How I Identified and Capitalized on Undergraded Washington Quarters (A Collector’s Step-by-Step Guide)

How I Spotted Hidden Gems in “Undergraded” Washington Quarters (And How You Can Too)

Let me tell you about the three Washington Quarters that changed how I collect coins forever. Last month, while sifting through a dealer’s inventory, I nearly passed over a 1937 specimen labeled MS64. But something caught my eye—the luster seemed too vibrant, the surfaces too pristine. That moment sent me down a rabbit hole of discovery that transformed my approach to coin collecting.

The Clues That Made Me Look Twice

As I held those Washington Quarters under my magnifier, three things triggered my collector’s instinct:

• A radiant glow that shouldn’t exist in coins of their supposed grade
• Surfaces cleaner than my best slabbed coins
• That intangible “wow factor” missing from most coins in their price range

My Practical 4-Step Coin Evaluation Method

Through months of trial and error (and a few costly mistakes), I developed this straightforward system:

1. Surface Detective Work

Armed with a simple desk lamp, I angled the light across the 1937 quarter’s surface and discovered:

• Fewer contact marks than my own MS65 coins
• Nearly invisible hairlines that wouldn’t bother any serious grader
• Original mint bloom untouched by cleaning or polishing

// My foolproof documentation system:
1. Video under natural light + two artificial sources
2. Macro shots of every quadrant (12MP minimum)
3. Side-by-side comparisons with PCGS reference images

2. Strike Strength Check

The 1942-D quarter surprised me with:

• Crisp feather details that typically soften in this series
• Sharp wheat sheaves that looked freshly minted
• Liberty’s hair details clearer than most museum specimens

3. Smart Market Research

I spent evenings comparing:

• Recent eBay sold listings for identical dates/grades
• CAC-approved premiums on PCGS CoinFacts
• Wholesale vs. retail spreads in Grey Sheet

4. The Profitability Test

Crunching numbers for the 1937 quarter:

• Market value as MS64: $175 max
• CAC potential: Could add $50-70 overnight
• MS65 bump: $400-600 with right buyer
• Out-of-pocket: $80 total for grading + CAC

The Costly Mistakes I Made (Save Yourself the Headache)

Learn from my early stumbles:

Photo Fiasco

My initial images caused chaos because:

• I couldn’t tell which coin was which
• Lighting changed between shots
• Magnification levels weren’t consistent

My Imaging Solution

// Current setup that works:
– iPhone with external macro lens
– Consistent 5600K LED lighting
– Homemade coin stand (yogurt container hack!)
– File names: DATE_GRADE_LIGHTINGSOURCE.jpg

Overlooked Details

The 1949 quarter hid exciting secrets:

• Subtle doubling on “IN GOD WE TRUST”
• A faintly repunched date
• Features that actually increased its value

When to Submit: My Simple Checklist

After wasting money on bad submissions, I now use this filter:

• Submit Now: Makes you catch your breath + clear technical superiority
• Maybe Later: Nice but not exceptional + minor advantages
• Walk Away: “Meh” reaction + no standout features

1937 Quarter Breakdown

Why this one screamed “submit me”:

• Visual appeal: 9/10 (that toning!)
• Technical specs: MS65 traits in MS64 clothing
• Profit potential: 4x return after fees

Getting It Graded: My Stress-Free System

Here’s how I navigate submissions now:

Paperwork Made Simple

• Create one-page visual comparisons
• Print relevant auction records
• Write three bullet points explaining why it’s special

Smart Service Choices

I ask myself:

• Is walkthrough grading worth $65 for faster turnaround?
• Will a CAC sticker add enough value to justify cost?
• Does this coin need professional conservation?

The Waiting Period

During those nerve-wracking weeks:

• Set up eBay saved searches for similar coins
• Connect with three potential buyers in advance
• Draft my sales listing so it’s ready to go

Real Results From My Submission

The moment of truth:

• 1937 quarter: MS65 + CAC gold bean!
• 1949: Held grade but got green sticker
• 1942-D: No grade change but CAC approved

By the Numbers

• Total costs: $225 (grading + CAC)
• Value jump: $1,150 → $2,400+
• Profit after fees: About $2,000

That MS64 holder? It was hiding a near-gem. Never assume the label tells the whole story.

3 Rules That Guide Me Now

This experience taught me:

• Document everything: Your photos are your evidence
• Compare ruthlessly: PCGS Photograde is your best friend
• Crunch the numbers: Fees add up fast—calculate first

Finding undergraded Washington Quarters isn’t about luck—it’s about knowing what to look for and having a system. While not every coin will be a winner, this method helps me spot the hidden potential others miss. The real treasure? Turning that knowledge into smarter collecting decisions.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• The Coin Collector’s Survival Guide: What Traveling Buyers Don’t Want You to Know – What I Wish I Knew Before Dealing With Hotel Coin Buyers Let’s cut through the noise. After twenty years trading c…
• 3 Advanced Numismatic Techniques for Mastering the 1907 Saint-Gaudens Commemoratives – Ready to Go Beyond the Basics? These Advanced Techniques Will Set You Apart From the Crowd Most collectors examine comme…
• Why Inconsistent Tech Standards Sink M&A Deals: Lessons from the Coin Grading Wars – When Third-Party Validation Makes or Breaks Tech M&A Deals When tech companies consider acquisitions, the real work…