Smart Buying Guide: How to Buy Call on bag of 1960 Lincoln cents with an official tag of being defective Without Getting Ripped Off

Understanding This Unusual 1960 Lincoln Cent Bag

If you’re looking to add this to your collection, you need a strategy to get the best deal. The case of a bag of 1960 Lincoln cents allegedly tagged as defective presents a unique opportunity with significant risks. Before diving into where to buy and how to negotiate, it’s essential to understand what makes this offering so unusual and potentially problematic.

Historical Context and Authenticity Concerns

In 1960, Lincoln cents were produced at multiple U.S. Mint facilities, including Philadelphia (no mint mark), Denver (D), and San Francisco (S). The 1960 cent was minted in copper (95% copper, 5% tin and zinc) and weighs 3.11 grams. Standard mint bags contained $50 face value (5,000 coins) and were sewn shut with official mint tags.

The claim that these cents were tagged as “defective” and set aside for disposal raises immediate red flags. The U.S. Mint’s modern disposal process involves melting down rejected coins under strict supervision, not bagging them for potential diversion. As one forum member noted, “If they sent the cents out for scrap, someone in the chain of custody could have grabbed a bag.” This suggests the possibility of theft or mishandling rather than legitimate defective coins.

Red Flags to Watch For

Several warning signs should make any potential buyer proceed with extreme caution:

• Unverified Claims: The bag’s origin story relies entirely on the seller’s word, with no documentation or provenance available.
• Missing Visual Evidence: Multiple forum members have requested pictures, which the seller has not provided despite multiple requests.
• Questionable Packaging: As one expert pointed out, “If the bag is never opened, how do we know that the coins are defective? If the bag is opened, how do we know who put what in it?”
• Economic Inconsistency: Standard 1960 cent bags (even opened ones) sell for around $400 on eBay, while 5,000 error coins would be worth substantially more, creating a suspicious pricing gap.

Where to Buy: Navigating the Market

Given the red flags, the safest approach is to avoid direct private purchases until more information is available. Consider these alternatives:

• Reputable Dealers: Established coin dealers with proper credentials can verify authenticity and provide guarantees.
• Certified Marketplaces: Platforms like Heritage Auctions or GreatCollections offer buyer protection and authentication services.
• Local Coin Shows: These events allow you to examine items in person and consult with multiple experts before purchasing.

Raw vs. Slabbed: The Authentication Dilemma

For this particular item, the question of raw versus slabbed becomes critical. Since the bag allegedly contains 5,000 coins, breaking it open for individual slabbing would destroy its collectible value as a complete unit. However, the lack of authentication for a raw bag creates significant risk.

Ideally, you’d want a third-party authentication of the bag itself (verifying it’s a genuine 1960 mint bag with proper seals) without opening it. Some professional grading services can authenticate sealed bags and provide a grade based on the condition of the bag and its contents’ appearance through X-ray or other non-invasive methods.

Negotiating Tips for This Unique Situation

If you decide to proceed despite the risks, employ these negotiation strategies:

1. Start with Documentation: Insist on seeing the original tag and any paperwork before discussing price.
2. Request Expert Verification: Offer to split the cost of having a professional numismatist examine the bag in person.
3. Price Based on Worst-Case Scenario: If the bag contains ordinary 1960 cents, what’s your maximum price? Start negotiations below that figure.
4. Include Contingencies: Make your offer contingent on authentication and the bag remaining sealed until verification is complete.
5. Consider the Time Value: The seller has held this item for years without selling it. This desperation can be leveraged in negotiations.

Due Diligence Before Purchase

Before making any commitment, conduct thorough due diligence:

• Verify the Seller’s Identity: The original poster mentioned having the seller’s phone number from when he previously brought it to a shop. Confirm this information independently.
• Research Similar Sales: While opened bags sell for around $400, understand that this sealed bag (if legitimate) would command a premium.
• Consult Multiple Experts: Get opinions from at least three knowledgeable numismatists about the bag’s authenticity and value.
• Consider Legal Implications: If the coins were legitimately disposed of by the mint, they might be considered stolen property, creating legal complications for the buyer.

Final Thoughts on Collectibility

The 1960 Lincoln cent bag presents a fascinating puzzle for collectors. While the story of defective coins set aside for disposal is highly unusual and likely problematic, the bag itself could still have value as a numismatic curiosity or historical artifact. Whether it contains ordinary cents, rare varieties, or something in between, the mystery adds to its appeal for certain collectors.

However, the lack of verifiable information, the suspicious circumstances of its acquisition, and the significant questions about its contents make this a high-risk purchase. Unless you’re prepared to potentially lose your entire investment or become embroiled in legal issues, this might be a case where the smartest buying strategy is to walk away.

For those who do proceed, remember that in numismatics, as in all collecting, the cardinal rule remains: buy the coin, not the story. In this case, that means demanding proof before paying, regardless of how compelling the tale might be.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• The 1960 Lincoln Cent Bag: A Coin Ring Artisan’s Perspective – Introduction: A Curious Discovery When I received a call about a bag of 1960 Lincoln cents supposedly tagged as defectiv…
• The Critical Importance of Proper Storage for 1960 Lincoln Cent Collections – Introduction: Protecting Your Investment for Future Generations Over the years, I’ve witnessed countless valuable …
• Grading Call on bag of 1960 Lincoln cents with an official tag of being defective: The Difference Between $10 and $1,000 – The Mysterious Bag of 1960 Lincoln Cents Condition is everything. Here’s how to examine the high points and fields…