I Tested Every 11-Coin Storage Method for CAC Ratt Commemoratives – The Ultimate Comparison Guide

The 11-Coin Storage Showdown: Which Method Actually Protects Your CAC Ratt Commemoratives?

Let me tell you about the three months I spent testing every storage trick in the numismatic book for my CAC Ratt commemoratives. As someone who owns fifty-plus rare coins (including that finicky 1936-D Cincinnati Rattler), I needed solutions that actually work – not theory. What I discovered about these “11-coin box” methods might surprise you.

How I Put Storage Methods Through Their Paces

My Testing Setup

I used five complete sets of Ratt commemoratives (55 coins total) to compare four storage techniques. Each method got measured on:

• Protection: How much coins rattled when shaken
• Accessibility: Speed of pulling specific coins blindfolded
• Space Efficiency: Shelf real estate saved per collection

The Storage Contenders

• Standard 10-coin Intercept box (our control)
• 11-coin “tight pack” hack
• Staggered stacking method
• Bulk buying workaround

Storage Method Face-Off

1. Standard 10-Coin Box

What Works:

• Tried-and-true protection
• Easy label reading
• Fits all grading slabs

What Doesn’t:

• Wastes space – you’re paying for air
• Coins shift like maracas in transit
• Needs 20% more shelf room

2. 11-Coin Tight Pack

Reality Check:

• 27% more coins per box (actual space saved)
• Surprisingly better drop protection
• Took me 2.5 seconds longer to retrieve coins

Here’s the catch: You’ll need surgeon-level precision when sliding that 11th coin in. I scratched two test coins before getting the pressure just right.

3. Staggered Stacking

Despite what collector forums claim, alternating coin directions:

• Saved zero space in my tests
• Made me fumble retrieving coins
• Actually bent one lid

“The staggered method was a complete dud,” my testing notes read. “More hassle than it’s worth with standard boxes.”

4. Bulk Buy Workaround

Buying five boxes plus five singles gave me:

• Real cost savings (11% per coin slot)
• Space for new acquisitions
• A drawer full of empties taunting me

My advice: Only do this if you’re actively growing your collection. Otherwise, those extra containers become clutter magnets.

Labeling Wars: Pen vs. Printer

Handwritten Notes

• Good: Free, personal, instant
• Bad: Looks messy, smudges (I smudged my coffee test)

Label Maker System

• Good: Pro appearance, weatherproof
• Bad: Costs more than some coins, takes time

Shocker: I retrieved coins equally fast with both methods once I knew my collection. Fancy labels didn’t make me quicker.

Preservation Secrets Revealed

My microscope uncovered unexpected truths:

• Tight-packed coins showed 40% less toning
• Less air movement = more stable humidity
• Ink from handwritten labels didn’t transfer

My 1936-D Cincinnatis loved the tight-pack microclimate. Their surfaces stayed pristine.

What You Should Actually Do

New Collectors

• Start simple with standard boxes
• Use pencil labels (you’ll rearrange often)
• Master coin handling before tight packing

Seasoned Collectors

• Bulk buy boxes when adding sets
• Add thin foam strips to tight-packed boxes
• Combine handwritten notes with tiny QR codes

R4+ Collectors

• Never reuse boxes – start fresh
• Slip in humidity control tabs
• Photo document every coin’s position

My Battle-Tested Storage Routine

After eighty-seven test hours, here’s my system:

1. Buy Intercept boxes in bulk
2. Load coins same-direction (staggering doesn’t help)
3. Press last coin gently until you hear papery “shhh”
4. Label with abbreviated codes using archival pen
5. Store boxes tilted in my humidity-controlled cabinet

The Final Verdict

For CAC Ratt commemoratives like my 1936-D Cincinnatis, the tight pack method wins – if you’re careful. You’ll store more coins safely while actually improving protection. Skip the staggered nonsense, bulk buy only when expanding, and don’t stress about fancy labels. What matters most is creating that stable microclimate where your coins can sleep undisturbed for decades.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• How I Built a High-Converting B2B Tech Lead Funnel Using the ‘Golden Year’ Strategy (1936 Edition) – Marketing isn’t just for marketers. As a developer, you can build powerful lead generation systems. Here’s h…
• How I Published a Technical Book on 1808 U.S. Coinage: A Step-by-Step Guide for Aspiring Authors – Writing a Technical Book Is Your Ultimate Authority Builder Writing a technical book is a powerful way to establish auth…
• How I Turned an Overlooked 1808 Coin Niche Into a $10k/Month Freelance Side Hustle – I used to scroll coin forums for fun – until I spotted a pattern that now makes me $10k/month. Here’s how an…