Unearthing the Truth: The Oldest Coin Minted in the New World?
July 14, 2025My Adventure with the New Horizon 2025 Vault Box
July 14, 2025I just cracked open the Vaultbox Horizon 2025 series, and let me tell you – what a ride! As someone who lives for the thrill of mystery boxes, this unboxing taught me plenty about taking chances, grading surprises, and that sweet satisfaction of filling gaps in my type sets. Grab your loupe and join me as I walk through this adventure.
The Weighty Clues
When my five boxes landed on the doorstep, I couldn’t help playing detective. I grabbed my scale, thinking coin weights might hint at the treasures inside. Here’s how they stacked up:
- Box 1: 127.7 grams – nickel territory for sure
- Box 2: 151.6 grams – screamed silver dollar
- Box 3: 136.4 grams – half dollar candidate
- Box 4: 150.4 grams – another silver dollar whisper
- Box 5: 131.4 grams – quarter dollar vibes
Weighing them definitely upped the anticipation, but we all know packaging can throw things off. Still, it’s part of the fun – like shaking Christmas presents!
Diving Into the Boxes
I started with Box 1, the lightest. Boom – 1883 Cents Nickel graded MS63, NGC value around $300. Not a jackpot, but a solid piece with great details that’ll nestle nicely in my collection. Box 2? Gorgeous coin but a financial ouch – let’s just say I winced. Box 3 landed better, but at this point I was averaging maybe half my cost back. When Box 4 showed a flash of red core through the seal (you know what that means!), I chickened out and jumped to Box 5 – another red core! The suspense shattered my willpower and I ripped them all open at once. Probably dumb for my bank account, but oh so satisfying.
The Full Reveal
So what did $1,875 get me? Here’s the haul:
- That 1883 Nickel (about $300)
- A stunning 1923 Peace Dollar with hair details so sharp they could cut glass
- A 1937-S Mercury Dime that made me gasp
- Plus others that plugged holes in my type sets
Total NGC value? $1,880 – dead even! Four coins filled empty slots in my albums, and the fifth upgrades a current holder. For me, that’s a win – saved me months of hunting. That Peace Dollar? Absolute showstopper. Puts those flat-haired Morgans to shame.
Grading Surprises
Now here’s a head-scratcher: they slabbed one Morgan as XF45, but the bands look fuller than any I’ve seen at that grade. Honestly? I’d call it AU50 or AU53 easy – which would triple its value from $45 to over $100. Pro tip: If you land an undergraded coin, sit tight before resubmitting. Fresh slabs need time to settle in the market. Circle back in six months – might be worth the gamble.
Collecting Insights and Market Observations
This whole experience hammered home some truths. First: filling type set holes feels like victory, even at break-even. Second: NGC values don’t always match reality. That $300 nickel? Recent auctions put it closer to $175. The dime? Actually pulled $500+ at Heritage. Always check actual sales data before celebrating. As for Vaultboxes – love the rush, but keep your hopes grounded. Most boxes won’t make you rich, and you’re stuck with whatever comes out. New collectors: start small and only bite if the theme excites you.
Lessons Learned
After all this, here’s what I’d tell fellow collectors:
- Manage expectations: Treat mystery boxes as entertainment, not retirement plans. If you fill collection gaps, call it a win.
- Savor the suspense: Unlike my impatient binge, stretch out the fun!
- Study the slabs: Grading surprises happen – spot undervalued coins by comparing to recent sales.
- Know your budget: At $400 a pop, this is champagne collecting. Only play if you love the game.
All told? I had an absolute blast with Horizon 2025. It reminded me why we do this – every coin tells a story, and sometimes the hunt’s the best part. If you take the plunge, drop me a line – I’d love to hear about your scores and stumbles!