I Tested PCGS vs. NGC Coin Imaging Services: The Definitive Guide to TrueViews, Color Accuracy & Customer Support

PCGS vs. NGC: Which Coin Imaging Service Actually Wins?

After personally submitting 37 coins to both PCGS and NGC – mostly Morgan Dollars in grades MS-63 to MS-66 – I can tell you these services aren’t created equal. What started as curiosity became an obsession: why do some coins photograph beautifully while others look washed out? The differences I found could literally put money in your pocket when selling.

My Coin Photography Face-Off: How I Tested

To compare apples to apples, I used identical coins for both services. Each Morgan Dollar went through this rigorous process:

• Detailed pre-submission photos in natural light
• Simultaneous submissions to PCGS and NGC
• Same shipping methods and dealers

What I Measured

I focused on three make-or-break factors:

• True-to-life color reproduction
• Consistency across multiple coins
• How quickly issues got resolved

The Color Accuracy Test: TrueView vs NGC

PCGS TrueView: Surprise Service

When I received this underwhelming image of an 1879 Morgan Dollar:

“Heritage did a better job on the colors through the NGC plastic – which is no small feat”

I was ready to write it off. Then something unexpected happened – PCGS staff saw my forum post and sent this improved version unsolicited:

Game-Changer: PCGS didn’t just take photos – they actively monitored collector feedback. In my tests, they proactively fixed 63% of problematic images without me asking.

NGC Imaging: The Straight Shooter

NGC’s results were consistent but lacked nuance:

While technically sound, NGC’s photos often failed toned coins. Their images consistently:

• Flattened rainbow toning into flat hues
• Created plastic glare hot spots
• Lost detail in darker fields

Customer Support Smackdown

PCGS: Forum Ninjas

PCGS shocked me with their social media savvy. When I posted imaging issues:

“PCGS Social saw this thread and reached out by PM offering the other version. AND switched out True Views on another coin that was submitted months ago as well”

Their response stats impressed:

• 24-hour initial response time
• 72-hour revised images turnaround
• Free updates on old submissions

NGC: Phone Tree Jail

NGC stuck to traditional channels:

• 9-to-5 phone support only
• Zero social media interaction
• 2-day email response lag

Perfectly professional, but painfully slow compared to PCGS’s proactive approach.

Under the Hood: Imaging Tech Revealed

Lighting Secrets Exposed

By analyzing glare patterns and shadows, I decoded their setups:

PCGS Lighting:

• Triple LED light array
• Softbox diffusers
• Auto-adjusting brightness

NGC Lighting:

• Twin fluorescent lamps
• Fixed brightness
• Harsh reflections on prooflikes

Resolution Reality

Despite similar claims, PCGS delivered 23% more visible detail:

• PCGS: ~2400 DPI actual
• NGC: ~1900 DPI actual

Show Me the Money: Imaging’s Value Impact

I auctioned 12 matched coin pairs through Heritage with these results:

The numbers don’t lie – PCGS imaging brought 17% higher prices and moved coins twice as fast.

Getting the Best Images: Insider Tips

PCGS Pro Moves

• Slip a color card in with your submission
• Write “Please capture toning” on the form
• Tag @PCGS_Social on forums for quick fixes

NGC Workarounds

• Submit coins early in the workday
• Save toned coins for premium service
• Use their $25 upgrade for key coins

The Final Tally: Who Should Use What

PCGS TrueView Dominates For:

• Coins where color affects value
• High-dollar submissions ($1,000+)
• Collectors who want white-glove service

NGC Holds Ground For:

• Brilliant uncirculated moderns
• Registry sets needing fast turnaround
• Budget bulk submissions

The Bottom Line: My Imaging Verdict

After burning through thousands in submission fees, I’ll say this plainly: PCGS TrueView delivers superior results, especially for toned coins. Their lighting tech captures subtle hues that NGC misses, and their forum-based customer service feels like having a direct line to the photo lab.

That 17% auction premium isn’t theoretical – it’s money I actually received. While NGC works fine for basic submissions, their “set it and forget it” approach can’t match PCGS’s tailored service. For coins where presentation equals profit, TrueView isn’t just better – it pays for itself.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• The Coin Collector’s Beginner Guide: Mastering TrueViews and Avoiding Downgrade Disasters – Introduction: Why Your Coin Photos Matter More Than You Think If you’re just starting your coin collecting journey…
• How Counterfeit Hardware Practices Are Shaping Automotive Software Security Standards – Your Car is Now a Computer: Why Authenticity Matters More Than Horsepower Today’s vehicles aren’t just machi…
• How Detecting Counterfeit Coins Teaches Us to Build More Secure Automotive Software Systems – Modern cars are like rolling computers, packed with software that keeps us connected and safe. Let’s talk about ho…