Counting My Precious Metals: A Deep Dive into Gold and Platinum Coin Collections
June 18, 2025Why You Should Never Tone a Gold Coin: A Collector’s Hard-Earned Lesson
June 18, 2025I’ve been fascinated by the SS Central America shipwreck and its numismatic treasures ever since I first saw that incredible rust impression of an 1857-S double eagle. The way it weaves together history, science, and collecting is something I just had to share with fellow enthusiasts.
The Shipwreck’s Golden Legacy
When the SS Central America went down off South Carolina in 1857, it took tons of California gold with it – including stacks of San Francisco double eagles. What happened next still amazes me: iron from the ship slowly formed goethite rust layers on those gold coins over decades. When salvagers finally brought them up, the rust had captured perfect surface details like a time capsule.
The Magic of Goethite Rust Images
Here’s the part that hooked me: Sometimes that rust flakes off intact, creating mirror images of the coins. I’ll never forget seeing an 1857-S double eagle flake showing every detail – even the original luster frozen in iron oxide. It’s like nature made its own coin cast. Makes you wonder how many more of these natural wonders are waiting to be found.
Restoration and Preservation Tips
Bob Evans, the restoration wizard, figured out how to remove rust without harming the gold underneath – which is why so many salvaged coins graded Mint State. If you’re lucky enough to have one of these fragile flakes, here’s what I’d suggest based on what I’ve learned:
- Encasement: Gently embed it in Lucite or similar acrylic. This protects it while letting you show it off without handling.
- Environment Control: Keep it somewhere cool and dry, like you would with your best coins. And steer clear of harsh cleaners like Verdi-Care – they’d destroy it in seconds.
Collecting Insights and Market Thoughts
As a collector, I’d give anything to own one of these – they’re historical artifacts, not just coins. Grading’s tricky since they don’t fit standard categories, but I’d expect “details” designation for corrosion. They’re incredibly rare and sought-after by specialists. Can you imagine displaying one alongside its original coin? If shipwreck recoveries or precious metals fascinate you, this adds fresh excitement to the chase.
Why This Matters to Me
This is why I love numismatics – it connects us to stories like the SS Central America in the most tangible way. Whether you grade, collect, or simply admire, these rust impressions show how history preserves itself in unexpected ways. I’m always searching for more discoveries like this, and I hope you’ll explore the research yourself – it’s full of surprises.