Cherry Picking the 1931-S Buffalo Nickel: How to Spot This Rare Treasure in Circulation

Imagine uncovering numismatic gold in the most unexpected places! While dealers’ cases hold their charms, nothing beats the thrill of spotting a rare variety in a dusty roll, a cluttered estate sale bin, or even everyday circulation. The legendary 1931-S Buffalo Nickel – a holy grail for series collectors – still surfaces in such unlikely spots… if you’ve trained your eye to recognize its secrets.

Historical Significance of the 1931-S Buffalo Nickel

Few coins capture the drama of American history like the 1931-S Buffalo Nickel. Born in the San Francisco Mint during the Great Depression’s bleakest year, this nickel survives as a numismatic David among Goliaths. With a mere 1.2 million struck – second-lowest in the entire series – its scarcity alone would command attention. But what truly sets this coin apart is its survivor’s tale.

This nickel’s numismatic value proves a vital truth: survival rates trump mintage numbers. Even common-date Buffalos pale next to a mint-state 1931-S.

Most of these nickels wore down in pockets and cash registers, victims of hard times. Those surviving in mint condition, like our forum’s stunning PCGS MS66 example, represent a microscopic fraction of the original mintage. For collectors, it’s the perfect storm: extreme rarity meets unwavering demand from series completists.

Identifying Key Markers in the Wild

Mint Mark Location

The tiny ‘S’ mintmark hides beneath the FIVE CENTS denomination – prime real estate for grime accumulation. On worn specimens, it can vanish entirely. Never leave home without your 10x loupe when hunting this elusive date!

Date and Design Details

Focus your Sherlock Holmes gaze on these make-or-break areas:

• Obverse (Buffalo Side): The buffalo’s flank and horn wear first. Date digits (1931) often show weakness – demand complete numerals.
• Reverse (Indian Head): Feather details in the headdress and crispness of ‘UNITED STATES OF AMERICA’ separate survivors from slugs.

Metal Composition Telltales

Authentic Buffalo nickels (75% copper, 25% nickel) develop distinctive patina. Beware replated imposters! Genuine coins show natural toning – soft grays, oceanic blues, or the russet-gold hues our forum member called “pure eye candy.” That “delicious luster” in their example? That’s original skin talking.

Grading Insights for Cherry Pickers

Our forum discussion revealed grading’s art and science:

• PCGS often rewards eye appeal more than NGC (notice how the coin jumped from NGC MS65 to PCGS MS66?)
• Hunt for “plus” qualities – the owner spotted “electric luster” and “cartwheel highlights”
• Three make-or-break factors: Minimal contact marks (especially on the buffalo’s vulnerable neck), strike sharpness, and untouched surfaces

Where to Find Hidden Treasures

Circulation Finds

While rarer than hen’s teeth, 1931-S specimens still surface in:
– Forgotten bank rolls from grandma’s attic
– Non-collector accumulations priced as junk silver
– Unpicked “cull” bins at coin shops

Estate Sales & Bulk Purchases

Prime hunting grounds include:
– Weight-priced collections where rarity goes unnoticed
– Inherited holdings where “just old nickels” hide treasures
– Auction lots with potato-quality photos masking key details

As our forum sage proved, patience makes perfect. Fifteen years refining his 1931-S hunt? That’s how you cultivate numismatic instincts.

Value Guide: What You’re Hunting For

This nickel turns collectors into treasure hunters for good reason:

• Graded MS63: $1,200-$1,500 (entry-level rarity)
• MS64: $2,000-$2,800 (serious collector territory)
• MS65: $4,000-$6,000 (our forum NGC example landed here first)
• MS66: $10,000+ (PCGS crossover unleashed its true value)

That exponential leap between grades? That’s why authentication and grading savvy separate the casuals from the connoisseurs.

The Thrill of the Upgrade Chase

Our forum thread showcases collecting at its finest. By:
1) Spotting superior eye appeal in a “fairly priced” BIN listing
2) Anticipating crossover potential between grading services
3) Moving faster than competitors who missed the nuance
This collector transformed smart buying into a portfolio highlight. Provenance matters, but knowledge builds true numismatic value.

Conclusion: Why This Nickel Still Excites Collectors

The 1931-S Buffalo Nickel embodies everything we adore about numismatics – scarcity with soul, grading mysteries that reward study, and the electric possibility of discovery. Whether you’re rifling through rolls, assessing estate finds, or eyeing a dealer’s “junk” box, remember: coins become legends because someone before you overlooked their potential. Hone your eye for strike quality and surface personality. Keep your loupe close and your reference books closer. As our forum hero demonstrated through patience and expertise, even Depression-era nickels can spark collector fireworks when you recognize true numismatic gold.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Market Mastery: Strategic Acquisition of the 1931-S Buffalo Nickel for Discerning Collectors – The Collector’s Guide to Acquiring the 1931-S Buffalo Nickel Hunters of semi-key dates, rejoice! The 1931-S Buffal…
• Unlocking the 1931-S Buffalo Nickel’s Jewelry Potential: A Metalsmith’s Perspective – Not Every Coin Belongs on the Ring Mandrel As a coin ring artisan with twenty years of transforming currency into wearab…
• Preserving the 1931-S Buffalo Nickel: Expert Conservation Tips for a Rare Coin Treasure – The Fragile Legacy of the 1931-S Buffalo Nickel As a lifelong numismatist, nothing breaks my heart faster than seeing a …