What is the Real Value of Collis Restrike Whereabouts in Today’s Market?

Historical Significance

The true value of these pieces lies beyond catalog prices—it’s found in understanding their place in American numismatic history. In 1959, Albert Collis created transfer dies from the original Washington Born Virginia medal dies, producing restrikes in multiple metals with extremely limited mintages. These restrikes have become coveted collectibles, bridging colonial-era American numismatics with modern commemorative pieces and telling a fascinating story of American heritage.

Identifying Key Markers

Collis restrikes can be identified by their distinctive uniface design and metal-specific characteristics. Historical records show remarkably low mintages: Platinum (1), Lead (1), Gold (7), Silver (22), and Copper (5,019). Copper versions are most commonly encountered, while precious metal variants are exceptionally rare. The pieces feature a right-facing bust of Washington with “WASHINGTON BORN VIRGINIA” inscription on the obverse, while the reverse remains intentionally blank, honoring the original design.

Current Market Prices

Recent auction results reveal a clear value hierarchy based on metal content and rarity. Copper examples, despite being most available, still command hundreds of dollars, with exceptional specimens reaching $500-700. Silver restrikes have shown particularly strong performance, with certified high-grade examples selling for $2,000-3,000. The gold restrikes, with only seven believed to exist, represent the pinnacle of the series, though their extreme rarity makes specific pricing data scarce.

Auction Results Analysis

Historical auction data offers crucial insights into market trends. The significant Bowers & Merena April 1986 sale (S Levine) included 40 copper examples in 5 lots, 15 off-center copper pieces in 7 lots, 6 silver pieces (1 per lot), and 3 gold pieces (1 per lot). This sale demonstrated varied collector interest across different variants. A 2022 silver specimen sale showed continued strong demand, with prices remaining robust compared to earlier decades.

Investment Potential

Investment potential varies significantly by metal type. Copper examples, while historically important, offer limited upside due to their higher survival rate. Silver restrikes represent the sweet spot for investors, combining historical significance, rarity, and precious metal content. Gold restrikes, while potentially offering the highest returns, require significant capital and carry substantial risk due to extreme rarity and the limited pool of potential buyers.

Factors Driving Value Up or Down

Several factors influence current market values. The condition of the piece plays a crucial role, with well-preserved examples commanding significant premiums. Metal type naturally affects value, with precious metal variants commanding higher prices. Provenance can also impact value, particularly for pieces with documented histories or those from notable collections. Market trends in colonial and early American numismatics affect demand, with increased interest potentially driving prices higher.

Authentication and Certification

Given these pieces’ value and historical significance, authentication is crucial. Professional grading services like PCGS have certified examples, with their population reports showing very low numbers for silver variants. The certification process helps establish authenticity and condition—critical factors in determining market value. Collectors should be particularly cautious of counterfeits or altered pieces, given the high values commanded by genuine examples.

Market Availability and Future Outlook

Availability of Collis restrikes in today’s market is limited, particularly for precious metal variants. Copper examples occasionally appear in online auctions and dealer inventories, while silver and gold pieces are rarely offered. This scarcity, combined with growing interest in colonial-era American numismatics, suggests a positive outlook for values, particularly for rarer variants. However, the market remains relatively niche, and values can be volatile based on when pieces become available.

Collecting Strategies

For collectors interested in acquiring Collis restrikes, a strategic approach is recommended. Copper examples offer an accessible entry point for those interested in historical significance without the high price tag of precious metal variants. Silver restrikes represent a balanced option for those seeking rarity and potential appreciation. Gold examples should be considered only by advanced collectors with significant resources and a long-term investment horizon.

Conclusion

Collis restrikes represent a unique opportunity in American numismatics, offering collectors pieces with direct connections to colonial-era history at various price points. While copper examples provide historical significance at accessible prices, precious metal variants offer rarity and potential investment value. As with any collectible investment, thorough research, authentication, and a clear understanding of market dynamics are essential for making informed decisions in this specialized area of numismatics.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Finding 1959 George Washington Steel Restrike Impressions in the Wild: A Cherry Picker’s Guide – Uncovering Hidden Treasures in Circulation You don’t always need a dealer to find this. Here is what to look for w…
• Crafting Potential: Can This 1959 George Washington Steel Restrike Be Made Into Jewelry? – Understanding This Unique Washington Restrike As a coin ring artisan, I’m often asked about unusual pieces like th…
• Preserving Your 1959 George Washington Steel Restrike: A Conservationist’s Guide – Understanding Your Steel Restrike’s Historical Context The 1959 George Washington Born Virginia medal restrikes re…