Finding 1937 D Buffalo Nickel in the Wild: A Cherry Picker’s Guide

Let me tell you, there’s nothing quite like feeling that rush when you spot a treasure in ordinary pocket change. After decades of hunting through bank rolls, estate sale finds, and auction bulk lots, I can confirm that discoveries like the legendary 1937-D Buffalo Nickel “Three-Legger” still hide in plain sight. This iconic error coin – born from a mint worker’s overzealous polishing during the depths of the Great Depression – commands awe among collectors not just for its rarity, but for its tangible connection to America’s numismatic history. In this guide, I’ll share hard-won insights on identifying genuine Three-Leggers while hunting through circulation coins, helping you separate true numismatic treasures from common pocket pieces.

Historical Significance: When a Mint Mishap Became Legend

James Earle Fraser’s Buffalo Nickel design (1913-1938) captures the spirit of the American West like no other coin. But the 1937-D issue from the Denver Mint holds a special place in collector lore thanks to a dramatic die-polishing accident. In an attempt to remove clash marks between the obverse and reverse dies, mint technicians accidentally erased the bison’s front leg – creating one of the most sought-after errors in U.S. coinage history.

This wasn’t some planned rarity, but a genuine artifact of Depression-era minting struggles. With dies being reused and manually maintained under tight budgets, the over-polished reverse die likely produced just 5,000-10,000 coins before being discarded. Today, each surviving Three-Legger whispers stories of resourcefulness and industrial grit. For roll hunters, finding one isn’t just about numismatic value – it’s about holding a piece of tangible history that slipped through the Mint’s quality control nearly a century ago.

Identifying Key Markers: Separating Treasure From Trash

Spotting a genuine Three-Legger requires more than a casual glance – you need to think like a detective. While most 1937-D nickels show the bison standing firmly on four legs, the prized error variety reveals a distinctive tripod stance. Here’s how to identify key features, whether you’re examining coins fresh from a bank roll or sorting through an uncleaned estate lot:

Obverse (Front) Features

• Native American Portrait: Look for strong details in the braid and feather work. Authentic 1937-D coins will show a crisp date with the mint mark positioned directly below – that small “D” is your first clue you might have a winner.
• Surface Quality: Examine the fields for original luster. While circulated examples will show wear, unnatural scratches or altered patina could indicate a counterfeit.

Reverse (Back) Features

• The Telltale Bison: The star of the show! On genuine Three-Leggers, the front leg isn’t just worn – it’s completely missing from the die. Compare against known examples: the remaining legs should show strong detail while the missing leg area appears smooth with no trace of musculature.
• Diagnostic Die Markers: Advanced collectors look for specific polish lines near the buffalo’s back and belly. Under magnification, you’ll notice subtle differences in the spacing between “E PLURIBUS UNUM” and the animal’s back compared to standard strikes.
• Strike Quality: Look for weakness in the leg area caused by die polishing. Genuine errors show natural metal flow – not the jagged edges of post-mint damage.

Forum discussions sometimes mention “transitional” pieces showing partial legs. While intriguing, stick to definitive Three-Leggers for maximum collectibility. When in doubt, consult the bible of error hunting – the Cherrypicker’s Guide to Rare Die Varieties – or compare your find against PCGS-certified examples.

Practical Tips for Roll Hunters

• Bank Roll Strategy: Focus on obtaining original bank-wrapped rolls from older branches. While Buffalo Nickels rarely surface in modern circulation, I’ve found more pre-1940 nickels in rolls from rural banks than big-city branches.
• Bulk Lot Goldmines: Seek out “unsearched” nickel lots with provenance – estate liquidations and old collection buyouts often yield better results than random online auctions. A single Three-Legger can justify buying an entire lot!
• Estate Sale Tactics: Arrive early and ask direct questions: “Do you have any old coin collections or jars of change?” Many heirs overlook coins while focusing on flashier antiques.
• Grading Essentials: Never clean a potential find! Even low-grade Three-Leggers retain significant value if they show original surfaces. Submit promising candidates to PCGS or NGC – their holders dramatically improve marketability.

Remember my toughest hunt? Three years searching before I spotted a worn 1937-D Three-Legger hiding in a $100 bulk lot – its telltale missing leg visible even through layers of honest circulation wear. That moment of discovery makes every box of ordinary nickels worth checking.

Value Guide: What Makes This Error So Special?

The Three-Legger’s value isn’t just about scarcity – it’s about story. This error represents one of the last great Mint mistakes before modern quality controls, combining historical significance with striking visual appeal. Current valuations reflect its legendary status:

• Good (G-4): Heavy wear but clear three-leg error. Value: $500–$1,000 – perfect for type collectors
• Very Fine (VF-20): Visible feather details with strong bison outline. Value: $2,500–$4,000
• Extremely Fine (EF-40): Light wear with excellent eye appeal. Value: $5,000–$8,500
• AU (About Uncirculated): Traces of mint luster with minimal high-point wear. Value: $9,000–$15,000
• Mint State (MS-60+): Full original luster with mark-free surfaces. Value: $20,000–$50,000+

Compare this to common 1937-D Buffalo Nickels (four legs) at $2-$10, and you understand why roll hunters obsess over this variety. Recent Heritage Auction results show certified specimens consistently outperforming generic rare coins – a testament to their enduring numismatic appeal.

Advanced Cherry Picking Techniques

Mastering Buffalo Nickel varieties requires developing your “coin eye”:

• Lighting Matters: Use angled daylight-spectrum lamps to reveal subtle die polish lines. The missing leg should appear seamlessly integrated, not like a gouged-out error.
• Die State Analysis: Early die state Three-Leggers show weaker polishing marks near the bison’s back. Later strikes display more dramatic leg removal but may have die cracks – all factors affecting collectibility.
• Provenance Hunting: Old collections often contain overlooked errors. I once found a VF Three-Legger in a 1950s album misidentified as “damaged coin” – the owner had circled the missing leg in pencil!
• Community Wisdom: Participate in error-coin forums like CoinCommunity or BuffaloNickels.org. The collective knowledge there surpasses any guidebook.

Never forget: every roll of nickels is a time capsule. That grimy coin from a small-town bank vault? It might have ridden trains with hobos during the Depression before landing in your hands. That’s the magic of coin hunting!

Conclusion

The 1937-D Three-Legger Buffalo Nickel represents everything we love about numismatics – history, art, and the thrill of discovery all stamped into a humble five-cent piece. While certified examples command top dollar at auctions, the dream of finding one in circulation keeps collectors checking every nickel that crosses their palm. Armed with the knowledge in this guide, you’re not just searching for a rare variety; you’re preserving a tangible piece of American minting history. So grab those bank rolls, dig into those estate sale boxes, and remember – the next nickel you flip could be the numismatic find of a lifetime.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• 1937-D Buffalo Nickel Buyer’s Masterclass: Expert Strategies for Acquiring Key Varieties – The Collector’s Guide to Hunting the Legendary 1937-D Buffalo Nickel For those captivated by America’s most …
• Forging Beauty from Buffalo Nickels: The 1937-D’s Hidden Potential for Jewelry Craftsmanship – Not Every Coin Is Meant for the Jewelry Bench With twenty years of transforming history into wearable art, I’ve le…
• Preserving History: Expert Conservation Techniques for the Rare 1937-D Buffalo Nickel (Including the 3-Legged Variety) – The Fragile Beauty of America’s Iconic Nickel Few things pain me more than seeing historic coins robbed of their s…