My Deep Dive into the 1831 Large Cent: Surprises and Insights
June 6, 2025My Adventures in the Lucky Large Cent Lounge 2025: Share Your Large Cents Too!
June 6, 2025
As a longtime coin collector, I’ve faced plenty of tough calls about whether to conserve a coin and where to send it for grading. These decisions can really impact a coin’s value, and I’ve picked up some useful insights from my own collecting journey.
When Conservation Makes Sense
Through trial and error, I’ve learned that conservation shines when coins have reversible problems hiding their true character. Take that stubborn green gunk (verdigris) on silver coins—like an 1847 Silver Dollar I once had. Professional removal often reveals beautiful details underneath and might bump up the grade. But for coins that are really beat up—say, a 1795 Large Cent with deep corrosion—I usually leave them alone. The risk of further damage often outweighs any potential gain. Before deciding, I always consider: How rare is it? What’s it worth? Can the flaw actually be fixed? For simple dirt or light toning, sometimes a careful rinse at home does the trick.
Picking the Right Grading Service
Choosing where to send your coins matters, and I’ve tested several services based on cost and skill. Here’s what I’ve found:
- ANACS: They’re conservation experts and offer great bulk rates—like $59 for 10 coins at shows. Not the cheapest for singles, but their conservation work is excellent.
- ICG: Super affordable at around $10 per coin for grading plus $10 for conservation. I’ve been impressed with their careful handling—perfect for coins needing a light touch.
- PCGS and NGC: The top names charge a percentage of value (minimum $25), so save them for your prize pieces. Their slabs add prestige but cost more than everyday coins might justify.
Remember to factor in shipping and fees—group submissions can save cash, and always check for current deals before sending anything.
Tips for New Collectors
If you’re just starting out, keep it simple: Ask yourself if fixing a coin will actually increase its value. That Silver Dollar with surface crud? Probably worth it. A battered Large Cent? Likely not. I always get my better coins certified—it protects their value whether you’re selling or passing them down. Go slow, watch how the market moves, and only conserve when it’ll genuinely improve the coin. Happy hunting! Every piece has its own history, and caring for it thoughtfully just deepens the joy of collecting.
