Beginner’s Guide to Modern MS68 Coins: When to Buy & Avoid Common Pitfalls

Welcome to the world of coin collecting! This beginner’s guide will help you understand modern MS68 coins without overwhelm.

If you’re just starting out with coin collecting, MS68-graded modern coins might seem confusing. Are they hidden treasures or overpriced placeholders? After handling thousands of coins and guiding new collectors, I’ve discovered clear patterns that make these coins easier to understand. I’ll share exactly when these coins are worth your attention – and when to walk away.

Understanding the Grading Scale: Where MS68 Fits

The Simple Sheldon Scale Breakdown

Think of the 70-point scale as a report card for coins:

• MS60-63: Noticeable scratches and wear
• MS64-65: Typical uncirculated condition
• MS66-67: Better than average quality
• MS68: Nearly perfect with tiny flaws
• MS69-70: Superstar quality

Why MS68 Causes Confusion

Modern coins (minted after 1965) often get high grades, creating a crowded middle ground. While MS70 coins grab headlines and MS69s offer affordable quality, MS68 coins sit in an awkward spot – too nice for silver stackers, but not quite perfect enough for serious collectors.

3 Smart Times to Buy MS68 Modern Coins

1. When Rarity Trumps Perfection

Some modern coins are scarce in any high grade. Take the 1995-W Silver Eagle – only 30,125 were made. Even in MS68, it sells for $4,000+. Watch for:

• Limited mintage (<50,000)
• Low population reports (<100 graded)
• Important first-year issues

Pro tip: Always check recent auction prices on PCGS CoinFacts before buying.

2. When Beauty Beats the Grade

I’ll never forget the MS68 2005-S Silver Eagle I found with rainbow toning like a shimmering oil slick – it sold for 15x normal price. Look for coins with:

• Natural rainbow colors
• Even, attractive toning
• Clean surfaces without spots

3. When You Want More Coin for Your Money

Building a type set? MS68 modern coins often cost barely more than raw coins. Imagine getting a guaranteed authentic $20 silver eagle for nearly melt value! Try this approach:

1. Pick key modern designs you need
2. Set alerts for prices just above melt
3. Stick to PCGS/NGC slabs for easy resale

4 Common Beginner Errors (And How to Avoid Them)

Error 1: Skipping Population Checks

That 2023 Kennedy Half in MS68 might seem special – until you see 8,742 others just like it. Here’s how to check:


Quick Population Check:
1. Visit pcgs.com/pop
2. Choose series/year/mint
3. Filter for MS68
4. Compare to MS69/MS70


Error 2: Misunderstanding “Modern”

Not all modern coins are equal – their age affects MS68 value:

Error 3: Chasing “Top Pop” Labels

New collectors often overpay for coins labeled “1 of 1” in MS68 when:

• More coins get graded weekly
• The series is still being minted
• Registry set popularity changes

Error 4: Overlooking Visual Appeal

I once saw two 2000-P Sacagawea Dollars:

• MS70: Dull surfaces, weak details
• MS68: Gorgeous strike with tiny flaws

The MS68 was clearly more attractive – proof that numbers don’t always tell the full story.

Smart Buying Strategies for Beginners

The Easy 20% Guideline

Keep these limits in mind:

• Max 20% over MS67 price for rare dates
• Max 20% under MS69 price for registry coins
• Max 20% over melt for bullion coins

When to Free Your Coin (Carefully!)

Consider removing coins from slabs if you want to:

1. Display in coin albums
2. Try for a grade upgrade
3. Save storage space

Safety first: Wear eye protection and work slowly – coins can fly when slabs break!

What’s Next for MS68 Modern Coins?

From thirty years in the hobby, I predict:

• Bullion Coins: Still bargains compared to higher grades
• Special Issues: Could become sleepers
• Errors/Varieties: The mistake matters more than the grade

Remember the 1999-P Delaware Quarter MS68? Once $400, now $85 – a perfect example of why grade alone doesn’t guarantee value.

Your MS68 Game Plan

Here’s the simple truth about modern MS68 coins:

• ✅ Buy when: Rare issue, stunning looks, or priced like bullion
• ❌ Skip when: Common coin, or prices climb too high

As my mentor once told me while examining a coin: “The grade confirms what your eyes should see first.” The best MS68 modern coins aren’t just numbers in slabs – they’re miniature works of art with stories to tell.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• How I Mastered Buying Modern MS68 Coins Without Losing Money (Step-by-Step Framework) – I Almost Got Burned Buying MS68 Coins – Here’s How I Fixed My Approach When I first saw that 2019-S Silver E…
• From Coin Collector to Technical Author: How to Write a Bestselling Book on Numismatics – How My Coin Collecting Passion Became a Bestselling Technical Book You know that moment when your hobby takes over the d…
• From Coin Errors to Cash Flow: How I Built a $52,000 Online Course Teaching Numismatic Detection – Turning Coin Expertise Into Digital Income What if your specialized knowledge could pay your bills while you sleep? That…