Building a Rare Coin Collection: My 6-Month Journey to Acquiring US Patterns & Cameos

I’ve been dealing with this issue for months. Here’s my honest experience and what I wish I’d known from the start.

Six months ago, I started something that would challenge and delight me like nothing else in my collecting life: building a complete set of US Pattern coins and Cameo proofs. It began as a simple curiosity. But soon, it became a full-blown passion. Along the way, I learned priceless lessons about numismatics, patience, and smart collecting.

The Allure of Patterns and Cameos

Pattern coins are truly special. They’re experimental pieces created by the US Mint to test new designs, metals, or denominations. Cameo proofs, on the other hand, showcase incredible artistry—frosted details set against mirror-like backgrounds. Both types offer a unique glimpse into minting history.

Why These Coins Captivated Me

• Historical significance: Every coin tells a story of America’s monetary past.
• Artistic beauty: Many designs are stunning but never made it into public hands.
• Rarity challenge: Finding them all is a thrilling and ambitious goal.

My First Major Acquisition: The 1858 FE & IHC Short Set

My journey kicked off with the 1858 Flying Eagle and Indian Head Cent short set. These patterns mark the shift from large cents to the smaller ones we use today. For me, they were the perfect entry into serious pattern collecting.

Here’s what I picked up from that first buy:

• Condition is everything with rare coins.
• Provenance (like ex-Bass collection coins) adds real value.
• Third-party grading (think PR64BN or PR65) offers peace of mind.

The Cameo Chase: Building a Registry-Worthy Set

Feeling more confident, I aimed for Cameo proofs next. Their sharp contrast makes them stand out under light. My highlight? The J-1550a Morgan “first design” pattern in PR65 CAM CAC—the second-finest known example. It quickly became my collection’s star.

What I Learned About Cameo Collecting

• Natural toning boosts value; artificial doesn’t.
• Deep cameo contrast means higher prices.
• Top examples get competitive in registry sets.

The Power of Networking in Numismatics

I was surprised by how much connections matter. Other collectors helped me with:

• Heads-up on upcoming auctions.
• Grading tips I wouldn’t find in books.
• Chances to buy before pieces hit the market.
• Stories that made each coin even more special.

Financial Realities of High-End Collecting

Building this set meant careful budgeting. I had to:

• Shift funds from other areas (I sold my Flying Eagle collection).
• Plan buys around big auctions and shows.
• Know when a rare piece was worth the premium.
• Use CAC-approved coins as a trusted guide.

Key Takeaways After 6 Months

Looking back, a few things stand out:

1. Focusing beats spreading yourself too thin.
2. Good records and research are as vital as the coins.
3. Connections with dealers and collectors really pay off.
4. Waiting often means better deals and smarter choices.

Advice for Aspiring Pattern Collectors

If you’re thinking of starting your own US Pattern coin collection, here’s what I’d suggest:

“Buy the books before the coins—it saves you from expensive errors.”

• Start with common patterns to learn the market.
• Visit major coin shows to see quality examples up close.
• Stick with certified coins until you’re sure of your grading skills.
• Get to know the specialists—they’re goldmines of info.

Conclusion: The Journey Continues

I’m proud to be halfway through my US Patterns set after six months. But there’s still a long road ahead. Every new coin teaches me more about history, the market, and what I truly value as a collector. What started as a hobby is now a deep passion—mixing art, history, and the excitement of the hunt.

The biggest takeaway? In rare coin collecting, it’s not just about the finish line. It’s about the stories each coin holds—and the ones we create along the way.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• How I Wrote a Technical Book on Coin Grading: A Step-by-Step Guide from Idea to Published Author – Writing a technical book is a powerful way to build authority. I’m going to walk you through my entire process—from stru…
• How I Turned My Niche Coin Expertise Into a $50K Online Course on Teachable and Udemy – Ever thought about turning what you know into a steady income stream? I did—and it worked. Here’s exactly how I packaged…
• How Mastering Niche Technical Expertise Like Coin Grading Can Elevate Your Consulting Rates to $200/hr+ – Want to earn $200+ per hour as a consultant? It all comes down to solving problems that really cost your clients money. …