Authenticating Santiago Pillar 8 Reales: The Expert’s Guide to Spotting Counterfeits

Counterfeit Crisis: Why Every Collector Must Master These Santiago Pillar Diagnostics

Among Spanish colonial silver crowns, few series ignite collector passion like the Santiago Pillar 8 Reales (1751-1770/69) – nor torment us with such authentication nightmares. With fewer than 70 confirmed survivors and most bearing damage or questionable provenance, these coins represent both the pinnacle of colonial numismatic value and a minefield of masterful counterfeits. Having handled six specimens and tracked every known example through auction archives and museum vaults, I’m sharing the critical diagnostic markers that separate museum-worthy treasures from costly fakes.

Ghost Coins of the New World: A Series Shrouded in Mystery

Crafted during Chile’s turbulent colonial reforms, these “Pillar Dollars” read like numismatic ghost stories. Of the 13 dates struck at the Santiago mint, four (1761, 1766, 1769, 1770/69) exist only in auction lore or institutional archives with fewer than three verified specimens. The legendary 1758 issue – the series’ lone mint condition survivor graded MS61 – would make any serious collector’s hands tremble. Even the “common” 1768 date survives in just 17-20 examples, with only three problem-free pieces boasting original luster and strike.

This extreme scarcity stems from Spain’s aggressive recoinage policies and the mint’s remote location. As Carlos Jara’s groundbreaking research revealed, most surviving specimens reached collectors through:

• 19th-century European cabinet acquisitions (trace that Brand-Zander-Craig-Karon pedigree!)
• River salvage operations in Southeast Asia (including the controversial 1769 “Ghost Coin”)
• South American family vaults preserved through revolutions and regime changes

Spotting the Real Deal: Key Authentication Markers

1. Weight, Composition, and That Telltale “Pillars” Patina

Authentic Santiago Pillars should tip the scales between 26.86g-27.28g (414-421 grains) with diameters spanning 38-40mm. I’ve seen “too perfect” modern fakes rejected solely for measuring 40.5mm. True pieces show .917 fine silver composition with:

• Distinctive 0.5-1.2% copper content
• Micro-traces of Potosí gold (<0.1%) - the fingerprint of colonial ore
• Complete absence of modern alloys (zinc/nickel are dead giveaways)

Pro Tip: Watch how the coin reacts to a rare earth magnet. Genuine pieces show slight movement from natural iron impurities – sterile .999 silver counterfeits won’t budge.

2. Die Traits That Separate Kings from Counterfeiters

Each date carries distinct “birthmarks” verified against the 68-piece census. Study these under angled light:

• 1751 – Crudely prepared undersized planchets (35-36mm) with legends that look punched by tired mint workers
• 1755 – Shield-side legend anomalies near the right pillar base that counterfeiters consistently misplace
• 1758 – That famous scratch through the “E” in “QUE” on the Krause plate coin
• 1768 – Three EF45 survivors each boast unique character:
  • Coin 1: Cathedral-worthy toning in protected recesses
  • Coin 2> Obverse die void at 8 o’clock resembling a mint worker’s thumbprint
  • Coin 3: Planchet flaw at 4 o’clock that’s become a collectibility signature

Modern fakers can’t replicate the Santiago mint’s crude technology. Authentic pieces always show:

• Asymmetrical legend spacing – no cookie-cutter perfection here!
• Tooling marks visible at 10x magnification (keep that loupe handy)
• Flattened pillar areas from desperate die polishing between strikes

Infamous Fakes That Fooled the Experts

The 1768 Chopmarked Chameleon

This coin’s journey (Bonhams 1996 → Heritage 2008/2018) proves even provenance lies sometimes. Despite NGC rejecting it in 2008, it resurfaces a decade later in an NGC holder. Red flags screaming “fake”:

• Metal flow around chops resembling modern tooling, not natural circulation
• Weight mysteriously gaining 0.23g between appearances – physical impossibility!
• Provenance gaps coinciding with suspected “enhancements”

The Indonesian 1769 “River Ghost”

Dredged from Southeast Asian waters in 2023 alongside genuine 1640s cobs, this controversial piece sparked heated debates. Though NGC rejected it, the evidence screams authenticity:

• Corrosion patterns matching verified river-salvaged silver
• Obverse die cracks aligning perfectly with 1768 specimens
• XRF analysis showing Potosí’s signature silver cocktail

Authentication Insight: Unique specimens often face rejection bias. When handling potential discovery coins, prioritize metallurgical testing over third-party opinions.

Modern Authentication: Beyond the Loupe

Today’s collectors wield scientific arsenals our predecessors couldn’t imagine:

• XRF Guns: Instant silver purity and trace element analysis
• Electron Microscopes: Spot modern casting porosity invisible to loupes
• Patina Forensics: Distinguish natural toning from chemical baths
• Provenance Mapping: Digital tools to trace auction histories to 1800s collections

The 1758 AU58 that stunned Stack’s 2020 sale ($42k hammer) passed the ultimate test:

1. Metal signature matching the Brand specimen down to 0.01% variance
2. Die marriage confirming it’s the long-lost “sibling” of the Banco de Chile example
3. Subsurface crystallization proving century-long underground storage

Conclusion: The Collector’s Ultimate Trophy

With just 55-61 survivors, the Santiago Pillar 8 Reales isn’t just rare – it’s Spanish colonial numismatics’ holy grail. Even problematic examples command $15k+, while pristine specimens like the 1758 MS61 ($55k+) approach national treasure status. Remember these hard-won lessons:

• Assume pedigrees are fictional until cross-referenced with Jara’s census
• Raw coins? Demand XRF tests – no exceptions
• Cherish honest corrosion – most genuine pieces show their 250-year journey

As new candidates emerge from Chilean estates and Indonesian riverbeds, remember: in this elite collecting tier, authentication isn’t just science – it’s the art of separating colonial masterpieces from heartbreak.

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Hunting Hidden Treasures: Error Spotting Guide for Santiago Pillar 8 Reales Rarities – Most collectors walk right past the tiny details that transform common coins into rare treasures worth thousands. As an …
• Santiago’s Silent Sentinels: The Turbulent History Behind Chile’s Rarest Colonial Coins – When Silver Crowns Bear Witness to Empire Hold one of these silver crowns, and you’re clutching a piece of Chile&#…
• The Last Breath of the Serenissima: Decoding Lodovico Manin’s 2 Scudi della Croce – History whispers through every artifact, but this breathtaking Venetian multiple shouts its story with silver brilliance…