APMEX’s Controversial Coin Selling Practices: What Every Collector Should Know

The Growing Concern Over Photo Inventory Practices

With counterfeits flooding the market, knowing the specific diagnostic points for this item is critical. When it comes to buying coins online, collectors must be vigilant about the practices of major dealers. Recently, a concerning trend has emerged where dealers use stock photos or images of coins they don’t actually own, creating a murky marketplace where what you see isn’t necessarily what you’ll receive.

Understanding the Photo Inventory Controversy

The issue came to light when collectors noticed identical coins being sold by different dealers across the country. For instance, a 1948-D Jefferson Nickel graded MS-66 by PCGS appeared simultaneously in listings from sellers in Oklahoma and Florida. This raised immediate red flags about whether these were actually the same coin being sold multiple times or if dealers were using shared photo inventories.

How Photo Inventory Systems Work

Companies like APMEX operate on a photo inventory model where they list coins they may have owned in the past or have images of, but don’t necessarily have in stock. Their listings often include disclaimers like “Photos in this listing may or may not be stock photos. The photos are meant to be an indication of the product you will receive.” This practice has become increasingly controversial in the collecting community.

Authentication Concerns and Red Flags

When examining listings, collectors should watch for several authentication issues:

Weight and Physical Properties

While not directly related to photo inventory issues, weight verification remains crucial for authentication. For silver coins, a genuine specimen should match the standard weight for its denomination. Any deviation could indicate a counterfeit or incorrect attribution.

Magnetic Properties Testing

Most genuine silver coins are non-magnetic. Using a simple magnet can help verify authenticity. If a coin that should be silver sticks to a magnet, it’s likely a fake or has been altered.

Die Markers and Surface Examination

Professional graders look for specific die markers – unique characteristics like die cracks, repunched mint marks, or other minting anomalies. When comparing photos from different listings, inconsistencies in these markers can reveal when the same image is being reused.

Common Fakes and Deceptive Practices

Photo Manipulation Techniques

Experienced collectors have identified manipulation techniques in photo inventory systems. For example, comparing obverse slab photos might reveal a stolen image with a black background added around the grading service’s gasket. The white background version might show unusual lighting patterns that don’t match natural photography.

Misleading Grade Representations

Another deceptive practice involves using high-grade images while selling lower-grade coins. A dealer might show a beautifully toned coin with a gold CAC sticker in their stock photo, while the actual coin you receive is a completely different specimen.

Testing Methods for Buyers

Direct Communication with Sellers

The most reliable testing method is direct communication. Ask sellers to confirm whether the coin in the photo is the exact coin you’ll receive. Request additional photos if necessary, including different angles and lighting conditions.

Documentation Verification

For graded coins, verify the certification number with the grading service. This ensures the coin hasn’t been switched or that you’re not looking at a photo of a different specimen.

Return Policy Importance

Always check the return policy before purchasing. Reputable dealers should offer returns if the coin doesn’t match the description or photos provided.

Industry Response and Best Practices

Collector Community Standards

The collector community has largely rejected photo inventory practices. Many experienced collectors now refuse to buy from dealers who use stock photos, preferring to deal with sellers who show the exact coin being offered.

Dealer Accountability

Some dealers have faced criticism for more than just photo inventory practices. For instance, there have been reports of dealers removing the best specimens from original mint tubes to submit for grading, then selling the remaining coins without disclosure.

Protecting Yourself as a Collector

Due Diligence Steps

Before making any purchase:

• Research the seller’s reputation thoroughly
• Read all disclaimers and fine print carefully
• Verify certification numbers when applicable
• Ask specific questions about the coin’s condition and appearance
• Consider dealing with established, reputable dealers even if prices are slightly higher

Alternative Buying Strategies

Many collectors now prefer buying from:

• Local coin shops where you can examine coins in person
• Established auction houses with return guarantees
• Known collectors and dealers with verifiable reputations
• Major grading service marketplaces where photos must match the actual coin

Conclusion

The photo inventory controversy highlights the importance of transparency in the coin collecting market. While practices like those employed by APMEX may be legal, they undermine trust between buyers and sellers. As one collector aptly described them, such companies have become “the hagfish of coin dealers” – creatures that feed on the trust of the collecting community.

For serious collectors, the message is clear: know exactly what you’re buying, verify everything, and don’t hesitate to walk away from deals that seem too good to be true or lack transparency. The peace of mind from knowing you have the exact coin you paid for is worth far more than any potential savings from dealing with questionable sellers.

Remember, in numismatics as in life, you typically get what you pay for. Building relationships with trustworthy dealers and doing thorough research before purchases will serve you far better than chasing the lowest price from unknown sources.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Uncovering Hidden Errors: How to Spot Rare Die Cracks and Mint Mark Variations – The Thrill of the Hunt: Finding Hidden Treasures Most people overlook the tiny details that can transform a common coin …
• The Hidden History Behind a 1948-D Jefferson Nickel: From Post-War America to Modern Collecting – Every Relic Tells a Story To understand this 1948-D Jefferson Nickel, we have to look at the era in which it was created…
• Finding Shipwreck Treasure in Circulation: A Roll Hunter’s Guide to Cherry Picking Rare Finds – The Thrill of the Hunt As a roll hunter, I’ve learned that the most exciting discoveries often happen right under …