Has Anyone Else Bought One of These? My Deep Dive into the US Mint’s 250th Anniversary Silver Eagle
June 17, 2025My Adventure with a ‘Box of 100’ CAC Type Set
June 17, 2025
As a coin collector, I’ve always been fascinated by that mysterious extra leaf on Wisconsin quarters—it’s one of those little oddities that makes our hobby so much fun. After spending countless hours examining these coins and chatting with fellow collectors, I’m excited to share what I’ve discovered to help you in your own search without stepping into common traps.
Understanding the Extra Leaf Variety
Here’s what I found: the extra leaf varieties—both high and low—were never part of the original design. They came about because a disgruntled mint worker scratched the dies, adding this unintended but totally cool feature. That’s why they’re so popular, but telling a real one from a regular quarter takes practice. When I’m checking a coin, I always turn to NGC’s variety page. Their photos are super clear, showing how the high leaf sits well above the stalk, while the low leaf is tucked in more subtly.
Spotting Scams and Fake Listings
When I’m browsing online marketplaces, I see tons of listings claiming to have the extra leaf when it’s just not there. Some sellers jack up prices—asking hundreds for a plain quarter—taking advantage of folks who don’t know better. It’s really frustrating, especially for newcomers who might feel like giving up. Here’s how I avoid getting burned:
- Always check photos carefully: Compare the leaf’s position to known real examples. If it doesn’t match or you can’t see it clearly, it’s probably fake.
- Double-check with trusted sources: I keep NGC and PCGS pages bookmarked so I can look them up while shopping.
- Watch out for crazy prices: Real extra leaf quarters are valuable, but even in top grades like MS66, they shouldn’t break the bank. Remember, if a deal looks too good to be true, it usually is.
Grading Tips and Market Observations
Grading matters a lot for value. Even in MS66, these coins can be pricey, but I’ve seen plenty of eBay listings that get the grade or variety wrong. Sometimes sellers mix up the extra leaf with a regular quarter, or even mistake it for a completely different error like the 1970-S Lincoln cent small date. My rule of thumb: only buy coins that have been graded by NGC or PCGS. That way, you know what you’re getting. As for the market, yes, rare coins cost more, but don’t rush. I’ve actually scored better deals through trusted dealers than in online auctions.
Personal Collecting Insights and Philosophies
For me, collecting is all about the thrill of the hunt. I’ve spent countless hours going through rolls of coins, hoping to find that extra leaf quarter. Every time I check my change, it feels like a little adventure. Some folks prefer to buy complete sets, and that’s fine if you can, but I get the most joy from the search. My own sets have gaps, and that’s perfectly okay. It’s the journey that counts, not just filling every slot. Plus, this way the hobby stays affordable and exciting, especially when you’re watching your budget.
Practical Advice for New Collectors
If you’re just starting out, here are a few things I’ve learned from my own wins and blunders:
- Learn the basics: Use free online resources to study up on varieties before you buy. It’ll save you from expensive errors.
- Start with what’s in your pocket: Search through coins in circulation. You might find something amazing, and it’s a risk-free way to build your skills.
- Report shady listings: If you see a scam on eBay or elsewhere, flag it. They have rules against false ads, and it helps keep everyone safe.
- Have fun: Remember, collecting should be enjoyable. Don’t stress about knowing everything at once. Connect with other collectors—they’re a great source of help and encouragement.
Through it all, hunting for that extra leaf has taught me to be patient and careful. Keep your eyes open, be wary of deals that seem too good to be true, and above all, enjoy every minute of this wonderful hobby. Happy collecting!
