Buried Treasure: How the S.S. Central America, Redfield & Saddle Ridge Hoards Changed Coin Collecting Forever — And What Salvers Know About Hoard Coins
May 5, 2026The Hidden History Behind the Garden State Coin, Stamp & Currency Show: A Numismatic Tradition in Parsippany, NJ
May 5, 2026Building a type set is the ultimate journey through history—and honestly, it’s the project that keeps me coming back to this hobby year after year. Let’s talk about how to represent each design in your collection the right way. Whether you’re a seasoned numismatist or just beginning to assemble your first album, the question of how to choose the right coin for each slot is one that defines the entire pursuit. After attending the Denver Coin Expo and soaking in the incredible atmosphere—130+ dealers, world-class rarities, and passionate collectors—I came away with renewed inspiration for how we approach the art of type collecting. In this post, I want to share my philosophy on building a type set that balances quality, budget, and historical significance, drawing on lessons from the show floor and decades of personal collecting experience.
What Is a Type Set and Why Does It Matter?
A type set, at its core, is a collection that aims to represent each distinct design, denomination, or major variety in American coinage—one example per type. Unlike a date set, where you chase every year and mint mark, a type set distills the hobby down to its most elegant form: one beautiful, representative coin for each design type. It’s the collector’s way of telling the complete story of American numismatic history, from the Flowing Hair half cent of 1793 to the modern Sacagawea dollar.
But here’s the critical question every type collector faces: which coin do you choose for each slot? That’s where the real art—and the real fun—begins. A recent trip to the Denver Coin Expo reminded me just how many decisions go into this process, and how the coins you encounter at shows can shape your entire approach.
The Role of Coin Shows in Type Set Building
Shows like the Denver Coin Expo are absolute treasure troves for type collectors. With 130+ dealers under one roof, the variety is staggering. I walked past tables displaying everything from common-date Wheat cents in rolls to breathtaking MS68 Buffalo Nickels with creamy, original luster. The energy is infectious—dealers and collectors trading stories, examining coins under magnification, and negotiating prices in real time.
For the type collector, shows offer something that online shopping simply cannot: the ability to compare coins side by side. When you’re trying to choose the best strike for a particular type, nothing beats holding two or three examples in your hand and evaluating them under good light. I’ve examined hundreds of Morgan dollars over the years, and I can tell you that the difference between a well-struck 1879-S in MS63 and a flatly struck example at the same grade is night and day. At a show, you can find that premium coin without paying a premium price—if you know what to look for.
What I Looked for at the Denver Expo
- Eye appeal above all else. A coin with original toning, strong luster, and minimal marks will always outshine a technically equivalent but lifeless example. This is the single most important factor in my type set decisions.
- Strike quality. Full details on the design elements—whether it’s the feather detail on a Buffalo Nickel or the hair strands on a Seated Liberty quarter—make a dramatic difference in how a type coin represents its design.
- Originality. I avoid coins that have been cleaned, whizzed, or otherwise altered. In my experience grading and evaluating coins over the years, original surfaces are non-negotiable for a serious type set. A coin’s patina tells its story—don’t let someone else rewrite it.
- Provenance and dealer reputation. Buying from established dealers at reputable shows reduces the risk of counterfeit or misrepresented coins. I always ask about a coin’s history when the price warrants it.
Choosing the Best Strike for Each Type
This is where type collecting becomes both a science and an art. Every coin design has its own strike characteristics, and understanding these nuances is essential for building a set you’ll be proud of. The numismatic value of a type coin isn’t just about the grade on the holder—it’s about how well that coin represents the designer’s original vision.
Understanding Strike by Design Type
Let’s break down some of the most common type set categories and what to look for in terms of strike:
- Large Cents (1793–1857): Early copper is notoriously difficult to find with sharp strikes. For types like the Draped Bust or Coronet designs, look for coins with full dentils and clear Liberty details. Weakness on the wreath reverse is common and often acceptable at lower grades—don’t let that stop you from filling the slot.
- Seated Liberty Coinage (1837–1891): The Seated Liberty design is notoriously unevenly struck. A well-struck Seated quarter or half dollar with full head and hand details on Liberty is worth seeking out. These coins command a significant premium over their weakly struck counterparts, and the difference in eye appeal is immediately obvious.
- Morgan Silver Dollars (1878–1921): The Morgan dollar is perhaps the most collected type in American numismatics. Look for full breast feathers on the eagle, sharp hair strands above Liberty’s ear, and minimal bag marks in the central devices. Coins from the Carson City mint often exhibit softer strikes, so adjust your expectations accordingly—but don’t settle for a mushy example if you can help it.
- Buffalo Nickels (1913–1938): Strike is everything with Buffalo Nickels. A Type 1 with a fully defined horn and clear date is worth multiples of a weakly struck example. I saw a stunning MS68 Buffalo at the Denver show with creamy, original surfaces—the kind of coin that makes you rethink your entire budget. That’s the power of a great strike.
- Indian Head $10 Gold Eagles (1907–1933): The Saint-Gaudens double eagle and the Indian Head eagle both reward collectors who prioritize sharp strikes. Look for full feather detail on the Indian’s headdress and a well-defined Liberty torch. In mint condition, these coins are among the most beautiful ever produced—and a sharp strike is what separates a good example from a great one.
The “Best Strike” Philosophy
My personal philosophy is simple: for each type slot, acquire the best-struck example you can afford. This doesn’t always mean the highest grade. I would rather own a beautifully struck VF-30 early type coin than a flatly struck MS-63. The strike tells the story of the design far more eloquently than the grade alone. When I look at my own set, the coins that make me smile aren’t always the highest-graded ones—they’re the ones with the most character, the sharpest details, and the strongest eye appeal.
Dansco Albums: The Type Collector’s Best Friend
No discussion of type set building is complete without mentioning Dansco albums. For decades, Dansco has been the gold standard for type set collectors, and for good reason. Their albums are thoughtfully designed, well-constructed, and organized in a way that makes building a type set both logical and visually satisfying. If you’re serious about type collecting, a Dansco album isn’t just a storage solution—it’s the framework for your entire collection.
Why Dansco Stands Out
- Comprehensive coverage. Dansco offers albums for virtually every major U.S. type set, from classic albums covering half cents through double eagles to specialized albums for gold type sets, commemoratives, and modern issues. Whatever your focus, there’s an album for it.
- Quality construction. The leatherette binders, clear Mylar slides, and labeled slots make it easy to display and protect your coins. After years of use, my Dansco albums still look presentable on the shelf—and that matters when you want to share your collection with others.
- Logical organization. Dansco arranges coins chronologically by type, which helps you visualize the evolution of American coinage as you fill each slot. It’s like watching history unfold, one coin at a time.
- Flexibility. The slide-in system allows you to upgrade coins easily. When you find a better example at a show—like the incredible coins I saw at the Denver Expo—you can swap it in without disturbing the rest of your set. This is huge for type collectors who are always chasing improvement.
Recommended Dansco Albums for Type Collectors
- Dansco 7760: U.S. Type Coin Album (Half Cents through Silver Dollars)—the classic starter album and the foundation of most type sets.
- Dansco 7765: Gold Type Coin Album—perfect for the collector who wants to represent every gold design type, from the tiny gold dollar to the mighty double eagle.
- Dansco 7770: Commemorative Type Album—often overlooked, but commemorative half dollars and silver dollars represent some of the most beautiful designs in American coinage. This album is a hidden gem.
- Dansco 7775: Modern Type Album—for collectors who want to extend their set through the Eisenhower dollar, Susan B. Anthony, Sacagawea, and Presidential dollars. Don’t skip the modern era just because it’s recent.
One tip from my own experience: buy the album before you start filling it. Having the empty slots in front of you is incredibly motivating. Every empty hole is a challenge, and every coin you slide in is a small victory. I’ve seen collectors at shows like the Denver Expo walk away with a single coin that fills a gap they’ve been hunting for months—there’s no feeling quite like it. The collectibility of a type set isn’t just in the coins themselves; it’s in the pursuit.
Budget vs. High-End Type Collecting: Finding Your Sweet Spot
This is the question that every type collector wrestles with: how much should I spend on each coin? The answer depends entirely on your goals, your budget, and your definition of “complete.” There’s no single right approach—and that’s part of what makes this hobby so accessible.
The Budget Approach: Building a Circulated Type Set
There is absolutely nothing wrong with building a type set in circulated grades. In fact, I’d argue it’s one of the most rewarding ways to collect. Here’s why:
- Affordability. A complete U.S. type set in Fine to Very Fine grades can be assembled for a few thousand dollars—a fraction of what a mint state set would cost. You don’t need deep pockets to build something meaningful.
- Historical character. Circulated coins have stories to tell. Each wear mark represents decades of commerce, of hands exchanging goods, of history being made. There’s a provenance to that wear that no mint state coin can replicate.
- Accessibility. Common-date type coins in circulated grades are abundant at shows, in OBW rolls, and in dealer bargain bins. I picked up several OBW rolls at the Denver show that will yield excellent type set candidates—sometimes the best finds are hiding in plain sight.
- Focus on design. In lower grades, you’re forced to evaluate the design itself rather than getting distracted by minutiae of grade. This can actually make you a better numismatist. You learn to appreciate the artistry, not just the technical specs.
For budget collectors, I recommend targeting the following grades by era:
- Early types (pre-1830): Good to Very Good. These coins are expensive in any grade, and a well-worn but problem-free example is a perfectly respectable type representative. Don’t let perfection be the enemy of completion.
- Mid-19th century types (1830–1900): Fine to Extremely Fine. This is the sweet spot where detail is still strong but prices remain reasonable. You’ll find plenty of options at this level.
- 20th century types (1900–1964): Extremely Fine to About Uncirculated. These coins are plentiful in high circulated grades, and the jump to AU is often minimal in cost. This is where budget collectors can really shine.
- Modern types (1965–present): Mint State. Modern coins are so affordable in high grades that there’s no reason to settle for less. Fill these slots with confidence.
The High-End Approach: Chasing Premium Quality
At the other end of the spectrum, high-end type collecting is a pursuit of excellence. Collectors in this category seek out coins at the top of the population report—MS66, MS67, and even MS68 examples with exceptional eye appeal. The coins I saw at the Denver Expo, including that breathtaking MS68 Buffalo Nickel and the colorful 1879-S Morgan dollar, represent this tier of collecting. These are coins that stop you in your tracks.
Here’s what high-end type collectors should keep in mind:
- Population reports matter. Before buying, check the PCGS and NGC population reports to understand how rare a coin is in your target grade. A coin that’s common in MS63 but rare in MS66 may be worth the premium—especially if it’s a rare variety with strong collectibility.
- Eye appeal is king. At the high end, the difference between a “generic” MS66 and a “blazer” MS66 can be thousands of dollars. Coins with original toning, exceptional luster, and strong strikes command significant premiums. I’ve seen two coins with the same grade differ in price by a factor of ten—all because of eye appeal.
- Certification is essential. For high-end type coins, always buy certified by PCGS or NGC. The peace of mind is worth the grading fee. When you’re spending serious money, you need that third-party assurance.
- Patience pays off. High-end coins don’t appear every day. It may take months or years to find the right example for a particular type slot. Shows like the Denver Expo, with their concentration of quality dealers, are ideal hunting grounds. But don’t rush—the right coin will come along.
The Middle Ground: A Hybrid Approach
My personal recommendation—and the approach I follow—is a hybrid strategy. For common types where high-grade examples are affordable (like Mercury dimes, Washington quarters, and Buffalo nickels), I aim for mint state. For rare and expensive types (like early gold or Seated Liberty dollars), I’m happy with a beautifully circulated example. This approach lets you build a set that’s both impressive and financially sustainable. It also keeps the hunt interesting—you’re always making decisions, always weighing trade-offs, always learning.
Lessons from the Denver Coin Expo: Practical Takeaways
Reflecting on my experience at the Denver show, here are the key takeaways I’d offer to fellow type collectors:
- Shows are for upgrading. Use shows to find coins that are better than what you already have. The ability to compare multiple examples in person is invaluable—something no website or auction catalog can replicate.
- Bring a want list. Know which type slots you’re trying to fill or upgrade. It’s easy to get distracted (I forgot to take photos of the entire event because I was so absorbed in looking at coins!). A want list keeps you focused and prevents impulse buys that don’t serve your set.
- Network with dealers and fellow collectors. I ran into fellow Denver Coin Club members, ANACS graders, and dealers I’ve known for decades. These relationships are the backbone of the hobby. A dealer who knows your type set goals will call you when the right coin comes in.
- Don’t overlook the “small” purchases. OBW rolls, raw coins in dealer boxes, and bargain-bin finds can yield surprising type set candidates. Some of my best coins came from unassuming sources. The collectibility of a coin isn’t determined by the price tag it’s sitting under.
- Take photos and notes. Document what you see at shows. Even if you don’t buy, the visual reference helps you recognize quality when you encounter it again. I wish I’d done more of this at the Denver Expo—lessons learned for next time.
Actionable Tips for Your Next Show Visit
Here’s a checklist for type collectors heading to their next coin show:
- Bring a loupe (10x minimum) and a small LED light for examining coins. Good lighting makes all the difference when evaluating luster and surface quality.
- Carry a printed or digital copy of your type set checklist so you know exactly which slots need filling. There’s nothing worse than getting home and realizing you passed on a coin you needed.
- Set a budget before you arrive and stick to it—show fever is real. I’ve been there. The excitement of a busy bourse floor can make you loosen your wallet faster than you’d expect.
- Prioritize coins with original surfaces over coins with high grades but questionable history. A cleaned coin in MS65 will never have the eye appeal or long-term value of an original AU58.
- Talk to dealers about what they specialize in. Many will set aside type coins for regular customers. Building that relationship is one of the most valuable things you can do as a collector.
- Consider submitting raw coins for grading at show services like ANACS, PCGS, or NGC if they’re on-site. It’s a great way to get coins certified while you’re still in the buying mood—and you might discover a rare variety in the process.
The Bigger Picture: Why Type Sets Endure
In a hobby that can sometimes feel overwhelming—with thousands of dates, mint marks, VAM varieties, and die states to chase—the type set offers clarity and focus. It’s a collection that tells the complete story of American coinage in a manageable, beautiful, and deeply personal way. Every coin in your Dansco album represents a chapter in that story: the evolution of our nation’s artistic ideals, its economic history, and its technological progress.
The Denver Coin Expo reminded me why I fell in love with this hobby in the first place. Walking among 130+ dealers, seeing coins that span two and a half centuries of American history, and sharing that experience with fellow collectors—it doesn’t get better than that. Whether you’re building a budget set in circulated grades or chasing MS67 gems, the journey is the reward. The numismatic value of a type set isn’t measured in dollars—it’s measured in the knowledge you gain, the relationships you build, and the history you preserve.
Conclusion: Your Type Set, Your Legacy
Building a type set is one of the most rewarding pursuits in all of numismatics. It combines historical knowledge, aesthetic judgment, financial planning, and the thrill of the hunt into a single, cohesive project. The coins you choose—whether a well-circulated Large Cent or a blazing MS68 Buffalo Nickel—reflect your personal taste, your budget, and your vision of what American coinage represents.
Shows like the Denver Coin Expo are where these decisions come to life. They’re where you find that perfect coin to fill a slot, where you learn from dealers and fellow collectors, and where you reconnect with the passion that drew you to this hobby in the first place. So the next time you attend a show, bring your want list, sharpen your eye, and remember: every coin you add to your type set is a piece of history that you’re preserving for future generations.
Happy collecting, and may every slot in your Dansco album find its perfect coin.
Related Resources
You might also find these related articles helpful:
- Buried Treasure: How the S.S. Central America, Redfield & Saddle Ridge Hoards Changed Coin Collecting Forever — And What Salvers Know About Hoard Coins – Some of the finest known examples of certain coins spent centuries underwater or buried in bank vaults. Let me take you …
- How a 2026 Dime Roll Giveaway Can Spark a Lifelong Love of History in Your Children – Holding a piece of history in your hand is still the single best way I know to make the past come alive for a kid. As
- Grading Breakdown: The Difference Between $10 and $1,000 — Was That Nickel Caused by Grease, a Double Strike, or Die Deterioration? – Condition is everything. Let me show you exactly how to read the high points and fields on a coin like this to nail down…