My Fascination with the Rust Image Artifact from the SS Central America Double Eagle
June 23, 2025My Nickel Collection Highlights: Embracing Sal’s Nifty Nickel Night Spirit
June 23, 2025
I’ve been collecting coins for years, and nothing gets me more worked up than seeing people try to tone gold coins. After witnessing some real heartbreakers, I’m convinced it’s a road you don’t want to go down—let me tell you why.
The Dangers of DIY Toning Attempts
Just last week, I spotted an eBay listing where someone tried toning a gold coin—what a train wreck. They ended up with this awful purple ring, probably from messing with Liver of Sulphur. Not only does it look terrible, but it shouts “amateur” and can tank a coin’s value to near scrap. Gold’s purity makes it stubborn to tone evenly, and one slip can cause permanent damage even the best conservators can’t fully fix.
Expert Restoration: A Glimmer of Hope
Remember those SS Central America shipwreck coins? They sat under nasty goethite crust for over a century. But pros like Robert Evans performed miracles—gently restoring them to earn top PCGS grades. So if you inherit or accidentally buy a toned coin, there’s hope. Send it straight to PCGS or NGC conservation. My golden rules:
- Never try cleaning it yourself—you’ll likely make it worse
- Let the experts handle it to protect both the coin and its grading potential
Market Wisdom: When to Buy or Pass
If I ever consider a toned gold coin, it’d only be at fire-sale prices—basically valuing it as raw bullion. Once altered, that numismatic premium evaporates. I’ve watched sellers overprice these mistakes, but sharp collectors wait for true bargains. Pro tip: assume hidden damage and inspect like a hawk, or better yet—just walk away.
Scientific Facts on Gold and Toning
Here’s the straight talk: pure gold doesn’t naturally tone. That funky color? Blame copper or iron impurities in the alloy. Forced toning fights gold’s nature and often backfires spectacularly. Why mess with perfection? That natural glow is what makes gold coins timeless.
After decades in this hobby, I’ll say it plain: toning gold is a fool’s game. Preserve what you’ve got, call the pros if things go sideways, and let that beautiful metal speak for itself. Your collection will shine brighter for it!
