1968 Double Eagles: When Gold Hoarders Drove Prices Beyond Melt Value

When the Gold Inside Outshines the Face Value

As both a bullion stacker and history enthusiast, few stories quicken my pulse like the 1968 scramble for $20 Double Eagles. Picture this: collectors and investors paying nearly double gold’s spot price for coins that had been contraband just years earlier! This extraordinary moment reveals the eternal dance between melt value and numismatic value – a tango every serious collector should understand. Let’s examine how metal content, fear, and collectibility collided to create one of gold’s most fascinating chapters.

1968: The Perfect Storm for Double Eagles

That March 1968 New York Times article didn’t just report news – it captured gold bugs in full frenzy. With international markets in chaos, $20 Saints (both Saint-Gaudens and Liberty Heads) suddenly became the hottest tickets in town. Imagine department stores like Gimbel’s and legendary dealers like Stack’s literally closing their doors as prices soared:

• Stack’s regular $50 price leaping to $82 overnight
• Underground dealers commanding nearly $100 per coin
• Retailers pulling inventory entirely as shelves emptied

All this madness happened while gold remained officially pegged at $35/oz! Each Double Eagle’s 0.9675 troy ounces meant a melt value around $33.86. Yet buyers happily paid 142-195% premiums. Why? Two explosive factors ignited this powder keg:

“The legal nuance in that article fascinated me – how 1954 loopholes transformed these from illegal contraband to coveted collectibles overnight”

After FDR’s 1933 recall, private gold ownership remained forbidden until collectors carved out exemptions. By ’68, savvy buyers recognized Double Eagles as legal gold with glorious provenance – tangible safe havens when paper currencies trembled.

Metal Meets Artistry: The Double Eagle’s Allure

Golden Anatomy of a Masterpiece

Every $20 Double Eagle whispers secrets of American craftsmanship:

• 90% pure gold glowing with deep luster
• 10% copper alloy giving durability without sacrificing eye appeal
• Total weight: 33.44 grams (1.075 troy oz)
• Pure gold content: 30.09 grams (0.9675 troy oz)

This precise composition makes melt calculations simple: Spot price x 0.9675 = base value. At 1968’s fixed $35 gold, that meant $33.86 melt value – yet collectors eagerly paid $82-$100! Today’s free-floating gold market creates entirely different dynamics for these magnificent coins.

When Premiums Defied Gravity

That 1968 frenzy shows sentiment trumping fundamentals. Compare key moments:

*1968 dollars adjusted for inflation
Data sources: Collector forums, BLS CPI calculator

Modern stackers enjoy negative premiums on common Saints – a world apart from 1968’s mania. This stark contrast proves why historical context matters in every acquisition strategy.

Wisdom From the Gold Frenzy: Three Timeless Lessons

Lesson #1: Buy When the Crowd Snoozes

Forum member @CaptHenway’s story speaks volumes:

“In May ’66, I plucked a BU Saint from Detroit dealer Earl Schill for $50… Sold it years later for college tuition at $55.”

His $50 investment carried a 47.7% premium pre-crisis. Had he held until ’68’s peak, he’d have doubled his money! The takeaway? Accumulate when premiums compress during quiet markets. As @jmlanzaf wisely notes:

“That same $50 in ’68’s S&P 500 would now be $18,500.”

While stocks outperformed long-term, gold’s 1968 spike offered spectacular exits – a reminder to rebalance when premiums detach from reality.

Lesson #2: Legal Status Dictates Collectibility

Ownership laws created the perfect collectibility storm:

• Pre-1933: Most gold recalled; only rare coins exempt
• 1954-1974: Collectible coins legalized; bars still banned
• Post-1974: All gold forms liberated

This explains why ’68 buyers fixated on Saints – they were gold you could actually own! Today’s stackers enjoy freedom but should still understand how legal history impacts numismatic value.

Lesson #3: Favor Liquid Coins Over Obscure Rarities

For bullion purposes, prioritize Saints with:

• Strong eye appeal (that iconic Saint-Gaudens strike!)
• Standardized weights dealers recognize instantly
• Minimal collector premiums

Common dates in XF-AU often trade 5-10% over melt – far below ’68’s insanity. For easiest liquidation, target:

• 1924 Philadelphia issues (no mintmark, plentiful)
• 1928-D (Denver’s workhorse output)
• Avoid 1927-D and 1930-S – their rare variety status commands premiums

Value Through Time: Melt vs. Market

1968’s Price Rollercoaster

Piecing together forum memories and period sources:

• Pre-crisis norm: $48-$50 (Coin World ads)
• ’66 smart money: $50 (@CaptHenway)
• ’68 peak frenzy: $75 (Gimbel’s) to $100 (backroom deals)
• Aftermath: $55 within two years

Adjusted for inflation, that $100 peak equals $875 today – more than double current prices! Proof that temporary panic creates prime selling opportunities.

Today’s Valuation Realities

With gold at $2,350/oz:

• Melt Value: $2,275
• Market Reality (Common Dates): $2,250-$2,325
• Key Date Collectibility:
  • 1920-S: +$5,000 (legendary rarity)
  • 1927-D: +$2,500 (low mintage beauty)
  • 1930-S: +$1,500 (final year premium)

Unlike ’68, today’s market sometimes prices common Saints below melt due to dealer costs – a stacking gift our forebears never saw!

Conclusion: Two Worlds in One Coin

The 1968 gold panic teaches us that Double Eagles live dual lives:

1. Bullion anchors securing tangible wealth
2. Historical documents preserving monetary drama
3. Sentiment barometers reflecting human nature

For modern collectors, $20 Saints offer golden versatility: commodity value with a numismatic safety net, yet liquid enough to capitalize on future frenzies. As the ’66-’68 swing proves, methodical collectors who build positions in calm markets harvest rewards when chaos returns.

“I longed to own one, but my wallet wept.” – Anonymous forum member on 1960s Saint prices

Don’t let history repeat itself as personal regret. Accumulate common-date Saints when premiums dip, preserving resources for market dislocations. Because as 1968 reminds us – when gold whispers, wise collectors listen… regardless of face value.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Preserving History: Expert Conservation Strategies for 1968 Gold Double Eagles – We’ve all winced at the sight of a heritage coin stripped of its luster by well-meaning but misguided care. Let&#8…
• Grading Lessons from the Sunshire Rarities Controversy: How Condition Separates $10 Junk from $1,000 Treasures – Condition Is Everything: A Professional Grader’s Perspective In our world of numismatics, condition isn’t ju…
• The Collector’s Playbook: Acquiring 19th-Century Proof Coins Without Overpaying – Mastering the Hunt: Acquiring 19th-Century Proof Coins Building a collection of 19th-century proof coins requires more t…