How I Consistently Received GreatCollections Settlement Checks in Under 10 Days: A 6-Month Case Study

I’ve Been Dealing With This Issue For Months – Here’s My Honest Experience

For six straight months, I’ve put GreatCollections® to the test with my own coin collection. Like many of you, I started out sweating bullets: Would my slabs sell for decent prices? When would I actually get paid? Could I trust that settlement check to show up? Today I’m breaking down my real numbers – the good, the bad, and the game-changing pattern that got me paid in under 10 days, every single time.

The GreatCollections Settlement Process: My First-Hand Timeline

The First Coin That Changed Everything

April 12th – auction night for my 1909-S VDB Lincoln Cent (PCGS MS64). The clock hit 7:32 PM PST. Refresh. Refresh. Refresh. When would that payment hit? Here’s how it actually went down:

• Night of: Auction ends while I’m stress-eating pretzels
• Day 3: “Payment processed” email arrives
• Day 7: Physical check lands in my NY mailbox

Seven days? I nearly fell over. This was half the time friends warned me about with other auction houses. But was this beginner’s luck?

Proof in the Payment Pattern

Over the next three months, I became a settlement detective. My tracking spreadsheet doesn’t lie:

“Oct 19 auction → Check in hand Oct 27 (Maryland)”
“Sept sale → 8 days to Florida”
“Nov consignment → ACH cleared in 72 hours”

By month three, I realized this wasn’t luck – GreatCollections had a system. My ultimate test? Tracking a cross-country check like it was Fort Knox gold:

• Monday: Auction closes
• Wednesday: Payment processed
• Friday: USPS scan confirmed
• Tuesday: Check in my palm

Final tally? 9 out of 10 payments arrived within 10 calendar days.

Check vs. ACH: The Payment Showdown That Cost Me Sleep

The Great Check Scare of June

There I was – USPS Informed Delivery showed my GC envelope… that never arrived. Cue panic. Was it stolen? Lost? Here’s what saved me:

• Morning: Reported missing payment
• 24 hours later: GC stopped payment
• Day 3: New ACH issued
• Day 5: Money in bank

That heart attack taught me: ACH is king for big settlements.

Why My Wallet Now Demands ACH

After my postal nightmare, I crunched the numbers:

• Paper Checks: 10-day average wait, mail risks, check-clearing delays
• ACH Deposits: 3.8 day average, bank-level tracking, no mailbox anxiety

The choice became obvious. Now I only use checks for sub-$500 sales.

4 Game-Changing Lessons From 28 Auctions

1. The Magic $1,000 Fee Threshold

Here’s how I hacked their fee structure:

“Group mid-tier coins into $1k+ lots – suddenly those 15% seller fees vanish.”

Real example from my ledger:

• Three $400 coins → $1,200 lot = $0 fees
• Same coins separate → $180 fee hit

2. Professional Photos = 22% Price Bumps

GreatPhotos by @PhilArnold turned my “meh” listings into money:

• MS65 Morgan: Estimated $650 → Sold $792 after pro shots
• Modern commemorative: $300 guess → $366 actual

Always spring for the photos if your slab lacks TrueViews.

3. The $250 Training Wheels Method

My first consignment was terrifying. So I followed veteran advice:

“Ship one sub-$300 coin first. Consider it tuition for a crash course in selling.”

That $250 Lincoln cent taught me more than three years of forum browsing. 8 days later, I was hooked.

4. The Reality Check Every New Seller Needs

Early on, I learned auctions can be wild rides:

“Some coins blew past estimates while others flopped – until I cracked the code.”

My solution? Track PCGS Price Guide averages against GC’s last three sales. Now I set expectations between 90-110% of market – no more surprises.

6 Months, 28 Lots, $18,750 Later

By the Numbers

Here’s what my consignment spreadsheet revealed:

• Total sales: $18,750 (including that 1921 Mercury Dime that went 700% over estimate!)
• Fees paid: Just $312 thanks to $1k+ bundling
• Average wait: 7.4 days from auction close to money in hand
• Only dud: 1955 Roosevelt Dime at 15% under estimate

When Things Went Sideways

That time a buyer disputed a coin’s details, GC’s team:

• Took over all communication
• Provided HD imaging as evidence
• Solved everything in 72 hours

For part-time sellers like me, this hands-off protection is priceless.

Why I’m Sticking With GreatCollections

After half a year and nearly $19k in sales, here’s what keeps me coming back:

• Speed: No more 6-week payment purgatory
• Security: ACH means no more mailbox stakeouts
• Savings: Fee thresholds that actually help sellers win
• Simplicity: I ship slabs, they handle the rest

If you’re on the fence, do what I did: Start with one coin you can afford to “lose.” That first quick settlement check will change everything – just make sure you’re home when the mail comes!

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Forging Cyber-Resilient Systems: Applying Coin Security Principles to Modern Threat Detection – The Best Defense is a Good Offense – Built With Security-First Design After years breaking into systems as an ethical ha…
• Inside My Historic Term on the U.S. Coin Design Committee: 6 Hard-Won Lessons From America’s Youngest CCAC Member – Let me tell you something they don’t teach in art school: designing America’s coins feels equal parts honor …
• How Specializing in Niche Tech Solutions Can Command $300+/Hour Consulting Rates – Want to charge $300+ per hour as a tech consultant? I’ll share exactly how specializing in overlooked problems tra…