Authenticating Early America’s Foreign Legal Tender: The 20,000 Reis, 400 Reis, and French Ecu

Don’t Get Fooled: Spotting Colonial-Era Treasures in a Sea of Fakes

As collectors hunt for tangible pieces of financial history, counterfeiters flood the market with convincing replicas of early America’s most fascinating foreign coins. The Brazilian 20,000 Reis gold behemoth, the impossibly tiny 400 Reis gold “minuto,” and the French Ecu silver giant represent the extremes of colonial numismatics – and prime targets for forgers. Let’s examine the critical diagnostics that separate authentic pieces from deceptive copies, preserving both your investment and numismatic heritage.

Historical Significance: Why These Coins Captivate Collectors

From taverns to tobacco plantations, these foreign coins fueled America’s economy for decades. As @oldabeintx astutely observed:

“Our ancestors used whatever rang true – weight and silver content mattered more than nationality.”

The 20,000 Reis (1725-1822) still astonishes with its 53.78g golden heft – nearly two troy ounces of monetary muscle. Meanwhile, the Brazilian 400 Reis (1700-1822) holds the crown as the smallest authorized gold coin, its 0.8938g frame smaller than a ladybug. The French Ecu (1641-1792) dominated colonial silver exchanges with its commanding 41mm diameter, outshining even the legendary Spanish 8 Reales in circulation.

The Authentication Trifecta: Weight, Design, and Provenance

1. Brazilian 20,000 Reis Gold Coin (The Colonial Bullion King)

• Weight: 53.78g (±0.10g) – feel the substantial heft!
• Eye Appeal: Crowned Portuguese arms with intricate scrollwork; crisp “PETRUS II” legend
• Edge: Milled lettering “IN HOC SIGNO VINCES” (In This Sign, Conquer)
• Red Flags: Blurred details on cast copies; incorrect 91.7% gold purity affecting luster

2. Brazilian 400 Reis Gold Coin (The Pocket-Sized Rarity)

• Weight: 0.8938g (±0.02g) – precision matters!
• Strike Characteristics: Distinctive crude cross reverse; miniature crown above shield
• Edge: Plain – unlike its larger cousins
• Red Flags: Modern counterfeits with improbably sharp details; magnetic response from wrong alloys

3. French Ecu Silver Coin (The Silver Leviathan)

• Patina: Look for natural gray toning on genuine 90% silver
• Portrait Details: Monarch’s profile (Louis XIV-XVI) with period-appropriate hairstyle
• Edge: Elegantly lettered royal mottos
• Red Flags: Seam marks on electrotypes; pewter casts lacking proper silver “ring”

Provenance & Testing: Your Authentication Toolkit

1. The Weight Test: Use a jeweler’s scale (0.01g precision). That 20,000 Reis should feel heavier than two silver dollars combined.

2. Magnetic Response: Gold must never attract; silver shows subtle diamagnetic slide.

3. Specific Gravity Tells All:

• 20,000 Reis: 17.5-18.0 SG
• 400 Reis: 17.2-17.8 SG
• French Ecu: 10.2-10.5 SG

4. Die Study Secrets: Examine adjustment marks under 10x magnification. As @Boosibri notes:

“Genuine Ecu strikes softened these marks under the portrait’s relief – fakes often overlook this detail.”

Counterfeit Clues: Separating Wheat from Chaff

Modern Threats: Laser scans create near-perfect fakes, but:

• 20,000 Reis: Improper reeding angles (45° vs genuine 60°)
• 400 Reis: Weight over 0.95g signals wrong composition
• Ecu: Squeezed lettering on edges reveals pantograph copies

Period Fakes: Even colonial Americans faced counterfeits:

• Hand-engraved dies showing tooling marks
• Test cuts revealing copper or lead cores
• Worn dies creating “spread” specimens

Collectibility & Market Trends

Authentic pieces command impressive premiums due to historical significance and rarity:

• 20,000 Reis: $8,000-$15,000+ in AU – numismatic value dwarfs gold content
• 400 Reis: $300-$800 despite size – true “rare variety” status
• French Ecu: $1,500-$5,000 for pre-1792 types with strong eye appeal

As @coinkat reminds us:

“These coins aren’t just metal – they’re the DNA of American commerce.”

Their collectibility stems from both historical importance and survival against incredible odds.

Conclusion: Guardians of Numismatic Truth

The Brazilian giants and French silver monarchs offer more than monetary value – they’re physical manifestations of colonial struggle and ingenuity. While counterfeiters grow sophisticated, the triumvirate of weight verification, metallurgical testing, and die analysis protects collectors. Remember: provenance and patina tell stories no forger can replicate. When evaluating these crown jewels of early American finance, let knowledge be your scale and skepticism your magnifying glass. Our collective vigilance preserves these treasures for future generations of historians and collectors alike.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Preserving the 1926-S Mercury Dime: Expert Conservation Strategies for Rarities Like the MS67FB CAC Specimen – The Fragile Legacy of America’s Iconic Silver Dime Few things pain a seasoned collector more than watching a centu…
• The Collector’s Playbook: Acquiring Rare Lincoln Cents at the Long Beach Expo – The Strategic Buyer’s Guide to Long Beach Expo Treasures If your heart races at the thought of adding wartime rari…
• Crafting Potential of Historic Lincoln Cents: 1943-S Bronze and 1944 Zinc as Jewelry – Not Every Coin Belongs on a Ring Mandrel As a coin ring artisan with twenty years of hands-on experience, I’ve lea…