Preserving Your 1931-S Lincoln Cent: A Conservationist’s Guide

The Hidden Dangers to Your Valuable Coins

As a conservationist who has witnessed countless numismatic treasures deteriorate over the years, I can tell you that proper preservation is the single most important factor in maintaining a coin’s value and historical integrity. The 1931-S Lincoln cent, with its relatively low mintage of 866,000 pieces, represents exactly the type of valuable collectible that deserves our utmost care and attention.

Why Preservation Matters

Many collectors focus solely on acquisition, never considering that improper storage or cleaning can destroy up to 90% of a coin’s value. I’ve seen pristine 1931-S cents worth hundreds of dollars reduced to common-date status through well-intentioned but disastrous cleaning attempts. The patina that develops naturally on copper coins—known as toning—is not damage but rather a protective layer that enhances both the coin’s appearance and its preservation.

Understanding Toning and Oxidation

Toning on copper coins like the 1931-S cent occurs through a natural chemical process where the metal reacts with sulfur compounds in the environment. This creates the beautiful array of colors—from amber and russet to deep magenta and electric blue—that serious collectors prize. These colors form in concentric bands and are completely random, making each toned coin unique.

The Science Behind Toning

When copper oxidizes, it forms copper oxide, which appears as a brown or black layer. Over time, this reacts with other elements to create various copper compounds. The most desirable toning occurs when these compounds form in thin, even layers that produce vibrant colors through light interference. A properly toned 1931-S cent in MS-65RB (red-brown) condition can command a 30-40% premium over a fully red example.

The PVC Threat: What Every Collector Must Know

Perhaps the most insidious danger to your 1931-S cent is PVC (polyvinyl chloride) damage. Many inexpensive coin flips and holders manufactured before the 1990s contain PVC, which was used as a plasticizer to make the material more flexible. When PVC breaks down over time, it releases hydrochloric acid that can permanently damage the surface of your coin.

Identifying PVC Damage

PVC damage appears as a cloudy, milky haze or a green, slimy residue on the coin’s surface. Once this damage occurs, it cannot be reversed. The affected areas will appear dull and lifeless compared to the surrounding surface. A 1931-S cent with PVC damage might lose 50% or more of its value, even if the damage is minimal.

Proper Storage Solutions

The key to preserving your 1931-S cent lies in using the right storage materials. Always opt for archival-quality, PVC-free holders. These are typically labeled as “acid-free” or “archival safe.” For individual coins, consider these options:

• Air-tite holders with gaskets
• Intercept Shield holders with anti-tarnish technology
• Hard plastic capsules with O-rings
• Acid-free cardboard 2×2 holders with Mylar windows

Environmental Considerations

Even with proper holders, environmental factors play a crucial role. Store your coins in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. Ideal conditions are temperatures between 65-70°F with relative humidity between 45-55%. Avoid basements and attics where temperature and humidity fluctuate dramatically. Consider using silica gel packets in your storage area to control moisture.

To Clean or Not to Clean: The Conservationist’s Perspective

This is perhaps the most controversial topic in coin collecting, and as a conservationist, my stance is clear: never clean a valuable coin unless you’re a professional conservator. The 1931-S cent, being a key date in the Lincoln cent series, falls firmly into the “do not clean” category.

The Science of Coin Cleaning Damage

Cleaning removes the natural patina and microscopic details from a coin’s surface. Even gentle cleaning with mild soap and water can create tiny scratches visible under magnification. These scratches scatter light differently than the original surface, creating an unnatural appearance that experts can immediately identify. A cleaned 1931-S cent might be worth only 20-30% of an uncleaned example in similar grade.

Professional Conservation Techniques

If you absolutely must address a specific issue with your 1931-S cent, consult a professional conservation service. These experts use techniques like:

• Distilled water baths to remove surface contaminants
• Specialized solvents that dissolve specific types of deposits
• Micro-abrasive techniques that preserve surface detail
• Electrolysis for removing certain types of corrosion

Remember: once metal is removed from a coin’s surface, it cannot be replaced. Professional conservation is about preservation, not restoration.

Displaying Your Collection Safely

If you wish to display your 1931-S cent, choose display cases with UV-filtering glass and maintain the same environmental controls as your storage area. Avoid hanging displays on exterior walls where temperature fluctuations are greatest. For valuable pieces, consider using a lockable display case with a humidity control system.

Handling Best Practices

Always handle coins by their edges, never touching the surfaces with your fingers. The oils and acids from human skin can cause permanent damage. Wear clean, cotton gloves when handling your 1931-S cent, and work on a clean, soft surface like a felt pad. Never talk over the coin, as microscopic droplets from your breath can contain corrosive compounds.

Long-term Preservation Strategies

For the serious collector, consider these advanced preservation strategies:

Climate-Controlled Storage

Invest in a small, dedicated climate-controlled cabinet for your most valuable coins. These units maintain constant temperature and humidity levels, providing optimal conditions for long-term preservation. Some advanced models even include air filtration systems to remove airborne contaminants.

Documentation and Photography

Maintain detailed documentation of your 1931-S cent, including high-resolution photographs taken under consistent lighting conditions. This documentation serves multiple purposes: it helps track any changes in the coin’s appearance over time, provides evidence for insurance purposes, and creates a historical record for future collectors.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Even experienced collectors make these common preservation errors:

• Storing coins in food-grade plastic bags (these often contain plasticizers)
• Using rubber bands or paper clips for organization (both contain sulfur)
• Cleaning coins with household cleaners or metal polishes
• Storing coins in areas with temperature extremes
• Touching coin surfaces with bare fingers

The Value of Proper Preservation

A well-preserved 1931-S cent in MS-65RB condition can be worth $200-300, while the same coin in MS-65RD (full red) might command $400-500. However, a cleaned example in similar apparent condition might struggle to reach $100 at auction. The difference in preservation quality can literally mean hundreds of dollars in value.

Insurance Considerations

For coins valued over $100, consider specialized collectible insurance. These policies often require professional authentication and grading, which also provides an additional layer of preservation through expert examination and encapsulation. Many grading services use inert holders that provide excellent long-term protection.

Conclusion: Preserving History for Future Generations

The 1931-S Lincoln cent represents more than just a collectible; it’s a tangible piece of American history from the Great Depression era. By following proper preservation techniques—using archival-quality holders, maintaining stable environmental conditions, avoiding cleaning, and handling with care—you ensure that this historical artifact survives in excellent condition for future collectors to appreciate.

Remember, the goal of conservation is not to make a coin look new, but to preserve its current state and prevent further deterioration. A properly preserved 1931-S cent, with its natural toning and original surfaces intact, represents the pinnacle of numismatic preservation and will continue to be a source of pride and historical connection for generations to come.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Grading the 1931-S Lincoln Cent: The Difference Between $10 and $1,000 – Historical Significance The 1931-S Lincoln cent stands as one of the most intriguing dates in the series, with a mintage…
• Is Your 1931-S Lincoln Cent Real? How to Spot a Fake – Historical Significance The 1931-S Lincoln cent is a true numismatic treasure, with a mintage of just 866,000 pieces mak…
• The 1931-S Lincoln Cent: Spotting Rare Die Varieties and Counterfeit Red Flags – The Devil’s in the Details: Why Tiny Errors Make Big Money Most people overlook the subtle details that can transf…