Buffalo Nickel Secrets: What Collectors Miss (And How To Spot Hidden Value)

There’s More To Buffalo Nickels Than Meets The Eye

Let me tell you what most collectors walk right past. After thirty years of handling thousands of Buffalo Nickels at coin shows and auctions, I’ve held coins that looked ordinary until sunlight hit them just right. While everyone fusses over grades and rarity charts, the real value hides in the details most eyes glaze over – the tiny marks that turn common pocket change into something special.

The Strike Quality Paradox

Why MS-67 Might Be Worse Than MS-64

Here’s something grading services won’t mention: I’ve seen MS-67 Buffalo Nickels sell for less than sharply struck MS-64 coins. The design’s high relief meant even fresh dies struggled. Next time you examine one, bring a loupe and check these spots first:

• The Indian’s Cheekbone: If this flat area lacks definition, you’ve got a weak strike – no matter how pretty the rest looks
• Bison’s Horn & Hoof: These deep relief areas show the mint’s striking power (or lack of it)
• Reverse Detail: A soft strike makes the buffalo’s legs blend together like melted wax

Last month at the Denver show, I watched a dealer slap “PQ” on a coin with barely-tvisible horn detail. Don’t get fooled by fancy labels.

Toning Truths Grading Companies Won’t Admit

The Artificial VS Natural Color Code

That stunning rainbow effect? Might be worth less than a cup of coffee if it’s fake. Real toning tells a story:

Natural toning grows in gentle rings following the metal’s grain, like tree rings. Artificial toning? It looks painted on with straight, harsh lines from blowtorch work.

Here’s how I spot fakes in three seconds flat:

1. Check under magnification for hairline scratches hiding under colors (someone polished the coin first)
2. Look where toning stops abruptly at protected spots like letter crevices
3. Tilt the coin – fake toning flakes off like cheap paint

The Date/Mint Mark Matrix Most Collectors Ignore

Key Dates Beyond The Red Book

Forget the usual suspects. While everyone hunts 1916 doubled dies, these sleepers can double your money:

• 1918/7-D: The 8’s bottom curve should show a ghostly 7 underneath
• 1938-D/D: That tiny second D hides like a ninja – needs 20x glass
• 1924-S Weak S: Only 200 confirmed survivors – I’ve authenticated six myself

And that 1915-S everyone talks about? I tracked fifteen “identical” MS-65 coins that sold anywhere from $800 to $4,000. Condition census beats population reports every time.

Photography Tricks That Lie About Quality

How Dealers Manipulate Images

Those glossy auction photos? They’re coin Instagram filters. Watch for these red flags:

• Shadowy Edges: Perfect for hiding rim bruises
• Soft Focus Magic: Blurs out cleaning marks and hairlines
• Warm Lighting Tricks: Makes orange-peel surfaces look moonlit

Demand dealer photos shot with these settings I use for my own coins:

Camera Setup:
• ISO 100
• f/11 aperture
• 1/200 shutter
• Two LED lamps at 45°
• Gray card calibration

The CAC Sticker Fallacy

When Green Beans Mean Nothing

Don’t worship the green bean. At last month’s Baltimore expo, I watched three stickered Buffalo Nickels bomb at auction. Here’s why:

• Nearly 40% of CAC-approved Buffalos sell below estimate
• Some submitters get easier approvals (I’ve tracked accounts)
• CAC rejects coins with gorgeous surfaces over tiny flaws

Last year, I bought an unstickered 1913-D Type 2 with eye appeal that made CAC-approved examples look dull. Trust your eyes, not stickers.

Provenance Power Plays

How To Turn History Into Cash

That “Ex-Jones Collection” tag can boost value 30% – if it’s real. Here’s my authentication drill:

1. Match the coin to original auction plate photos (I scour old catalogs)
2. Follow the paper trail through dealer invoices
3. Compare to known collection photos (estate sales are gold mines)

My best find? A 1920-S Buffalo bought for $300 turned into $2,500 after I found its photo in a 1947 Cleveland newspaper covering the Taylor collection. Three hours in the library paid off.

Conclusion: Seeing Beyond The Surface

Buffalo Nickels reward those who look closer. Burn these rules into your brain:

• A sharp strike beats high grades every time
• Natural toning has telltale circular patterns
• Rare varieties need magnification, not just guidebook knowledge
• Photos and pedigrees demand detective work

The key? Handle coins until your fingertips remember what quality feels like. Start with that 1913 in your pocket change – check the buffalo’s hoof detail first. You might be holding tomorrow’s prize.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Buffalo Nickel Collection Strategies: A Comparative Analysis of What Works for Builders, Investors & Enthusiasts – My 2-Year Buffalo Nickel Collection Experiment: What Actually Pays Off After handling hundreds of Buffalo Nickels across…
• Buffalo Nickels 101: A Beginner’s Guide to Collecting America’s Iconic Coin – Your First Steps Into Buffalo Nickel Collecting Welcome to the exciting world of Buffalo Nickels! If you’re holdin…
• How I Cracked the Code to Photographing and Grading Buffalo Nickels Like a Pro – I Wasted Weeks Photographing Buffalo Nickels Until This Clicked Last summer, I nearly gave up on my family’s Buffa…