Beginner’s Guide to Identifying MS-Worthy AU Coins: A Step-by-Step Tutorial

If You’re New to Coin Grading, Start Here

Ever held a coin and wondered if it’s more valuable than it appears? I remember my beginner days when I almost sold an 1893 Morgan dollar for $400 – only to discover later it graded MS-63. That heart-stopping mistake taught me what I’ll share with you today: how to spot hidden gems in your collection.

The AU-MS Difference Made Simple

Your Key to Understanding Grades

Think of AU (About Uncirculated) coins like a car that’s been driven just enough to show slight tire wear. MS (Mint State) coins? They’re straight from the showroom floor. The difference often comes down to microscopic details – like whether Liberty’s cheekbone shows friction or a feather’s edge remains razor-sharp.

4 Signs a Coin Might Be Mint State

• Luster Quality: Look for a velvety glow that moves like liquid when you tilt the coin
• Sharp Details: Check for crisp hair strands and lettering that aren’t worn down
• Clean Surfaces: Minor handling marks are okay, but no heavy scratches
• No High-Point Wear: The raised areas should feel smooth, not sandy

Hands-On Grading Techniques for Beginners

The Magic 30-Degree Tilt

Grab a desk lamp with an old-school bulb (LEDs lie!). Hold your coin 6 inches below the light and slowly tilt it. Watch the surface closely:

True Mint State coins will show light that rolls like a wheel across the surface. If the light stutters or breaks, you’re likely seeing AU-grade wear.

Where to Look for Wear

Every coin has its weak spots. Keep your magnifier ready for these trouble areas:

• Walking Liberty Half: Check her knee and breast
• Morgan Dollars: Inspect hair above the ear
• Buffalo Nickels: Focus on the animal’s hip

Run your (gloved!) fingertip gently across these spots. If they feel gritty instead of glass-smooth, it’s probably AU.

Common Newbie Mistakes to Avoid

Shiny Doesn’t Always Mean Valuable

I learned this the hard way with a polished Mercury dime. Remember:

• Original mint luster looks frosted, not mirror-bright
• Cleaned coins lose their natural glow
• Toning can hide wear – check under different lights

Don’t Get Distracted by Flaws

A Standing Liberty quarter taught me this lesson. Its fields looked perfect, but wear on the shield dropped it to AU58. Remember: scratches in empty areas matter less than friction on the design itself.

Your First Grading Session: Simple Steps

Step 1: Create Your Cheat Sheet

Start with these free resources:

• PCGS Photograde (your visual dictionary)
• Recent eBay sold listings (real-world examples)
• A dollar store magnifying glass (seriously!)

Step 2: The 5-Minute Coin Check

1. Front Inspection: 2 minutes on design high points
2. Back Inspection: 2 minutes with different light angles
3. Edge Check: 1 minute feeling for wear ridges

Step 3: Keep a Coin Journal

Start simple with notes like:

Coin: 1943 Steel Penny
Light Test: Broken shine on Lincoln's cheek
Touch Test: Smooth wheat stalks, rough jawline
Guess: AU55 - wear on high points

Real Success Stories

The Mercury Dime That Surprised Everyone

A collector nearly spent a 1942-S dime before noticing:

• Full detail on wheat stalks
• Buttery luster across the fields
• Almost invisible wear on Liberty’s cap

Graded MS62 after cleaning – tripling its value!

The Buffalo Nickel That Crossed Over

This 1936-D shows how close AU/MS can be:

• Sharp horn details but dull shoulder
• Frosty protected areas
• No visible rub under 10x

Upgraded to MS63 after reassessment.

When to Spend Money on Grading

From my experience grading hundreds of coins:

• Most AU coins stay AU – don’t get excited too fast
• The winners usually have:
  • Zero wear under 15x magnification
  • Even luster front and back
  • Crisper details than typical coins

You’ve Got This!

Remember that first coin I misgraded? Today it sits framed above my desk – not for its value, but as a reminder that every expert was once a beginner. Start with these steps:

1. Examine 5 coins from your pocket change tonight
2. Compare them to Photograde images
3. Pick your most promising coin to practice on

Grading isn’t about being perfect immediately. It’s about training your eyes to see what matters. What hidden treasure will you discover first?

Related Resources

You might also find these related articles helpful:

• Pearl Harbor’s Warning for Tech M&A: How Code Quality Audits Prevent Catastrophic Deal Failures – When Hidden Code Flaws Sink M&A Deals Imagine buying a promising tech company, only to discover their core systems …
• Pearl Harbor’s Strategic Lessons for Modern Tech Leadership: A CTO’s Guide to Resilient Systems – As a CTO, I live where technology meets business reality. Let me share how December 7, 1941 reshapes how we think about …
• Bust Coin Error Identification Showdown: I Tested 7 Diagnostic Methods to Reveal What Actually Works – My Hands-On Test of 7 Bust Coin Error Methods – The Surprising Winners After spending three months examining 43 bust coi…