How I Decided Between Selling My Gold Eagles or Pre-1933 Saints: A Step-by-Step Guide to Maximizing Your Returns

I was stuck in this exact spot last week, trying to decide what to do with my gold coins. After digging in, I found a clear path forward—here’s what worked for me.

My Gold Selling Dilemma: Eagles or Saints?

I had 10 Gold American Eagles and 10 slabbed MS63 Saint-Gaudens from 1924. Both are solid assets, but which one should I sell to get the best return? I wanted to balance gold content, collector appeal, and market timing. Let me walk you through how I made my choice.

Step 1: Compare the Gold Content

First things first: weigh the gold. Each Eagle holds a full troy ounce. My Saints, being pre-1933 coins, contain about 0.9675 troy ounces each. So, 10 Eagles meant 10 ounces of gold, while 10 Saints came out to roughly 9.675 ounces. For pure metal value, the Eagles had a small advantage.

Step 2: Check the Numismatic Value

Next, I looked at collector premiums. My Saints are over a century old and graded MS63—that usually means something to enthusiasts. But when I checked recent sales, the premium was almost nonexistent. In today’s market, even nice Saints like mine often trade near melt value. Eagles, on the other hand, move fast and easy since they’re recognized bullion.

Step 3: Watch the Market and Timing

Gold prices were climbing, and I didn’t want to miss a good selling window. I reviewed trends and decided: sell some now, keep some for later. It gave me cash when I needed it and left room for gains if gold kept rising.

Step 4: My Final Choice—Sell Half of Each

I went with a mix: five Eagles and five Saints. This way, I got the Eagles’ higher gold content and the Saints’ slight numismatic chance. Plus, it spread my risk and kept me partly invested.

Step 5: Selling and Seeing the Results

I listed both on trusted sites. The Eagles sold fast at spot price. The Saints drew a bit more interest—and a small premium—from buyers who love history. In the end, the blended approach worked great for me.

Key Takeaways for Your Own Sale

Start with gold weight—it’s your baseline. Check recent sales for accurate premiums. Sell in portions to stay flexible. And keep an eye on gold markets to time your move well.

Wrapping Up

By taking it step by step—comparing gold content, evaluating numismatic value, and watching the market—I made a smart choice that met my needs. Whether you have Eagles, Saints, or other gold, this method can help you get the most from your sale.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• How I Tracked Down My Ultimate Flying Eagle Coin: A Collector’s Step-by-Step Blueprint – My 3-Month Quest for the Perfect Coin (And How You Can Avoid My Mistakes) I ran into this exact issue and spent hours fi…
• Building a Scalable Headless CMS: A Developer’s Guide to API-First Content Management – Content management is evolving, and headless is leading the way. In this guide, I’ll share how to build a flexible, fast…
• Optimizing Shopify & Magento Stores for Maximum Speed and Conversions: A Developer’s Guide – For e-commerce stores, site speed and reliability directly impact revenue. If you’re managing Shopify or Magento s…