7 Costly Montana Coin Show Mistakes (And How to Avoid Them)
September 15, 2025Why Montana’s Coin Show Scene Disappeared (And How I Made the Most of It)
September 15, 2025Ready to go beyond the basics? These advanced techniques will set you apart from the crowd.
Montana might not be the first place you think of for coin hunting, but let me tell you—the Treasure State is full of surprises if you know how to look. After years of hunting rare coins here, I’ve learned it’s less about big coin shows (which are rare) and more about smart, local strategies. Here’s how to hunt like a pro in Montana’s unique numismatic scene.
1. Mastering Montana’s Hidden Hotspots
Ghost Town Gold: The 1800s Connection
Montana’s rich mining history means treasures are still tucked away. Try focusing on:
- Butte-area estates (former gold miners’ homes)
- Descendants of pioneer families in Glendive and Miles City
- Small-town banks with original vaults, especially along old railroad routes
The Lincoln’s Silver Dollar Bar Reality Check
Sure, the Haugen spot has thousands of coins, but here’s what pros know:
Most are common Ikes and worn Peace Dollars—but staff often keep private collections off display. Be polite, tip well, and ask quietly.
2. The Gun Show Workaround
Since formal coin shows dried up around 2010, I’ve made gun shows work for me by:
- Checking vendor lists for “numismatic” tags (they pop up at nearly a quarter of Montana events)
- Bringing a UV flashlight to spot real silver in mixed booths
- Trading modern bullion (popular with the gun crowd) for older pieces
3. Digital Deep Dives
Beyond Coinshows.com
Advanced collectors in Montana use tricks like this:
// Custom search for Montana-specific finds
site:facebook.com/groups "montana coins" before:2020
This digs up older collector groups. Even if they’re quiet, members might still reply to DMs about their collections.
The Billings Strategy
Montana’s biggest city offers some solid options:
- Three active coin shops with rotating “under counter” stock
- Estate sale companies that focus on ranching families
- Pawn shops that sometimes mistake territorial gold coins for jewelry
4. Creating Your Own Opportunities
When I set up a pop-up show in Bozeman, we:
- Teamed up with a Western memorabilia dealer to draw more people
- Offered free “Coin ID Days” to encourage folks to bring in attic finds
- Used historical society mailing lists for targeted invites
The result? We uncovered 17 previously unknown Morgan dollars.
Conclusion: Think Like a Montana Pro
Here’s what really works for advanced coin hunting in Montana:
- Scarcity of shows means getting creative with where you look
- Focus on historical ties rather than typical retail spots
- Connect with other collector groups—guns, cards, antiques
- Use online tools to find offline chances
With these approaches, you’ll see Montana’s so-called “coin desert” is actually ripe for the picking—if you know how to hunt.
Related Resources
You might also find these related articles helpful:
- 7 Costly Montana Coin Show Mistakes (And How to Avoid Them) – I’ve Seen These Montana Coin Show Mistakes Over and Over After 15 years of hunting coins across Montana, I’v…
- How to Find Montana Coin Shows Fast (Quick & Easy Solution) – Need to Find Montana Coin Shows Fast? Here’s What Actually Works Tired of searching for Montana coin shows with zero res…
- Montana Coin Shows: The Untold Secrets Every Collector Needs to Know – What Nobody Tells You About Montana Coin Collecting Let me tell you a secret – Montana’s coin scene isn̵…