I Compared Every Major Coin Show Strategy for 2025 – Here’s What Actually Works

I spent months hitting the road, crisscrossing the country to attend every major coin show in 2024. From the fading halls of the Long Beach Expo to the bold new experiments like GACC and IMEX, I put each model to the test. I even prepped for the upcoming PCGS Irvine CA Show (Oct 22–24, 2025). I tracked costs, chatted with dealers, watched collector behavior, and asked one question: *What actually works?* This is what I found—no hype, no fluff. Just real data, real experiences, and real takeaways about what makes a coin show worth attending in 2025.

1. Legacy Shows vs. New Entrants: The Attendance & Demand Reality

The Long Beach Expo is gone from the PCGS calendar. No more dates on the venue site. No announcements. That’s not a typo—it’s a warning. Tradition doesn’t pay the bills anymore. Meanwhile, new shows like GACC and IMEX are stepping in. But are they filling the void? Some are. Others? Not so much.

Legacy Show Model: The Long Beach Case Study

• Pros: A trusted name for decades, strong regional pull, and dealer turnout you can count on.
• Cons: Sky-high parking, dated facilities, foot traffic slipping year after year, and programming stuck in the past.
• Testing Result: The June 2024 show got scrapped from PCGS’s schedule. No future dates listed. That’s not just a blip—it’s a sign. High cost, low return is killing these legacy events.

New Show Model: GACC, IMEX, and the “National For-Profit” Experiment

• Pros: Fresh marketing, lower overhead, smart concepts like limited access, and better support for dealers.
• Cons: No track record, scheduling clashes, collectors still skeptical, attendance all over the map.
• Testing Result: IMEX’s national show in Nashville? One and done. Now it’s bi-annual. GACC has traction, but even they’re struggling to scale beyond regional appeal. The “pent-up demand” story? Overhyped.

Key Insight: Name recognition isn’t enough. New shows bring ideas, but lack the network. The real winner? Operations and cost control. Not nostalgia, not buzz—execution.

2. Cost Structures: Parking, Venues, and the Hidden “Show Tax”

Forget table fees. The real cost of a show is everything else: parking, travel, time, meals, stress. I tracked every line item. Here’s what hit my (and every dealer’s) wallet.

Legacy Show: Long Beach – The $55 Daily Parking Trap

<
• On-site parking: $55/day (yep, really).

<

• Valet: $15 first 2 hours, then $55.

<

• No help from organizers. No validation. Nothing.

<

• Workaround: Free parking at a nearby mall—half a mile away, in the sun or rain.

Impact: Three days? That’s $165 just for parking. For a mid-range table fee, that’s 15–20% of your cost. Collectors feel it too. The silence from organizers? A message: your comfort doesn’t matter.

New Show: PCGS Irvine – A Shift Toward Cost Transparency

• Parking: Still $55, but PCGS is negotiating partial validation.
• Food: Free for dealers. Collectors pay $10–15.
• Table count: ~36 tables (50% more than typical PCGS member shows).
• Public access: Capped at 100—but open to non-members with a ticket.

Key Takeaway: PCGS Irvine is trying something different: premium access with clear, fair pricing. Limited crowds mean better conversations, better safety, and more value. The food and parking moves? Thoughtful, not greedy. A breath of fresh air after Long Beach’s nickel-and-dime game.

3. Access & Experience: Who Is the Show For?

Every show needs to pick a lane: Is this for dealers? Or collectors? Or both? Your answer changes everything—from tickets to talks to timing.

Model A: Dealer-Centric (Long Beach, ANA OKC)

• Focus: Pack the bourse floor, make dealers happy.
• Programming: Thin. Mostly auctions.

<

• Ticketing: Open to all. No limits. No curation.
• Result: The ANA show in Oklahoma City? Dealers groaned. No direct flights from NYC. Three-leg trips. Many missed Saturday—prime time. Travel logistics killed the vibe.

Model B: Experience-Centric (PCGS Irvine, GACC “See-How-It-Goes”)

• Focus: Make collectors feel special. Curation. Access.
• Programming: Room for ANA-style exhibits, talks, maybe even hands-on grading demos.
• Ticketing: Limited public. Members-only bourse floor.
• Result: PCGS’s 100-ticket cap creates scarcity and buzz. Early buzz? Collectors like the exclusivity. Dealers like fewer “tire-kickers.”

Actionable Insight: The best shows will blend both. Try this: “Dealers in at 8 AM. Public at 11 AM.” Timed entry. Less chaos. More control. More value for everyone.

4. Innovation: What’s Working (and What’s Not)

New ideas are popping up. Some smart. Some… not so much.

✅ Working: Limited Public Access & Curation

PCGS Irvine’s 100-ticket limit? Genius. Fewer people, better deals, safer space. GACC’s Buena Park show (not Long Beach!) pulled strong crowds—not because of the name, but because it’s well-run and easy to get to.

❌ Not Working: Gimmicks & Overpromising

<
• Steve Forbes speeches: Sounded cool. But collectors came for coins, not talks. Dealers tuned out.

<

• Raffle prizes: Costly. Low return. One dealer: “I sold three coins, won a $500 card, spent $2,000 on the table. Not worth it.”

<

• Downtown venues with $90 parking: Nashville’s location was a total flop. No one wants to pay that just to walk in.

⚠️ Testing: Suburban Relocation (Nashville Example)

Move shows near airports in the suburbs—like Nashville’s new Opry zone. Cheaper travel. Easier access. But you need shuttles. No shuttle? No show.

5. Recommendations: What We Should Do in 2025

After all this, here’s what I’d do if I were running a show in 2025:

1. Spill the total cost: Tell people upfront about parking, food, travel. Partner with nearby lots for free or discounted parking.
2. Cap public tickets for premium events: 100–200 is the sweet spot. Makes people want in.
3. Stop the gimmicks: Focus on smooth setup, fast Wi-Fi, and fair hours. Ditch the raffles and speeches.
4. Try the suburbs: Near airports, with shuttles. It works if you plan it right.
5. Split the day: Dealers: 8 AM – 6 PM | Public: 11 AM – 5 PM.
6. Mix in the museum vibe: Add ANA-style exhibits. Pull in collectors with stories, not just sales.

Conclusion: The Future of Coin Shows Is Experience, Not History

The Long Beach fade-out isn’t about poor management. It’s about what people expect now. Collectors want a good time, not a crowd. Dealers want profit, not exposure for exposure’s sake. The shows that survive will be the ones that put people first, keep costs fair, and try smart ideas—not stunts.

The PCGS Irvine show (Oct 22–24, 2025) is the first real test of this new playbook. Will it work? Maybe not perfectly. But it’s trying. And that matters. My guess? Limited access, clear pricing, and dealer support will win. The days of “just park at the mall” are done. The future? Deliberate. Designed. Worth the trip.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Your First Guide to the Last Long Beach Show & Upcoming PCGS Irvine CA Show (Oct 22-24, 2025) – Think of this as your starter pack for understanding a major shift in the coin collecting world: the end of the Long Bea…
• Why the Long Beach Show’s Demise and PCGS Irvine’s Rise Signal a Turning Point in Numismatic Markets – I’ve spent decades walking coin show floors—staring at slabs, shaking hands, and listening. And what I’m seeing now? It’…
• How I Solved the Last Long Beach Show – Update PCGS Irvine CA Show Oct 22-24 2025 in Comments Problem (Step-by-Step Guide) – I spent hours troubleshooting this exact issue—and I finally cracked it. Here’s the real fix that saved my schedule, my …