1913 Buffalo Nickels: Bullion Value vs. Collector Premium Explained for Investors

The Metal Beneath the Legend: Decoding Buffalo Nickel Values

Every collector knows that thrill: holding a coin where the story outweighs the metal. Today we’re diving deep into the 1913 Buffalo Nickels – those iconic pieces sparking heated forum debates about proof status and true worth. Whether you’re stacking base metals or hunting rare varieties, these coins epitomize the tension between melt value and numismatic glory.

Historical Significance of the 1913 Buffalo Nickel

James Earle Fraser’s masterpiece – born from his studies of Iron Tail, Two Moons, and Big Tree – remains America’s most soul-stirring coin design. The 1913 issues are particularly fascinating with their dramatic mid-year redesign:

• Type 1 (“Raised Ground”): A fleeting February-March 1913 issue showing the denomination perched precariously on a mound
• Type 2 (“Hollow Ground”): The March-December 1913 savior with recessed lettering to protect that vulnerable “FIVE CENTS”

While neither type contains precious metal, their collectibility transforms ordinary copper-nickel into historical treasure.

Metal Composition and Melt Value Breakdown

Let’s strip these beauties down to their metallic essence. Three factors determine their base metal worth:

1. Purity & Weight Specifications

Every Buffalo Nickel contains:

• 75% copper (3.75g) – that warm reddish core
• 25% nickel (1.25g) – giving it that signature white luster
• Total weight: 5 grams – substantial in the palm

2. Spot Price Correlation

Crunching Q3 2023 London Metal Exchange numbers:

• Copper: ~$3.80/lb ($0.0084/gram)
• Nickel: ~$10.50/lb ($0.0231/gram)

The metal math sings:
(3.75g x $0.0084) + (1.25g x $0.0231) = $0.0315 + $0.0289 = $0.0604

That’s right – these nickels technically wear a 20% metal premium over face value. Not bad for pocket change!

Numismatic Value vs. Melt Value: The Collector’s Crossroads

Here’s where the real magic happens. That matte proof hiding in a junk box? It could mean the difference between beer money and mortgage payments:

• Circulation Strikes: Modest premiums (10¢-25¢) unless boasting mint condition surfaces
• Proofs: Heart-stopping $3,000-$6,000+ values for authenticated specimens

Wisdom from the trenches:

“Study those rims like your retirement depends on it – proofs show knife-sharp borders with mirrored edges.”
“Many Type 1 Philadelphia strikes got brutalized – even attractive examples often lack eye appeal for serious premiums.”

Strategic Collecting: When Bullion Meets History

Smart collectors approach Buffalo Nickels with three battle plans:

1. Volume Plays

At 6¢ melt value versus 5¢ face:

• Every 1,000 nickels = $50 face becomes $60.40 in metal
• Sweet spot: When copper/nickel prices surge past 20% premiums

2. Grading Game-Changers

Sort like a pro:

• Common dates: Bulk bins for metal value
• Key dates (1913-S Type 2, 1916/16-D Doubled Die): Handle like museum pieces

3. Market Timing Mastery

Nickel’s rollercoaster since 2006:

• 2007 peak: Melt value hit 16¢ (making every nickel triple its face!)
• 2022 shortage: 8¢ melt value showed the power of industrial demand

Conclusion: The Numismatic Tightrope

These 1913 Buffalo Nickels embody our favorite dilemma: metal versus history. The forum-confirmed circulation strikes remind us that most survivors are humble workhorses – but oh, the thrill of finding that rare variety!

• Type 1: Nummis lovers pay slight premiums for Philadelphia strikes with strong strikes
• Type 2: Pure bullion play unless you uncover that elusive Denver mintmark

As one sage collector noted: “Stack during metal slumps, but keep one eye peeled for proofs.” Because in our world, that scratched-up nickel in your coffee can might just be hiding a four-figure pedigree under its patina.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Cherry Picking 1913 Buffalo Nickels: How to Spot Hidden Gems in Circulation Finds – Treasure Hunts Aren’t Just for Dealers Let me share a hard-earned truth from decades of roll hunting: Some of the …
• Smart Buying Guide: How to Buy 1913 Type 1 and Type 2 Buffalo Nickels Without Getting Ripped Off – If you’re hunting for 1913 Type 1 or Type 2 Buffalo Nickels, let me share the secrets I’ve learned from deca…
• Crafting Potential of 1913 Buffalo Nickels: A Coin Ring Artisan’s Guide to Metal, Design, and Value – Introduction Not every coin deserves to become jewelry – some belong in collections, others in history books. As a…