The Hidden Signals in Charmy’s 2025 Great American Coin Show Report: What the Data Reveals About the Future of Numismatics

I’ll admit it – when I first read Charmy’s show report, I focused on the shiny coins. But after stepping back, I noticed something far more telling: the subtle signals pointing to where our hobby is headed.

The 2025 Rosemont/Chicago Great American Coin Show wasn’t just another numismatic event. It was a real-time snapshot of a market undergoing significant changes. While the photos of rare coins, PCGS slabs, and Gibson’s dinners grabbed headlines, the real insights came from what wasn’t immediately obvious. The lines, the conversations, even the frustrations – they all reveal fascinating truths about the health, direction, and future of American coin collecting. The surge in public attendance, the dynamics between dealers and customers, and the rise of unique experiences – these are the threads weaving the next chapter of numismatics.

1. The Attendance Surge: Why Crowds at Coin Shows Matter More Than You Think

The image of a “very long line” of people waiting to get in on Thursday is more than just a photo op. It’s a powerful economic indicator. Think about it: why would collectors spend time, money, and effort to attend a coin show? When public turnout hits record highs, it tells us a lot:

• People have money to spend: Travel, entry fees, and potential purchases aren’t trivial expenses.
• Confidence is high: They believe it’s a good time to buy, sell, or trade – a sign of market optimism.
• They want the real thing: Physical interaction with coins is back in a big way, not just online browsing.

Beyond the Turnstiles: What the Crowds Really Signal

This isn’t isolated to Rosemont. It’s part of a broader “return to physical” movement in niche markets. For collectors, investors, and dealers, this means a few important things:

• Shows are now primary marketplaces: They’re not just for socializing anymore. This impacts how we think about marketing, booth setup, and even show logistics.
• Impulse buys drive high-margin sales: Remember the 1856 Flying Eagle cent and 1955/55 Double Die Lincoln cent sales? Those weren’t just luck. High foot traffic and the ability to see a coin’s “toning” and “luster” in person make all the difference.
• It’s a timing signal: For investors, this suggests we’re in a “buyer’s market” phase – supply is strong (dealers selling), and demand is rising (public attending).

For your next show: Don’t just show up – watch the crowd. Are they young? New to collecting? Buying from multiple dealers? This tells you about market segments. Track it: create a simple show_attendance_scorecard.xlsx to log turnout, dealer density, and average transaction size. Use it to plan inventory and pricing.

2. The “1943 Copper” Moment: When Trust Becomes the Biggest Market Friction

That interaction with the customer holding a “1943 copper” cent (deemed counterfeit by PCGS) isn’t just a single frustration. It’s a symptom of a much bigger issue: how trust breaks down in the authentication process. This is the silent killer of market efficiency.

The Technical Hurdle: Why Third-Party Grading Feels Opaque

The customer’s skepticism – “they could have switched the coin” – cuts to the core. PCGS, NGC, and others are the “gatekeepers” of value, but their process often feels like a black box. This creates real problems:

• Information asymmetry: The customer feels like the grading company has an unfair advantage, making them question the result.
• Added friction: Seeking a second opinion (like going to Andy at Angel Dees) takes time, costs money, and isn’t guaranteed.
• Market delays: A coin’s value gets stuck in limbo while the owner verifies the grade.

The “diagnostic” article the narrator carries is a clever workaround, but it’s not a real solution. The future? Blockchain-based grading. Imagine:

<
• Every coin scanned, with data (weight, composition, die markers) recorded on a blockchain when submitted.

<

• Grading process recorded on video and stored.

<

• Final grade and supporting data linked directly to the coin’s unique ID.

Code snippet for a basic blockchain concept (Ethereum/Solidity):


// Simplified coin grading record on blockchain
contract CoinGrading {
struct Grade {
string coinID;
string gradingCompany;
string grade;
string supportingDataHash; // Hash of video/data
uint256 timestamp;
}
mapping(string => Grade) public grades;

function submitGrade(string memory _coinID, string memory _gradingCompany, string memory _grade, string memory _dataHash) public {
grades[_coinID] = Grade(_coinID, _gradingCompany, _grade, _dataHash, block.timestamp);
}
}


The Real Cost: Time, Emotion, and Lost Sales

For dealers, this isn’t just about a single coin. It’s about the hidden cost of managing customer trust. The narrator’s frustration – “they think we don’t know what we’re doing” – is something every dealer knows. It’s the emotional labor of proving expertise while handling skepticism. In a market where high-value items (like a true 1943 copper cent) are rare, the cost of a false positive (rejecting a real coin) or a false negative (accepting a fake) is huge.

Practical fix: Invest in trust-building. This isn’t just about carrying articles. It’s about creating a “trust infrastructure”:

• Offer quick, free verification (like a magnet test for copper cents) at your table.
• Create a “counterfeit education kit” with photos, videos, and common red flags (think: weight, metal composition, strike quality).
• Partner with TPGs to get simple “explainers” on their process – make it transparent, not mysterious.

3. The Social Network: How Relationships Drive Value in Numismatics

Those photos of Rick Snow, Peter Treglia, Chad Stachowicz, Justin Waddel, James Sego, PCGS, ANACS, and CAC reps aren’t just social media fodder. They’re a map of the entire numismatic ecosystem. The dinners, the conversations, the moments on the bourse floor – they show how value flows.

The “Ecosystem Effect”: Why It’s Not Just About the Coins

The market isn’t just about buying and selling. It’s built on relationships, trust, and shared knowledge. Think of it like this:

• Core nodes: Dealers like Rick Snow – they’re hubs of information, inventory, and connections.
• Peripheral nodes: Collectors, TPGs, and other dealers who connect to the core for expertise and inventory.
• Value transfer: Coins move from core to periphery (dealers to collectors), but knowledge flows both ways (collectors share finds, dealers advise on trends, TPGs validate authenticity).

The dinner at Gibson’s with James Sego, Justin Waddel, and Curt Mease? That’s not just a meal. It’s a knowledge exchange. Justin showing off a “stunning toner 1885-O Morgan dollar” isn’t bragging – it’s a demonstration of expertise. The narrator sharing it in the report validates Justin’s skill, building his reputation and, by extension, his market value.

The Rise of the “Influencer Dealer” and Why It Matters

This ecosystem is changing. The narrator’s plan to write for *Coin World* and the photo of “DavidK7 from the forums” point to a trend: dealers are becoming influencers. They’re not just selling coins – they’re building personal brands, creating content, and cultivating communities. For collectors and investors:

• Dealers with strong reputations command premium prices (think: “Rick Snow’s table” vs. a generic dealer).
• Collectors seek expertise – they want dealers who can validate authenticity, spot trends, and provide context.
• TPGs rely on dealer networks – a coin graded by PCGS is more trusted if a respected dealer has also examined it.

Practical fix: If you’re a dealer, build your brand. This isn’t just social media. It’s about:

• Writing articles, giving talks, or creating content that shows off your expertise.
• Building relationships with collectors, other dealers, and TPGs – it’s a network effect.
• Using shows as “content labs” – capture videos, photos, and stories to share later.

4. The Shipwreck and the Art: Why “Experience” Is the New Premium

The Central American shipwreck display and Robert Julian’s hand-drawn coin artwork aren’t just “nice additions.” They’re strategic differentiators. In a market where coins are increasingly standardized (PCGS slabs, online auctions), the unique, the rare, and the experiential are becoming the most valuable.

The “Experience Economy” and the Shift in Value

The shipwreck display isn’t just about antique coins – it’s about storytelling, history, and rarity. Robert Julian’s art isn’t just about aesthetics – it’s about creating a personal connection. For collectors and investors, this means:

• Experiential items command premium prices (shipwreck coins, historically significant pieces, handcrafted art).
• They attract non-traditional collectors – people who value history, art, or storytelling more than just the coin itself.
• They create “buzz”** – the photos of the shipwreck and Julian’s art got specific mentions, increasing their visibility and value.

Practical fix: If you’re a dealer or collector, think beyond the slab. Curate experiences, not just coins:

• Seek out coins with provenance – shipwreck finds, historically significant pieces, or coins with a documented history.
• Invest in artistic or handcrafted items – hand-drawn art, custom display cases, or even unique packaging.
• Create “story packages” for high-value coins – include the history, how you acquired it, and the context. Make it desirable.

The Future of Numismatics: Human, Hybrid, and Experiential

The 2025 Rosemont show wasn’t just a success – it was a blueprint. The key insights are clear:

1. Public attendance is the best market indicator. Focus on shows with high turnout and study the crowd.
2. Trust is the biggest friction point. Solve it with transparency (blockchain grading) and education (customer kits).
3. The ecosystem drives value. Build your personal brand and cultivate relationships.
4. Experience differentiates. Focus on stories, history, and art, not just the coins themselves.

For dealers, collectors, and investors, the message is clear: the numismatic market is evolving from a commodity-driven model to a human-driven, experience-based economy. The coins will always be the foundation, but the future belongs to those who understand these signals, build trust, and create compelling stories.

The next show? It’s not just about the coins. It’s about the data you gather, the relationships you strengthen, and the experiences you create. That’s what Charmy’s report – and the careful analysis of these hidden signals – truly reveals about the future of our hobby.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Show and Tell: My Exonumia Collection Journey – Lately, I’ve been spending more time with exonumia, and what a fascinating world it’s opened up! Tokens, med…
• My Journey Through Exonumia: Tokens, Medals, and Hidden Treasures – I’ve been diving into the fascinating world of exonumia lately—those coin-like objects like tokens, medals, and co…
• How I Solved the Post-Coin Show Report Dilemma: Turning 100+ Pictures Into a Cohesive Story (Step-by-Step Guide) – I stared at my phone after the 2025 Rosemont/Chicago Great American Coin Show—over 100 photos, scribbled notes, and a gr…