The Complete Beginner’s Guide to Cherrypicking Rare Coins: How to Spot Hidden Gems and Outsmart the Market

So you’ve got a few old coins lying around—maybe a jar of silver dollars from your grandpa, or a handful of worn nickels you picked up at a flea market. What if I told you one of them might be worth way more than you think? Not because it’s shiny or rare at first glance, but because of something *hidden*—a tiny detail most people, even seasoned dealers, overlook.

That’s where cherrypicking rare coins comes in. It’s not about luck. It’s about learning how to spot what others miss. And the best part? You don’t need to be a numismatic expert to start. This isn’t just a hobbyist’s secret—it’s a real strategy used by collectors to find overlooked coins that trade for double, triple, or even ten times their listed value.

What Is Cherrypicking in Numismatics?

Cherrypicking means finding coins that are misgraded, misattributed, or undervalued—not because they’re damaged, but because their unique details have been ignored. Think of it like finding a vintage Rolex at a yard sale priced as a “nice watch.”

These overlooked traits can include:

• Mint errors like double strikes or off-center planchets
• Rare die varieties (like overdates or doubled dies)
• Unique toning or luster patterns that boost value
• Repunched mintmarks (RPMs) hidden in plain sight

And here’s the kicker: most of these coins are sitting in plain sight—on dealer counters, in bulk lots, or even sealed in grading slabs—because no one flagged the special details.

Why Cherrypicking Matters

The coin market runs on three things: scarcity, condition, and demand. But here’s what beginners miss: grading and attribution errors are everywhere.

Major grading services like PCGS, NGC, and ANACS do a great job assessing condition (grade), but they don’t automatically scan for rare varieties—unless you specifically ask. That means a coin labeled “1936 Buffalo Nickel MS-64” might actually be a rare doubled die, worth much more. The label doesn’t lie… but it *doesn’t tell the whole story* either.

“Most dealers don’t care or check for varieties. It’s not where the money is—so they don’t bother. That’s your edge.”

The Cherrypicker’s Mindset

Forget “perfect coins.” Real cherrypicking is about finding potential. You’re not shopping for slabs in a case—you’re hunting for clues. Ask yourself:

• Does this coin look “off” in a way that could be valuable?
• Is there doubling in the date or letters?
• Could that weird mark be a die crack or a repunched mintmark?
• Is this toning hiding a rare die state?

It’s detective work. And your magnifying glass is your best tool.

Getting Started: Tools and Resources You Need

You don’t need a lab or a six-figure budget. Just a few simple tools and a curious eye. Here’s what every beginner should have on their desk.

Essential Tools

• 10x loupe: Your new best friend. Use it to spot die cracks, doubling, and mintmark details. Cheap ones under $20 do the job.
• Coin reference books: Start with The Cherrypickers’ Guide to Rare Die Varieties by Bill Fivaz and J.T. Stanton. It’s the collector’s bible for spotting overlooked gems.
• Digital loupe or smartphone macro lens: Snap close-up photos to compare with known varieties. A $15 clip-on lens works great.

<

• Online databases:
  VAMWorld.com (for Morgan/Peace dollars) and
  ShieldNickels.net are free and packed with high-res images.
• Grading guide: Learn the Sheldon scale (Good, Fine, Uncirculated, etc.) and how to spot bag marks, luster, and surface quality. It’s not about perfection—it’s about potential.

Where to Look for Cherrypicks

Skip the big auctions and eBay’s “Buy It Now” listings. The real finds are where less attention is paid:

• Local coin shops: Many dealers focus on bullion or generic silver—rare varieties often slip through.
• Coin shows and club auctions: Bring your loupe. Ask to flip through raw coin trays. You’ll often find gems priced as “common.”
• Online auction sites (Great Collections, Heritage): Search for “raw” or “ungraded” coins with clear photos. Watch for toning, doubling, or odd mintmarks.
• Bulk lots and estate sales: Buy a bag of “common” nickels or cents. Five bucks could buy a $200 coin.

Understanding Die Varieties: The Core of Cherrypicking

The biggest wins in cherrypicking come from die varieties—coins made with unique dies that create distinct, traceable differences. These aren’t mistakes. They’re historical fingerprints.

Key Varieties to Know (and Hunt For)

1. Doubled Die Obverse (DDO) / Doubled Die Reverse (DDR)

When the die is misaligned during production, parts of the design appear doubled. The 1955 Lincoln Cent DDO is famous, but lesser-known ones—like the 1936 Buffalo Nickel—are hiding in collections everywhere.

How to spot it: Use your loupe. Look at letters, dates, and shield lines. If they seem blurred, stacked, or slightly offset, you might have a DDO. The 1873 Shield Nickel with a “monster DDO” shows clear doubling in the shield—easy to miss, but worth big.

2. Overdates (OVDs)

Older dies were often re-engraved with a new year. The 1855/54 half dollar (WB-1) is a classic example—often sold as “just another 1855.”

Red flag: If the date looks smeared or uneven, zoom in. Compare it to a known overdate image.

3. Re-punched Mintmarks (RPMs)

When the mintmark is punched in more than once, it creates a visible “doubling” of the letter. The 1951-S/S Jefferson Nickel is a perfect example—only one has been graded MS67 by PCGS.

Pro tip: Use VAMWorld to look up the “tail of the S.” You’ll see the extra S below the main one.

4. Missing or Extra Legs (e.g., 3.5-Legged Buffalo Nickel)

Die deterioration or doubling can make part of the buffalo’s leg disappear. The 1913 Type 1 Buffalo Nickel with a 3.5-leg is a well-known—and valuable—example.

Why Grading Services Miss These

Grading companies don’t search for varieties unless you ask. They focus on condition, not attribution. If your coin is labeled “1936 Buffalo Nickel MS-64,” but has a DDO, they won’t flag it—unless you request “variety attribution” when submitting.

One collector shared: “I had a slabbed coin for years. When I finally asked for attribution, it came back with a ‘DDO’ designation—and the value jumped from $60 to $300.”

Common Misconceptions (And How to Avoid Them)

Misconception #1: “Only Experts Can Cherrypick”

Truth: You don’t need a PhD. Start with one series—Buffalo Nickels, Franklin Halves, or Lincoln Cents. Learn 5–10 key varieties. Master them. Then grow.

Misconception #2: “Cherrypicks Are Always Raw Coins”

Truth: Slabbed coins can be cherrypicks too! A coin graded “MS65” without “FS” (Full Steps) or “DDO” might qualify for a much higher grade with proper attribution. One collector broke out a slab, resubmitted with a photo and VAM reference—and turned a $60 coin into an MS67FS worth over $1,000.

Misconception #3: “Toning Is Always a Good Thing”

Truth: Rainbow toning can add value, but dark, mottled, or spotty toning can hide doubling or overdates. Always examine the metal beneath—use your loupe, not just your eyes.

Misconception #4: “All Varieties Are Valuable”

Truth: Some are rare but not in demand. Check population reports (PCGS/NGC) before buying. A variety with only 15 known examples is worth more than one with 200+.

Actionable Steps to Start Cherrypicking Today

No fluff. Just real steps you can take this week:

1. Pick one series (e.g., Shield Nickels, Buffalo Nickels, or Lincoln Cents).
2. Study 5–10 known varieties in that series (use VAMWorld or the Cherrypickers’ Guide).
3. Visit 2–3 local coin shops and ask to look through raw coin trays.
4. Set an eBay alert for “raw [your series] coin” + “toned” or “ungraded”.
5. Take close-up photos of anything that looks odd—then compare to reference images.
6. Submit to PCGS/NGC with attribution request if you find a likely match.

Pro Tip: The “Breakout and Resubmit” Strategy

If you find a high-potential coin in an old slab (especially ANACS or ICG), consider breaking it out and resubmitting to PCGS or NGC. Include:

• High-res photos of the variety
• VAM number or Cherrypickers’ Guide reference
• Request for “Variety Attribution”

Yes, it costs a bit. But the payoff can be huge.

Real-World Cherrypick Examples (And What You Can Learn)

• 1936 Buffalo Nickel DDO: Bought for $48, graded MS64, no attribution. Could be worth $200+ with proper designation.
• 1951-S/S Nickel: Found by checking the “tail of S.” Only one known at MS67—bought raw, now a Top Pop.
• 1867 Shield Nickel with Rays (FS-301): Unattributed AU55 coin worth $3,000. Missed because the dealer didn’t know the variety existed.
• 1956 Type 1 Franklin Half (Frosted Device): Found at a local show. Frosted devices are rare on Type 1s—another attribution opportunity.

Your Edge Is Knowledge, Not Luck

There’s no magic trick to cherrypicking. No “secret formula.” Just this: look closer than everyone else.

Most dealers skip the details. Grading services wait for you to ask. Bulk lots get mass-priced. That’s your opening.

Remember:

• Dealers focus on bullion, not varieties. That’s your advantage.
• Grading services won’t find them for you—you have to point them out.
• Start small. Pick one series. Learn it cold. Then expand.
• Keep your loupe handy. Always ask: “Could there be more here?”

The next $500 coin might be sitting in a $5 bag at your local show—waiting for someone with the right eye. And now? That someone is you.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Why Your Best Cherrypick of 2025 Is a Strategic Masterclass in Numismatic Edge – I cracked this open after months of chasing “sleepers” at shows and online auctions—and what I found changed…
• How ‘Cherry Picking Fake Bin’ Findings Shape M&A Tech Due Diligence Outcomes – When one tech company acquires another, technical due diligence makes the difference between a smart investment and a co…
• A CTO’s Perspective: Strategic Implications of ‘Cherry Picking Our Own Fake Bin’ in Technology Roadmaps – As a CTO, I spend my days making tough calls about technology. It’s not just about picking the latest tools. It&#8…