My 6-Month Gold Selling Experiment: Why I Chose Eagles Over Saints and What It Taught Me About Investment Strategy

I’ve been wrestling with this exact gold-selling dilemma for half a year now. Looking back, there are a few things I wish I’d understood sooner—so I’m sharing my real experience here.

The Initial Dilemma: Eagles vs. Saints

Six months ago, I stood at a crossroads. On one side: 10 gleaming 1 oz Gold American Eagles. On the other: 10 MS63 1924 Saint-Gaudens Double Eagles. Both were valuable, but I needed to sell one set to free up cash.

At first, I figured I’d just pick whichever was worth more. But it wasn’t that simple. I ended up learning a lot about coins, investing, and what really matters when you need money now.

Why I Almost Went With the Saints

Those Saints are stunning. Over 100 years old, graded, and rich with history. They felt special—like holding pieces of the past.

Part of me wanted to keep them, thinking their collector value might grow. But after some digging, I realized most Saints like mine don’t carry a big numismatic premium unless they’re truly rare or flawless.

The Practical Appeal of the Eagles

The Eagles, though? They’re simple, modern, and easy to sell. Each contains exactly one ounce of gold, so their price tracks closely with the spot market.

If you need quick cash with minimal fuss, Eagles are hard to beat. But I still wondered—was I giving up future gains by letting the Saints go?

What I Did and Why

After a lot of back-and-forth, I sold the Eagles. Here’s why: I needed liquidity, fast.

Gold prices were climbing, and I didn’t want to wait. The Eagles sold in just a few days, with low fees and no hassle. The Saints would’ve taken longer—finding the right buyer isn’t always quick.

The Immediate Results

Selling the Eagles was smooth. I got a fair price based on the gold market, and the cash hit my account quickly. No surprises.

Could I have made more with the Saints? Maybe. But not without extra time and effort—which I couldn’t spare.

Long-Term Perspective: Did I Regret It?

Months later, no regrets. Gold kept rising, but so did the value of my remaining Eagles. The Saints’ premium didn’t jump like I’d wondered.

If I’d held onto the Saints, I might still be waiting for the perfect buyer. Sometimes, simple is better.

Lessons Learned

This whole experiment taught me a few things about investing in gold:

• Liquidity Over Potential Premiums: If you’re not a serious collector, bullion coins like Eagles are easier to sell when you need to.
• Market Timing Matters: Selling when gold prices were rising helped me get more, no matter which coins I chose.
• Diversify Even in Sales: Next time, I might sell half of each—just to balance quick cash and future potential.

Actionable Takeaways for You

If you’re weighing Eagles vs. Saints yourself, here’s what I’d suggest:

• Ask how soon you need the money. In a hurry? Go with Eagles.
• Check recent sales for Saints like yours. Is the extra value worth the wait?
• Consider selling a mix. You don’t have to go all in on one type.

Real Results and Final Thoughts

Selling the Eagles gave me the cash I needed, no complications. I still have the Saints—they’re a longer-term hold now.

I learned that not every investment has to be optimized to the last dollar. Sometimes, good enough is perfect.

Conclusion

Your best choice depends on your situation. Need reliability and speed? Eagles are fantastic. Love history and don’t mind waiting? Saints could be worth it.

I hope my six-month experiment helps you skip some of the uncertainty I felt. Happy investing!

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• 5 Critical Mistakes Everyone Makes When Selling Gold Coins (And How to Avoid Them) – I’ve watched these same errors play out time and again. Let me help you steer clear of the traps that catch so man…
• Sell Your Gold Eagles or Pre-1933 Coins in Under 5 Minutes: The Fast, Efficient Method That Actually Works – Need to sell your Gold Eagles or pre-1933 coins right now? I’ve been there – staring at my collection, wonde…
• The Insider’s Guide to Selling Gold: Why Your Choice Between Eagles and Pre-1933s Could Cost You Thousands – Let me let you in on a little secret most gold sellers never discover until it’s too late. After two decades in th…