How I Accurately Graded My 1867 Shield Nickel: A Step-By-Step Coin Evaluation Guide

How I Cracked the Code on Grading My 1867 Shield Nickel

When I first held my 1867 Shield Nickel, my hands shook. Was this a hidden treasure or just another worn coin? Those mysterious scratches on the shield kept me awake – normal wear or value-killing damage? After weeks of squinting at blurry photos and contradictory forum posts, I finally figured it out. Let me walk you through exactly how I graded my nickel correctly (and saved myself from costly mistakes).

Why Grading This Nickel Isn’t Like Other Coins

My “Aha!” Moment With the No Rays Variety

My grading breakthrough started when I noticed sunlight – or rather, the lack of it. My 1867 nickel was the special “No Rays” version (minted 1867-1869), missing the sun rays between stars on the back. This isn’t just trivia – it affects everything from grading standards to potential value, especially since “With Rays” versions often sell for more.

When 60+ Die Varieties Made My Head Spin

I nearly went cross-eyed discovering PCGS lists over 60 die variations! Here’s the cheat sheet I made to stay sane:

• Check for ghost letters in “UNITED STATES OF AMERICA” (sign of DDO)
• Inspect dates for telltale doubling at the base
• Study wreath leaves like a botanist – missing ones mean premium varieties
• Spot die clashes near the shield’s right side

The Exact Process That Worked for Me

1. Getting the Lighting Right (After Many Failed Attempts)

Bad photos ruined my first grading effort. Here’s what finally worked:

• Two adjustable LED lamps at 45-degree angles
• Smartphone macro mode (no fancy camera needed)
• Polarized filters to kill glare – game changer!
• Multiple shots at different exposures

2. Reading the Wear Patterns Like a Detective

Through trial and error, I learned three spots that tell the real story:

Front (Obverse):

• Horizontal lines on the shield (breaks mean wear)
• Hair details above Liberty’s ear
• That pesky rim ding at 4 o’clock

Back (Reverse):

• Leaf separation under “CENTS”
• Ribbon details in the wreath
• Sharpness of star points

3. Making Sense of Those Dreaded Scratches

Those shield marks almost fooled me. Here’s how I learned to tell the difference:

• OK: Fine parallel lines from circulation
• Warning: Deep solitary scratches crossing designs
• Bad news: Actual pits where metal is missing

The $64,000 Question: To Grade or Not to Grade?

I did the math on professional grading – here’s my real-world breakdown:

• Cost: $45 grading fee + shipping/insurance
• Worth it only if: My coin hit MS60+ ($300+ value)
• Smart alternative: $20 dealer appraisal at my local coin show

How I Landed on My Final Grade

After three days of obsessive examination, here’s how I called it:

1. Confirmed “No Rays” variety with 10x magnification
2. Ruled out premium die varieties despite cool die crack at 3:00
3. Settled on AU50 because:
   • Worn shield lines
   • That rim ding at 4 o’clock
   • Partial luster but not full glow
4. Kept it raw – grading costs outweighed potential value

Hard-Won Wisdom for Fellow Collectors

What I wish I’d known before grading my Shield Nickel:

• Natural light is free – use multiple angles before judging
• Print PCGS reference photos – screen images lie
• Focus on key wear points, not overall “look”
• When unsure, grade lower – these nickels often disappoint

My Takeaway for New Collectors

Grading my 1867 Shield Nickel taught me more than any guidebook. Sure, mine wasn’t worth thousands, but now I can confidently evaluate any Shield Nickel. Remember: good lighting beats expensive gear, minor flaws matter more on early coins, and sometimes the real value is in keeping your coin exactly where it belongs – in your collection, not sealed in plastic.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Why the Best Cherrypicks of 2025 Are Reshaping the Future of Numismatic Value Discovery – What if the next great numismatic discovery isn’t just about luck—but about spotting what others miss *before* it’s obvi…
• The 5-Minute Guide to Spotting and Cherrypicking High-Value Coin Varieties (That Most Dealers Miss) – Need to solve this fast? Here’s the no-nonsense method I use. You’re at a coin show, scrolling eBay, or brow…
• I Tested Every Cherry-Pick Strategy for Rare Coins in 2025 – Here’s What Actually Works (and What Doesn’t) – I tested every cherry-pick strategy for rare coins in 2025—so you don’t have to. I bought, resubmitted, and even hacked …