My Adventure in Creating a Twelve Caesars Coin Calendar
June 26, 2025My Insights on Overpriced Ancient Coins
June 26, 2025After years of dreaming and browsing countless listings, I finally added an Athenian Owl tetradrachm to my collection—joining that special club felt incredible. Holding this iconic coin for the first time gave me goosebumps, and I picked up some practical tips I’d love to share.
The Thrill of Owning an Owl
My Owl’s a hefty chunk of ancient silver weighing just over half an ounce—it instantly made my Roman denarii look tiny. That dramatic high relief meant it needed a thicker NGC holder. Like many Owls, Athena’s bust gets clipped by the flan edge, but I focus on what shines: that gorgeous reverse owl. Mine’s graded Strike 5, Surface 3, with a hairline scratch on Athena’s cheek you’d miss if you weren’t looking. It’s a gentle reminder that these ancients wear their history.
Making Sense of Grading
When my Owl arrived, I noticed how services like NGC fixate on surface issues—toning, deposits, porosity—which feels misleading for coins this old. Since wear comes with the territory, I now examine coins myself before checking the slab. Here’s what works for me:
- Look at the coin first, not the label: Is the strike full? Are the owl’s feathers and olive leaves crisp?
- Strike ratings help judge completeness, but surface grades are subjective—ask yourself if flaws actually distract from the coin’s appeal
- Get familiar with the type through research—it builds confidence in your own eyes
This approach keeps me from obsessing over numbers and focuses on what makes a coin special to me.
Smart Buying in a Hot Market
Owl prices have climbed steadily, making impulse buys tempting. I watched listings hit thousands before finding mine at a sensible price. Some strategies that helped:
- Try auctions for common coins like Owls—disciplined bidding often beats dealer premiums
- Dealers shine for rare pieces, but always cross-check prices
- Remember those Turkish hoards? Supply is decent—wait for coins matching both your budget and taste
Set your spending limit early. Let overpriced coins walk—another beauty always appears.
History That Comes Alive
Discovering the backstory deepened my connection. Athens struck millions between 440–404 BC using Laurium silver, but quality shifted over time. Early pieces like the Star Group III (around 465 BC) show charmingly crude style, while later coins standardized with lower relief but larger flans. Watch for plated fakes—they’re uncommon but identifiable. This context explains why so many survive and helps spot the real treasures.
Finding Your Perfect Owl
Choosing mine taught me to balance beauty and flaws. My personal checklist:
- Centering matters: Try to find one showing Athena’s full helmet crest
- Seek strong strikes where owl details pop clearly
- Accept minor cracks or scratches as character—but avoid major distractions like blobs, heavy stains, or clipped edges
- Choose what feels right: slabbed for protection or raw for handling—I prefer slabs for ease
In the end, pick the coin that speaks to you. Perfection’s overrated in ancients.
Final Reflections
Landing my Athenian Owl stands among my proudest collecting moments. If you’re after one, savor the hunt. These coins bridge centuries—holding mine feels like shaking hands with history. Thrilled to finally be in the club, I’m already daydreaming about which ancient wonder might join it next!