Cherry Picking the Elusive 1916 Buffalo Nickel: How to Spot Misattributed Varieties in Circulation Finds

You never know where numismatic treasure might hide. While dealers’ cases glitter with premium specimens, some of our hobby’s most exciting discoveries still emerge from dusty bank rolls, overlooked estate sale lots, and everyday circulation finds. Today, we’re delving into one of the Buffalo nickel series’ most fascinating puzzles—the legendary 1916 doubled die obverse—and how a recent auction controversy reveals essential truths for variety hunters.

Historical Significance of the 1916 Buffalo Nickel

Though not a rare date in overall mintage (Philadelphia struck over 63 million pieces), the 1916 Buffalo nickel holds special status as the final year of the original Type 1 design. What transforms ordinary examples into numismatic superstars? The VAM-1 doubled die obverse—first cataloged by Leroy Van Allen and A. George Mallis—a rare variety that commands jaw-dropping premiums even in well-worn condition. Finding one in mint state? That’s the holy grail for Buffalo specialists.

Anatomy of a Legendary Variety

True 1916 DDO specimens display three unmistakable diagnostic markers under magnification—the fingerprint that separates ordinary coins from numismatic royalty:

• Date & Designer’s Initials: Clear separation in the “1916” digits and Fraser’s “F”
• Ribbon Ties: Distinct notching at the knot beneath “LIBERTY”
• Primary Feather: Pronounced doubling at the base of the large neck feather

Spotting Truth in Worn Coins: A Test of Skill

Our case study coin—PCGS G04 #50731189—demonstrates how challenging attribution becomes when heavy wear obscures details. At Good-4 grade, surface loss can mimic or erase doubling markers, demanding expert scrutiny. When this example appeared with a $1,000 opening bid as a DDO, sharp-eyed collectors immediately questioned its pedigree.

“There’s nothing there to even be confused for doubling” – Forum User Observation

Community analysis revealed three smoking guns:

• Flat, undoubled ribbon ties
• Absence of feather base separation
• Date digits showing mechanical distortion—not true hub doubling

The Acid Test: When Cleaning Masks Truth

This coin’s “Details” grade hints at a darker story. Chemical cleaning—particularly acid etching—can create artificial surface irregularities. On weakly struck Buffalo nickels, these alterations sometimes mimic die doubling to inexperienced eyes, permanently damaging both eye appeal and numismatic value.

Value Realities: Knowledge Pays Dividends

Understanding these dramatic value gaps separates savvy collectors from disappointed bidders:

• Authentic 1916 DDO (G04): $1,000-$1,500+ based on strike and remaining detail
• Regular 1916 (G04): Modest $10-$20 as a semi-key date
• Chemically Altered (Details): $5-$15 due to compromised surfaces

The GreatCollections auction withdrawal (#1995928) proved a powerful reminder: even certification guarantees variety attribution, not absolute provenance.

Case Study Lessons: PCGS #50731189

This coin’s journey teaches us three non-negotiable truths:

1. Grading ≠ Godhood

Even PCGS experts can miss subtle details on heavily circulated coins. The slab’s authority stems from the coin’s surface—not infallible variety attribution. Always verify key markers yourself!

2. Collective Wisdom Protects Our Hobby

When forum members sounded the alarm, they demonstrated how shared knowledge safeguards collectors. As one veteran advised: “Never underestimate the hive mind of experienced cherry pickers.”

3. Digital Tools Revolutionize the Hunt

High-resolution certification images (like PCGS CertView) enable remote sleuthing. The telltale photo (cert/165128105/large/4q9IcQMAN0aYTzq5waoYMg.jpg) allowed detailed analysis without handling the coin—a game-changer for modern variety hunters.

Buffalo Nickel Hunting: Pro Strategies

Building a worthy collection requires equal parts knowledge and grit:

Prime Hunting Grounds

• Bank Rolls: Still yield pre-1960 surprises—especially in rural areas
• Estate Lots: Untouched collections often hide in “junk nickel” boxes
• Dealer Bargain Bins: Where G/VG coins get overlooked for quality

Essential Field Gear

• 10x-20x loupe for checking luster and strike details
• Latest “Cherrypickers’ Guide” (your variety bible)
• Population report access to gauge rarity

Critical Examination Points

• Date/mintmark placement anomalies
• Liberty’s neckline definition
• Reverse horn texture (Type 1 vs Type 2 tells)

Conclusion: Why We Chase the Buffalo

This 1916 DDO saga reminds us that numismatic magic lives in the hunt itself—the thrill of scrutinizing a coin’s patina, the adrenaline rush spotting a rare variety, the camaraderie of collective discovery. While our case study coin didn’t deliver treasure, its story reinforces what makes collecting timeless: every coin holds history waiting to be unpacked by curious minds.

So keep those loupes polished and your Cherrypickers’ Guide handy. Remember—the next great find might be hiding in plain sight, waiting for someone who knows to check those ribbon ties!

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Smart Buying Guide: How to Buy a 1916 Buffalo Nickel So-Called Doubled Die Obverse Without Getting Ripped Off – If you’re hunting for a 1916 Buffalo Nickel So-Called Doubled Die Obverse (SCDDO) to elevate your collection, buck…
• The $10 vs. $1,000 Question: Grading the Controversial 1916 Buffalo Nickel (PCGS #50731189) – Condition Is Everything: A Professional Grader’s Breakdown Let’s cut to the chase: in our world, condition i…
• 1916 Buffalo Nickel Authentication Guide: Exposing Fake ‘Doubled Die’ Varieties and PCGS Slab #50731189 – The Hidden Dangers Lurking in Your Buffalo Nickel Collection Few things quicken a collector’s pulse like spotting …