How I Tracked Down and Acquired the Rarest 1878-CC Chopmarked Trade Dollar: A Collector’s Step-by-Step Journey

The Collector’s Holy Grail: My Hunt for the Elusive 1878-CC Chopmarked Trade Dollar

Picture this: You’re scrolling through auction listings when an 1878-CC Trade Dollar catches your eye. But not just any specimen – one with authentic Chinese chopmarks. Your hands shake as you realize this might be one of only twelve known examples. I know that thrill firsthand.

After years of searching (and countless late nights researching), I finally added this numismatic unicorn to my collection. Here’s exactly how I did it – the hard-won lessons, near misses, and ultimate victory in tracking down America’s rarest chopmarked silver dollar.

Why This Coin Is a Needle in a Haystack

The Numbers Don’t Lie

When I started collecting chopmarked Trade Dollars, I didn’t understand why seasoned dealers would pale at the mention of an 1878-CC. Then I crunched the numbers:

• Original Mintage: 97,000 coins struck at Carson City
• Melted by Government: Nearly half destroyed under the Bland-Allison Act
• Circulated Examples: Just 53,000 made it to China for commerce
• Known Survivors: Maybe 500 total coins remain worldwide
• Chopmarked Specimens: Only about a dozen confirmed by experts

The Shocking Grading Census

After months of research, I compiled what might be the most complete grading census available:

PCGS MS62 – unknown variety
PCGS AU58 – C-3
PCGS AU55 – C-3
PCGS XF45 – C-3
PCGS XF40 – C-4
PCGS XF40 – unknown variety
NGC XF40 Details – C-4
PCGS VF35 – C-1
PCGS VF35 – C-3

Nine certified examples. That’s it. And some varieties still hadn’t surfaced when I began my search.

How I Finally Landed My White Whale

Step 1: Becoming an Auction Ninja

The last public auction was in 2017 – six years before my find. Here’s what I did differently from casual collectors:

• Set up custom alerts on every major auction platform
• Built trust with specialized dealers who might get first dibs
• Attended every major coin show within 500 miles
• Tracked price trends religiously (Heritage Auctions was my go-to)

Step 2: Spotting Fakes Like a Pro

With so few genuine examples, counterfeits abound. My authentication process became second nature:

• Silver Content Check: Every gram matters with these
• Die Study: Matching to known VAM varieties
• Chopmark Expertise: Learning which symbols were period-correct
• Surface Analysis: The patina tells the truth

Step 3: Cracking the Grading Code

Early PCGS holders labeled chopmarked coins as damaged. I learned to:

• Recognize transitional holders from 2003-2006
• Write detailed provenance letters for raw submissions
• Request specific graders who understood Trade Dollars
• Accept that “details” grades were often the reality

Step 4: Building Collector Intel

Through discreet conversations, I discovered:

• Six current owners (most weren’t selling)
• Three coins locked up in estates
• Two potential European holdings
• Critical die variety details from shared images

Step 5: Seizing the Moment

When my chance finally came, I was ready:

1. Had funds pre-cleared with the auction house
2. Arranged for immediate expert inspection
3. Set a firm max bid based on rarity
4. Placed my winning bid in the final seconds

Preserving a Piece of History

The Grading Process

For my raw acquisition, I used this submission approach:


Submission Form Details:
- Service Level: Regular
- Designation: Chopmark Attribution
- Special Instructions: "Compare to 1878-CC Census C-1/C-3"
- Value Declaration: $18,500


The result? PCGS AU Details (Cleaned) with proper variety attribution – a triumph after so much effort.

Long-Term Care

• Custom capsule with tarnish prevention
• Bank vault storage with humidity control
• Regular high-res photography
• Annual insurance updates

What This Hunt Taught Me

As another collector once told me:

“Building a chopmarked set means embracing coins that might not be pretty, but scream history.”

Before chasing your own white whale, ask:

• How many have come to market in the last decade?
• Will another surface in my collecting lifetime?
• Does this complete a meaningful collection goal?

My 1878-CC journey changed how I collect. I learned that:

1. Patience beats perfect timing every time
2. Fellow collectors are your best resource
3. Grading is fluid – adapt your expectations
4. Every rare find inspires the next generation

As my mentor told me: “The rarest coins aren’t stumbled upon – they’re earned through relentless preparation meeting that one fleeting opportunity.” May your collecting journey be as rewarding as mine continues to be.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• How Counterfeit Coin Analysis Reveals Critical SEO & Digital Marketing Blind Spots – Ever wonder why some websites seem to rank higher despite similar content? The answer often lies in technical details mo…
• The Ultimate Beginner’s Guide to Collecting Pattern Coins: From Fundamentals to First Acquisitions – Welcome to the world of pattern coins! If you’re just starting out, this guide will walk you through everything yo…
• The Hidden Risks of Stuck Code: How Thermal Expansion in Legacy Systems Reveals Tech Debt During M&A Due Diligence – When one tech company acquires another, a deep technical audit is required. I’ll explain why a target company&#821…