1917 Buffalo Nickel Authentication Guide: Spotting Counterfeits in the Wild

With Counterfeits Circulating, Your 1917 Buffalo Nickel Needs This Forensic Eye

Friends, if your coin cabinet holds a 1917 Buffalo Nickel or you’re hunting one, lean in close. As lifelong authentication specialists, we’ve watched counterfeiters evolve from crude fakers to frighteningly skilled artists. The Philadelphia issue discussed across forums this month? It’s ground zero for why we must sharpen our skills to surgical precision. That “quirky” detail you’re admiring could be a rare variety doubling your investment – or the heartbreak of a well-disguised fake.

Why the 1917 Buffalo Nickel Earned Its Place in History

James Earle Fraser’s masterpiece doesn’t just sit in our albums – it carries the spirit of the American frontier. The composite Native American portrait whispers stories of diverse nations, while Black Diamond the bison embodies raw wilderness. Though 51 million left Philadelphia’s presses, time has been cruel. Finding one with original luster dancing across its fields? That’s where the numismatic value soars. Even circulated examples whisper tales if you know how to listen.

The Naked-Eye Test Won’t Cut It: Key Authentication Markers

1. Weight & Composition – Your First Truth Detector

Place nothing less than a jeweler’s scale between you and disaster. Authentic 1917 specimens breathe at 5.00 grams ±0.20g – a heartbeat separating treasure from trash. Deviations often expose:

• Alloy imposters (true 75% copper, 25% nickel sings when dropped)
• Casting’s telltale porosity beneath magnification
• Strategic overweighting mimicking honest wear

Remember: Grams are gospel. Anything beyond 4.80-5.20g deserves suspicion.

2. Magnet Test – The Invisible Handshake

Slide a neodymium magnet across your suspect. Feel that? Nothing? Breathe easier. Authentic Buffalo Nickels exhibit zero magnetic attraction – a silent nod to pedigree. Even slight pull signals iron contaminants screaming “fake!”

3. Die Poetry – Reading the Buffalo’s Hooves Like Tea Leaves

Here’s where collectors separate from casuals. That forum debate about the buffalo’s front leg? Let’s decode it:

• Genuine 1917 Hallmarks: Three crisp toes standing proud; tendon definition sharper than a Bowie knife
• Danger Signs Whispering “Forgery”:
  • Horizontal striations from overzealous die polishing
  • “Weak hoof” syndrome from exhausted dies
  • Struck-through errors flattening details like prairie grass

Know Your Enemy: The Counterfeit Hall of Shame

Cast Fakes – Amateur Hour with Expensive Tickets

These insult our intelligence but still snag newcomers. Spot them by their:

• Feather tips softer than grandma’s butter knife
• “Orange peel” surfaces screaming “cast me!”
• FIVE CENTS spacing tighter than a Gilded Age corset

Struck Fakes – Wolves in Sheep’s Clothing

Modern dies make these terrifyingly convincing. Outsmart them by examining:

• Die polish lines dancing against period-correct patterns
• Edge reeding counts (118-124 teeth – count every last one!)
• The 1917 date’s distinctive “1” crossbar – too thick? Sound the alarm

From Hobbyist to Expert: Your Authentication Toolkit

Stage 1: The Loupe’s Embrace – Seeing Beyond the Naked Eye

Press your 10x loupe against the glass like a lover’s letter. Hunt for:

• LIBERTY’s headband details sharper than a banker’s suit
• Buffalo horn tips that could puncture rawhide
• Date positioning floating perfectly in its field

Stage 2: Measuring History – When Fractions of Millimeters Matter

Break out the calipers! Authenticity lives in:

• 21.2mm diameter – not a hair more or less
• 1.95mm rim thickness – precision matters
• Edge curvature subtle as a Wyoming sunset

Stage 3: Calling in the Cavalry – When Your Gut Says “Verify”

For coins whispering doubts, deploy:

• XRF analysis reading alloy like a DNA test
• Electrostatic conductivity checks feeling the metal’s soul
• Microscopic autopsies revealing tooling’s dirty secrets

Mystery Solved: The Forum’s “Interesting Buffalo” Revealed

Remember that debated 1917 with the distorted leg? After sleepless nights and coffee-fueled examinations, we conclude:

• Probably Real: Wear patterns matching honest pocket journeys
• Plot Twist Potential: Grease strike-through error adding character
• No Red Flags: Clean magnetic response and natural patina development

“Assume every mark is damage until proven otherwise. Those 1917 dies saw more polishing than a Fifth Avenue doorknob – learn their scars better than your own reflection.”
– Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) Examiner Field Notes

Grading’s Gavel: How Condition Commands Your Coin’s Destiny

Watch how a single point changes everything:

• Good (G-4): $2-$4 – history you can hold
• Very Fine (VF-20): $10-$15 – details emerging from the mist
• Extremely Fine (EF-40): $25-$40 – the sweet spot for budget collectors
• Mint State (MS-63): $150-$250 – where luster makes hearts race

Counterfeiters adore VF-EF clones – just worn enough to hide their sins.

Final Wisdom: Guarding Your Collection’s Legacy

The 1917 Buffalo Nickel isn’t just metal – it’s a bronze-and-nickel time machine. Protect yours with these battle-tested rules:

1. Weight discrepancies? Walk away faster than Custer from Sitting Bull
2. Study genuine die markers until you dream in three-toed buffalo hooves
3. Still uneasy? PCGS/NGC submission isn’t surrender – it’s wisdom

Arm yourself with knowledge, and your collection will stand as unshakable as the Black Hills. Happy hunting, fellow time travelers.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• 1917 Buffalo Nickel Errors: A Hunter’s Guide to Die Cracks, Varieties & Hidden Value – Most folks walk past tiny details that can transform pocket change into rare treasures worth thousands. As an error coin…
• The 1917 Buffalo Nickel: Witness to America’s Industrial Ascent and Artistic Ideals – Hold history in your palm. The 1917 Buffalo nickel sparking collector debates isn’t just pocket change – it&…
• What is the Real Value of an Interesting Buffalo Nickel? An Appraiser’s Market Analysis – Market Analysis: Beyond the Book Price Any seasoned collector knows the real thrill lies beyond printed price guides. Wh…