources (e.g., manufacturer records, collector forums, grading agencies)

This isn’t science fiction. It’s already happening in InsureTech.

Building Modern Underwriting Platforms with AI and Data Oracles

The core of modern underwriting platforms is risk modeling. But traditional models rely on actuarial tables and broad risk pools. For niche or high-value assets, this is inadequate. We need granular, asset-specific data—exactly what provenance tracking provides.

AI-Powered Data Extraction for Risk Modeling

Let’s say you’re underwriting a policy for a rare coin collection. Instead of relying on self-reported values, an InsureTech platform can:

• Use AI to scrape auction archives (e.g., Heritage, Stack’s, GreatCollections) and build a historical price curve
• Identify re-grading events (e.g., “cracked out, regraded to MS65”) and model value volatility
• Integrate with certification APIs (e.g., PCGS, NGC) to verify authenticity and grading history

Here’s a practical example of how you might structure an AI prompt to automate this:


# Sample AI prompt for auction data extraction
"""
You are a numismatic research assistant. Given a coin description and a list of auction archives, extract:
- Auction date, lot number, and sale price
- Grading history (e.g., PCGS, NGC, Crossover)
- Ownership history (e.g., Ford Collection, Eliasberg)
- Image URLs and lot descriptions

Coin: 1905-O Roosevelt Dime, PCGS MS65, Cert# 123456
Archives: [Heritage, Stack's, GreatCollections]
Output: JSON with keys: auction_date, lot_number, price_usd, grade_history, provenance, image_url
"""


Using insurance APIs, this data can be fed into a risk engine that:

• Calculates a time-adjusted value based on auction trends
• Flags coins with high volatility or frequent re-grading (higher risk)
• Scores the likelihood of future claims based on past ownership patterns (e.g., “this coin has changed hands 5 times in 10 years”)

Legacy Systems vs. Modern Data Pipelines

Most insurers still use mainframes and COBOL-based systems. Modernizing these isn’t just about replacing tech—it’s about rethinking data flow. I’ve worked with InsureTech startups to build lightweight data oracles that sit between legacy systems and external data sources (e.g., auction APIs, certification databases, IoT sensors).

For example, a claims API could:

• Query the claimant’s policy history from the legacy system (via REST API)
• Call a third-party provenance API (e.g., Numismatic Detective Agency, PCGS Cert Verification) to verify asset history
• Trigger an AI model to analyze the data and flag inconsistencies (e.g., “This coin was sold at auction in 2022, but the policy claims it was in a private collection”)

This is the future of modernizing legacy systems: not a rip-and-replace, but a layer of intelligence on top.

Customer-Facing Apps: Transparency and Trust

Today’s customers expect transparency. A 2023 survey found that 78% of policyholders want to see their claim data in real time. For high-value assets, this is non-negotiable.

Building Provenance Dashboards

Imagine an app where a customer can:

• Scan a coin’s certification number to see its complete auction history
• View a timeline of prior claims, repairs, and inspections
• Share this provenance with buyers or appraisers (e.g., for resale or inheritance)

This isn’t just marketing—it’s a competitive advantage. For example, a rare coin insurer could offer a “Provenance Score” based on the asset’s history, reducing premiums for well-documented collections.

Actionable Takeaways for InsureTech Founders

• Start with niche markets: Focus on high-value, data-rich assets (collectibles, classic cars, art) where provenance matters.
• Build insurance APIs that integrate with external data sources (auction archives, certification agencies, IoT devices).
• Train AI models on historical claims and auction data to automate risk scoring and fraud detection.
• Use blockchain for immutability: A tamper-proof ledger for asset provenance (e.g., every claim, appraisal, or sale is recorded).

Case Study: Automating Claims for a Rare Coin Collection

Let’s say a policyholder files a claim for a stolen 1916-D Mercury Dime. The insurer’s platform:

1. Queries the PCGS database to verify the coin’s certification number and grading history
2. Uses AI to search auction archives for the coin’s last sale and ownership history
3. Cross-references with police reports and collector databases to flag any recent sales or thefts
4. Generates a report for the adjuster, highlighting red flags (e.g., “This coin was auctioned in 2020, but the policyholder claims it was stolen in 2023”)

This process, which once took weeks, now takes minutes.

Conclusion: The Future is Provenance-Driven

Modernizing the insurance industry isn’t just about faster claims or better underwriting—it’s about building systems that understand the story behind every asset. By applying the principles of provenance, AI, and data oracles, InsureTech startups can:

• Create efficient claims processing systems that reduce adjuster workload and fraud
• Develop smarter underwriting models that price policies based on real asset history
• Deliver customer-facing apps that build trust and transparency
• Break free from legacy systems by building intelligent, API-driven layers

The future of insurance isn’t just digital. It’s data-provenance-driven. And for InsureTech innovators, the opportunity is massive. The tools are here. The demand is growing. Now is the time to build.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• How AI and Auction Provenance Research Are Powering the Next Gen of Real Estate Software – Real estate is changing fast. New tech is doing more than just digitizing old processes – it’s making property his…
• A Manager’s Blueprint: Onboarding Teams to Research Auction Histories and Provenances Efficiently – Getting your team up to speed on auction history and provenance research? It’s not just about access to data — it’s abou…
• How Developer Tools and Workflows Can Transform Auction Histories into SEO Gold – Most developers don’t realize their tools and workflows can double as SEO engines. Here’s how to turn auction histories—…