Is Your 1911 Coin Authentic? Expert Authentication Guide for Collectors

With counterfeits flooding the market, knowing the specific diagnostic points for 1911 coins is critical. As we honor the 115th birthday of Jean Norton Shinnick (1911-1980) – a talented painter and beloved grandmother celebrated in collector forums – we turn our attention to the coins of her birthyear. This guide arms you with professional authentication techniques to protect your investments and preserve history.

Historical Significance of 1911 Coinage

The year 1911 marked a transitional period in American numismatics. The US Mint produced:

• Lincoln Wheat Pennies (first issued in 1909)
• Indian Head Pennies (final year before discontinuation)
• Barber Dimes, Quarters, and Half Dollars
• Saint-Gaudens Double Eagles ($20 gold pieces)

These coins represent America’s economic landscape before World War I, with over 100 million pennies struck at Philadelphia alone. Their historical weight makes them prime targets for counterfeiters.

Key Authentication Markers for 1911 Coins

Weight: Your First Line of Defense

Precision scales (0.01g accuracy required) should verify:

• Lincoln Cents: 3.11g ±0.10g
• Indian Head Pennies: 3.11g
• Barber Dimes: 2.50g (90% silver)
• Barber Quarters: 6.25g
• Barber Half Dollars: 12.50g

Tip: A 1911 Lincoln cent weighing 2.8g likely has been altered or is counterfeit

Magnetic Properties Tell the Truth

Authentic 1911 US coins exhibit predictable magnetic responses:

• Bronze Pennies: Non-magnetic (95% copper composition)
• Silver Coinage: Weakly magnetic due to iron impurities in planchets
• Gold $20: Non-magnetic (0.900 gold, 0.100 copper)

Warning: Modern Chinese counterfeits often use magnetic base metals with copper plating.

Die Markers: The Devil’s in the Details

Use 10x magnification to examine these diagnostic features:

• Lincoln Cents: Look for Victor D. Brenner’s “V.D.B” initials below wheat stalks (removed mid-1909 but reappeared on truncation in 1918)
• Indian Head Pennies: Three distinct feather tips on headdress (counterfeits often show blurred detail)
• Barber Series: Sharp denticles with consistent spacing (wear patterns should match grade)

Common Fakes and How to Spot Them

Three prevalent counterfeit types plague the 1911 market:

1. Cast Replicas: Show porous surfaces under magnification and incorrect weight (±15% variance)
2. Electroplated Copies: Pass magnet tests but fail specific gravity measurements
3. Altered Dates: 1914-D pennies frequently altered to 1911 – check digit spacing and field marks

Professional authenticators recently identified a batch of fake 1911-S Barber dimes with telltale raised die polish lines in protected areas.

Professional Testing Methodology

Beyond basic tools, experts use:

• XRF Analysis: Measures exact metal composition (silver coins should show 90% Ag ±0.5%)
• Ultrasonic Thickness Gauges: Detects plugged coins or layered fakes
• Electrostatic Detection: Reveals tool marks under counterfeit surfaces

Step-by-Step Authentication Protocol

1. Weigh to 0.01g precision
2. Conduct magnet slide test (silver should show slow fall)
3. Inspect under 10x loupe for mint mark placement
4. Verify date style against Sheldon reference plates
5. Perform specific gravity test for silver/gold coins

Collectibility and Market Value

Properly authenticated 1911 coins command significant premiums:

A certified genuine 1911-S Barber dime in MS-65 condition sold for $14,950 in 2021 – underscoring why authentication matters.

Conclusion: Preserving History Through Vigilance

As we celebrate historical connections like Jean Norton Shinnick’s legacy, rigorous authentication preserves both monetary value and historical integrity. Remember: Knowledge of weight tolerances, magnetic responses, and die markers separates savvy collectors from fraud victims. When in doubt, consult NGC or PCGS-certified professionals before purchasing any 1911 coin.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• 1911 Error Coins: The Hidden Fortune in Your Grandmother’s Pocket Change – Most collectors overlook the microscopic details that transform ordinary coins into extraordinary treasures. As an error…
• The Hidden History Behind Happy 115th Birthday Grammy: Unearthing the 1911 Coin Collection – Every coin whispers secrets of the past. When we hold these 1911 treasures—the Morgan Silver Dollar with its stoic Liber…
• Unearthing Vintage Walker Treasures: How to Spot Coveted Early Holders in Circulation – Treasure hides in plain sight – you just need to know where to look. After pulling 90% silver Walkers from ordinary bank…