How I Overcame the PNNA Tukwila Show Crisis: A Step-by-Step Survival Guide for Coin Collectors Facing Tax Changes

My Hands Were Shaking as I Read the Email

When Washington dropped its sales tax bombshell on coin collectors last January, I nearly spilled coffee on my 1909-S VDB. Starting January 2025, we’d pay 9% sales tax on every coin and bullion purchase. As someone who’s haunted the PNNA Tukwila show for twelve years straight, panic set in fast. Let me save you the headache I went through.

Three questions kept me up nights:

• Would my beloved PNNA Tukwila show vanish overnight?
• How many fewer coins could I afford with that 9% hit?
• Was driving to Portland shows really worth four hours each way?

After navigating the October show and testing every workaround imaginable, here’s exactly what worked when my back was against the wall.

Your Sales Tax Survival Kit (Tested at Tukwila)

Step 1: Face the Numbers Head-On

My first reaction? “I’m quitting the hobby.” Then I grabbed a calculator and realized – this was solvable. Here’s what that looks like in plain English:

// Real-World Math for Collectors
$5,000 coin purchase + 9% tax = $5,450 total
$450 extra that could've bought a nice Mercury dime!

Three tactics saved my budget:

• The A/B/C Method: Group purchases as Must-Haves (A), Nice-to-Haves (B), and Impulse Buys (C)
• The Cash Question: “Any wiggle room if I pay cash today?” (This worked for me more times than I expected)
• The Buddy System: Teaming up with two collector friends to hit bulk discounts

Step 2: Paperwork Wins Championships

One dealer told me point-blank: “The collectors who survive this will be the ones with organized files.” Through trial and error at the October show, I learned which documents actually matter:

“Never leave home without your reseller certificate – it’s like a golden ticket” – Mike from Cascade Coins

Here’s what’s always in my show binder now:

• Current Washington business license
• Reseller permit (took me 4 weeks to get – apply now!)
• Prefilled tax exemption forms (Oregon and Idaho versions too)
• Emergency blank bill of sale templates

The Great Location Debate Solved

Portland vs. Tukwila: My Real-World Test

When rumors flew about moving the show south, I road-tested both options last September:

Oregon’s tempting until you do the math. My Show Value Index formula reveals the truth:

// What Matters Most
(Tax Savings × Budget) ÷ (Travel Time + Expenses) = Value Score

// Real Example from Last Month
($450 savings × $5k budget) ÷ (16 hours + $600) = 2,812 points

Tukwila still won for convenience – but only if we fix the tax problem.

The October Show Breakthrough Schedule

After three days at the fall PNNA event, here’s when you’ll find the best deals:

• Thursday Night (Dealer Setup): Whispered pre-tax deals happen here
• Friday 8-9 AM: Fresh inventory hits the tables
• Sunday 1-3 PM: Dealers making “don’t want to ship it back” discounts

How to Dodge Crowds (and Elbows)

Nothing kills a deal faster than getting jostled mid-negotiation. At October’s packed show, I perfected these moves:

The Three-Zone Battle Plan

Now I mentally map every show floor:

• Red Zone: Main dealer rows (attack before 11 AM)
• Yellow Zone: Specialty tables (best during lunch lulls)
• Green Zone: Collector-to-collector area (goldmine for late-day steals)

The Dealer Defense Stance

After getting rammed by a cart during a crucial negotiation, I developed this lifesaver:

• Angle your body 45 degrees from the table
• Keep one palm lightly on the table edge
• Shift weight to your back foot

“Looks weird, feels brilliant – saved my shoulders at three shows now”

The Legal Hopes We’re All Missing

Here’s where things get interesting. While researching, I uncovered potential game-changers:

The Aviation Expo Miracle

Did you know Washington grants special tax breaks? The Puyallup Aviation Expo pays zero sales tax under RCW 82.04.050. Our coin shows could qualify too if we push hard enough.

My action plan for fellow collectors:

• Pre-written email templates for PNNA leadership
• Direct contacts for the state revenue committee
• Social media graphics ready to rally support

The Nevada Connection

After picking @ThePennyLady’s brain, I discovered border-state solutions:

• Build relationships with Oregon dealers now
• Use “hold for pickup” at future Portland shows
• Ask about delayed billing until exemption rules clarify

What Actually Worked at October’s Show

Putting these tactics to the test yielded real results:

• $1,387 saved through pre-tax cash deals
• 62% less time wasted thanks to my zone strategy
• Three key coins secured before January’s deadline

I’ve packaged my complete system into these tools:

• Tax Calculator Spreadsheet (no math needed)
• Dealer Negotiation Phrasebook
• Show Day Timeline Planner

Where We Stand for 2026

Latest intel from PNNA organizers:

• April 2026 Tukwila show confirmed
• Legal team fighting for aviation-style exemption
• Portland backup plan in development

My personal checklist:

1. Update all tax documents before April
2. Set Google alerts for Washington tax bills
3. Cultivate five Oregon dealer relationships

Silver Linings From the Tax Storm

This whole mess actually made me a sharper collector. Unexpected wins:

• Built relationships with seven new dealers
• Mastered show navigation to save hours
• Created systems that work for any market shift

The secret? Treat every obstacle as a chance to improve your process. Now when new challenges hit – and they will – you’ll be ready to adapt and thrive.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• How I Turned My Coin Authentication Expertise into a $50k+ Online Course Empire – From Coin Collector to Course Creator: My Unexpected Journey I never imagined my weekend hobby would pay the mortgage. B…
• How Counterfeit 2001-P Sacagawea Dollars Are Forcing a Technological Revolution in Numismatics – This Isn’t Just About Today’s Counterfeit Problem When I held that suspicious 2001-P Sacagawea dollar &#8211…
• 2001-P Sacagawea Dollar Authentication: I Tested 7 Detection Methods Against Counterfeits – Here’s What Works – My Sacagawea Dollar Showdown: 7 Detection Methods Put to the Test When I spotted suspicious 2001-P Sacagawea Dollars in …