Cherry Picking the 1889-CC Morgan Dollar: A Roll Hunter’s Guide to Spotting Fakes & Finding Treasures
January 22, 2026What is the Real Value of Proof Silver Eagles in Today’s Market?
January 22, 2026
When the Metal Beneath Outshines the Legend
In my twenty years handling Morgans, I’ve discovered an ironclad truth that separates serious stackers from casual collectors: Not every silver dollar deserves a premium showcase. The 1889-CC Morgan debate we’re unpacking today pulses with the age-old tension between bullion fundamentals and numismatic fantasy. Let’s explore why weight, purity, and spot price should anchor your strategy—even when handling legendary coins that make historians catch their breath.
Melt Value Essentials Every Stacker Should Know
Before we dive into this specific beauty, let’s ground ourselves in why silver content remains king:
- Purity Matters: Morgans aren’t pure—they’re 90% silver alloyed with copper (0.77344 oz ASW)
- Weight Tells Truths: 26.73 grams of history in your palm
- Spot Price Reality: At $25/oz silver? That’s $19.34 of precious metal singing beneath the patina
The arithmetic seems straightforward… until you encounter a coin like the 1889-CC. A genuine G-4 specimen commands $4,500—but as our forum sleuths revealed, this particular piece screams “counterfeit” to trained eyes. That’s where collectibility and numismatic value collide with cold, hard metallurgy.
The 1889-CC Morgan: A Masterclass in Authentication
Studying the forum photos made my spidey senses tingle. Several telltale gaps scream “fake” to anyone who’s handled raw Morgans fresh from Nevada soil:
Key Diagnostic Markers (Missing in Action)
- Mint Mark Poetry: Authentic CC mint marks tilt left like a cowboy’s hat in VAM-3 varieties
- Die Personality: With only 7 die pairs ever used, the missing ‘M’ in Liberty’s bow is like a missing fingerprint
- Surface Storytelling: That artificial toning lacks 130 years’ honest oxidation—it’s costume jewelry patina
“Mushy details and that ‘too perfect’ toning? Red flags waving like a Comstock Lode claim jumper!” — Forum Veteran
When Spot Price and Collectibility Collide
For us silver stackers, the 1889-CC presents a delicious paradox:
| Scenario | Value Driver | Smart Move |
|---|---|---|
| Authentic Rarity | Scarcity (Just 350k minted) | Numismatic play if certified |
| Silver Fake | Melt value alone | Assay and stack the metal |
| Base Metal Imposter | Doorstop value | Run like the Pony Express |
As one grizzled forum member nailed it: “For every real 1889-CC, there’s a wagon train of fakes.” This risk profile demands more caution than handling a stick of Comstock dynamite.
Why Counterfeits Should Keep Stackers Awake
Think fakes only hurt collectors? Think again. Three ways they threaten bullion buyers:
- Market Trust Erosion: Floods of fakes make all raw Morgans suspect
- Capital Misallocation: That “bargain” CC dollar could’ve bought verifiable ASEs
- Exit Strategy Blues: Even silver-plated fakes turn your LCS into a crime scene
The forum’s consensus—“modern Shanghai special”—reveals how counterfeiters now use real silver, creating collector-grade nightmares with bullion-grade consequences.
Bullion Buyer’s Guide to Key-Date Morgans
When temptation whispers about CC Morgans, arm yourself with this metal-first protocol:
The Stacker’s Authentication Gauntlet
- Weigh it (26.73g ±0.20g—no exceptions)
- Probe its soul (specific gravity or XRF test)
- Study its face (compare denticles to PCGS CoinFacts)
- Crunch premiums (anything over 100% spot needs NGC/PCGS armor)
Remember: No unverified coin deserves shelf space. As one eagle-eyed member noted: “The wear patterns tell conflicting stories—like a dime novel full of plot holes.”
History Lesson: Why CC Morgans Captivate Us
Carson City silver dollars (1870-1893) practically smell of frontier whiskey and gunpowder. The 1889-CC emerged during the mint’s twilight years, most survivors battered like prospectors’ boots. This legacy fuels collectibility—and explains why authenticated examples belong in museum cases, not junk silver bins.
Conclusion: Let Silver Be Your Compass
The Great 1889-CC Debate teaches us that even legendary coins bow to elemental truth. While genuine rarities deserve their numismatic glory, today’s counterfeiters craft deception with frightening skill. For stackers, this coin represents both siren song and schoolroom—if you:
- Treat silver content as holy writ
- Watch spot prices like a Comstock assayist
- Hone your eye appeal instincts or partner with grading gurus
As the forum’s collective wisdom echoes: When a coin feels wrong in your palm, listen. In bullion and numismatics alike, knowledge is the scale that weighs true treasure against clever lies.
Related Resources
You might also find these related articles helpful:
- Cherry Picking the 1889-CC Morgan Dollar: A Roll Hunter’s Guide to Spotting Fakes & Finding Treasures – Every collector knows that heart-pounding moment when a seemingly ordinary coin reveals its hidden pedigree. As someone …
- 1889-CC Morgan Dollar Buyer’s Guide: Expert Strategies to Avoid Counterfeits and Secure Value – Introduction: The Irresistible Allure of the 1889-CC Morgan Dollar Few coins quicken a collector’s pulse like the …
- 1889-CC Morgan Dollar: Assessing Jewelry Potential in a Sea of Counterfeits – Not Every Coin Deserves the Hammer Let’s settle this frontier debate once and for all: that questionable 1889-CC M…
