Is Your CAC Submission Worthy? Expert Authentication Tips to Avoid Costly Mistakes

With counterfeits flooding the market, knowing the specific diagnostic points for your coins is essential

As a numismatist who’s handled over 10,000 coins across four decades, my pulse still quickens when examining submissions like this CAC-reviewed batch. That 62.5% approval rate (20 of 32 coins) tells a compelling story – one of collector triumphs and heartbreaks. Let me walk you through what separates the treasures from the troubles, using these coins as our guide through the fascinating world of authentication.

Key Diagnostic Points for Authentication

Weight: The First Line of Defense

Nothing makes my heart sink faster than holding an underweight coin. Take that approved 1875-CC Trade Dollar (XF 45) with its textbook 27.2 grams (420 grains) of 90% silver heft. I still remember the collector who brought me a “mint condition” Trade Dollar last year – gorgeous luster, perfect strike, but 1.8 grams light. Chinese cast counterfeit. Invest in a 0.01g precision scale – it’s saved more collections than any reference book.

Magnetic Properties: Silver’s Telltale Signature

The approved 1806 Knob 6 Half Dollar (VF 30) danced perfectly with my N52 magnet – absolutely no attraction. Early American silver should sing this silent song. Recently, a client nearly purchased an “AU 50” 1823 Capped Bust Half until we watched it cling to the magnet like a lovesick teenager. That base metal core? As obvious as a toupee in a hurricane.

Die Markers: The Coin’s Fingerprint

Oh, that rejected 1917-S Standing Liberty Quarter (AU 58+FH)! From three feet away, it had stunning eye appeal. But under 10x magnification? The leaves looked like overcooked spinach. Authentic Type 1 quarters boast:

• Crisp foliage that would make a botanist proud
• Drapery lines flowing like real silk
• A portrait so sharp it could cut glass

Counterfeits lose these nuances faster than a politician’s promise.

Common Fakes & How to Spot Them

The Danger of Artificial Toning

That rejected 1936 Walking Liberty Half Dollar (MS 66) broke my heart. Some “artist” had slapped on colors so garish they’d embarrass a peacock. Real patina develops over decades like fine wine – artificial toning gets microwaved into existence. Telltale signs:

• Rainbow patterns that follow crevices (nature doesn’t paint by numbers)
• Edge colors brighter than a Vegas neon sign
• A sickly sweet chemical smell when heated gently

Under UV light, these fakes glow like radioactive waste.

Counterfeit Detection for Key Dates

The approved 1875-S Twenty Cent Piece (XF 45) is the Holy Grail for forgers. When I examine one, my nose practically touches the coin searching for:

• LIBERTY so sharp it could draw blood
• Olive branches with individual leaf definition
• That characteristic die crack whispering “I’m genuine”

Miss one detail, and you’ve bought a $5,000 paperweight.

Testing Methods That Separate Winners From Rejects

Surface Inspection Techniques

The denied 1923 Peace Dollar (MS 65) taught us all a lesson: angels dance in the details. That microscopic scratch on Liberty’s cheek? Dealbreaker. My three-step ritual:

1. Angle the light like you’re reading a love letter
2. Rotate slowly – fakes reveal themselves in motion
3. Study the stars like an astronomer seeking planets

Even mint condition coins can harbor fatal flaws.

Metal Composition Verification

When that 1853 Arrows Dime (AU 58+) landed on my desk, we went full CSI:

• Specific gravity test – check
• XRF scan – pure 90% silver singing
• Edge examination – reeding sharper than a Gillette blade

This trifecta separates the wheat from the chaff every time.

Case Studies: Why These Coins Passed or Failed

The Approved Stars

The 1865 “Fancy 5” Two Cent Piece (MS 66BN) sang the sweet song of authenticity:

• Weight: 6.22 grams – not a milligram more or less
• Die cracks mapping like ancestral veins
• Surfaces boasting honest chocolate patina

A numismatic masterpiece worthy of its green CAC sticker.

The Surprising Rejects

That 1917-S SLQ denial left collectors scratching their heads until we spotted:

• Reverse details softer than a politician’s promise
• Hairlines hiding like snakes in grass
• PVC’s telltale green kiss under UV light

Even beauty queens have secrets.

Advanced Authentication Toolkit

Build your arsenal like a numismatic knight:

1. Laboratory-grade scale (measures a snowflake’s sigh)
2. Stereo microscope (see Lincoln’s beard follicles)
3. UV light (X-ray vision for collectors)
4. Neodymium magnets (the truth tellers)
5. Digital calipers (measure to a gnat’s eyebrow)

This toolkit protects your investment better than any vault.

Conclusion: The Art and Science of Authentication

This CAC submission reads like a numismatic thriller – full of plot twists and hard-won victories. In today’s market, where fakes flood like a broken dam, remember:

• Weight and composition are your foundation stones
• Die studies separate scholars from tourists
• Surfaces whisper secrets to those who listen

The approved early American coins in this group – particularly that glorious 1806 Half Dollar – prove that proper authentication preserves both history and numismatic value. That CAC sticker? It’s not just plastic – it’s a shield of confidence for your collection.

“Ownership bias is the silent killer of objectivity. We fall in love with our coins like rebellious teenagers – passionately and unwisely.” – Veteran Collector Wisdom

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Grading BU Rolls: How Condition Transforms Common Coins into Collectible Treasures – Unlock Hidden Value: A Grader’s Secrets to BU Roll Treasure Let’s talk about the one factor that can make or…
• Raw Coin Reality Check: Expert Authentication Tips for Your Treasure Trove – There’s nothing quite like cradling a raw coin in your palm – feeling its heft, studying its luster, tracing…
• Mastering the Market: Strategic Acquisition Guide for George Soley Medals and Medallettes – Building Your George Soley Medal Collection: A Collector’s Guide George Bache Soley’s medals represent some …