Why I’ll Never Tone a Gold Coin: Lessons from a Collector’s Nightmare
June 20, 2025My Nifty Nickel Night: Adventures in Collecting Jefferson Nickels
June 20, 2025As a lifelong coin collector, exonumia has always captivated me—those fascinating coin-like pieces that exist just outside traditional currency. Recently, I’ve been exploring this niche more deeply, discovering an entire universe of tokens, medals, and counterstamps that add such richness to my collecting journey. Here are some discoveries and observations from my adventures with these numismatic cousins.
What Exactly is Exonumia?
Think tokens, badges, medals, even wooden nickels—they’re not government-issued money but often carry incredible historical weight. I love how they offer fresh collecting avenues beyond regular coins. Take wooden club nickels, for example: they add such a fun, hands-on dimension to our hobby while preserving club histories.
Exonumia Gems I’ve Encountered
During my searches, several pieces have stopped me in my tracks. A few personal favorites:
- A breathtaking 1776 French jeton showcasing the period’s artistic craftsmanship
- Civil War storecard tokens that feel like holding history from America’s turbulent past
- A Brooklyn Bridge commemorative medal featuring a winged figure—I’ve heard it honors workers who lost their lives during construction
- Encased coins, which fascinate me with their dual stories of coinage and protective casing
- Counterstamped tokens where tiny die variations make each piece uniquely compelling
- An Anaconda mine copper sheet—proof that exonumia isn’t just about traditional metals
Hands-On Collecting Advice
From my experience, here’s what helps when building an exonumia collection:
- Study die types carefully—those subtle differences can mean big value changes. My loupe is always handy!
- Verify authenticity diligently. I once bought a visually appealing fake; now I always cross-check with references
- Handle fragile items like wooden nickels gently—they show wear more easily than metal pieces
- Consider historical context. My 1879 Temperance medal isn’t just beautiful—it whispers stories of social reform
Grading Realities & Market Notes
When assessing exonumia, I focus on condition, strike quality, and scarcity. Well-preserved tokens and medals—especially from limited runs—tend to attract premium prices. Lately, Civil War tokens and French jetons seem particularly hot, with values climbing for crisp examples. Counterstamps are gaining serious collector interest too, making now a great moment to seek them out. Even industrial pieces like copper sheets hold value when tied to important historical narratives.
Exploring exonumia has truly reignited my passion for collecting. I’m constantly amazed by what surfaces next in this field—why not join the hunt? There’s always another story waiting to be uncovered in these extraordinary pieces!